Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

Rohan vs Gondor

#1Jase  Jun 15 2008, 09:28 AM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
This game was quite good loads of mistakes on my side, should have finished him sooner but oh well. Alot of running during early-mid game but during the late stages things got quite good and exciting, with a few battles Trebs vs HA's Ara and Theo. Watch to find out more.
#2Church  Jun 15 2008, 10:32 AM -
can i claim this for review?
#3Jase  Jun 15 2008, 13:30 PM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
Up too you. ^^
#4Pallando  Jun 15 2008, 13:39 PM -
Oh, a new RR contender w00t.gif eyebrow.gif ?
#5BcVcB  Jun 15 2008, 14:47 PM -

Replays: 46 Game:
Awards:
QUOTE
can i claim this for review?


Please wait with your 2nd application review until after you got feedback for your 1st one to prevent that you do same mistakes again.
Once you've gotten feedback for your 1st one you can of course review this unless it's already reviewed by someone else.

Good luck with your application smile.gif
#6Church  Jun 18 2008, 06:59 AM -
Review by: ChurchMan

[b]Starting positions:

Rohan/Despair|n|peace/Team1 - South
Gondor/OHIHO/Team2 - North

Overview:
This was an alright game played by both players. In my opinion gondor should have won considering he had such early GTW. Despair took a bit to long to finish game, could have been won much earlier with entmoot. This replays is quite good to see a aragorn vs treb ownage.

Rohan/Despair|n|peace/Team1
Very good start on game , you harassed his farms well, and some early creeping put you ahead. Your later game wasn't as good the game shoudl have been finshed by you alot earlier. I liked the aragorn and horse micro against the trebs, heres some points for next time:
  • quicker upgrades instead of horse archers would have given you a more of an upperhand.
  • quicker theo at start would have been good to get creeps and then gc.
  • if in that situation you should have gone quick ent moot.

Gondor/OHIHO/Team2
You didn't do the best in early game, you didnt attack farms but took 1 creep which didnt help too much. As the game went on you got better with a bit more harrassment. Your plan for early gandie was good but u needed more horses before trebs so you can overpower rohan and make him hide. A few tips for next time:
  • harass farms in ealry game
  • your pippin shoudl defend your farms
  • more horses after gandie maybe another 2 batalions
  • quicker horse shields would have helped against the horse archers.
This post has been edited by Sebbra: Jun 23 2008, 15:55 PM
#7Pallando  Jun 18 2008, 11:11 AM -
A bit to short tbh sad.gif .
#8BcVcB  Jun 18 2008, 12:28 PM -

Replays: 46 Game:
Awards:
QUOTE
A bit to short tbh sad.gif .


Lol, Pallari you're not the SRR and if you're so good at reviewing why don't you apply yourself? tongue.gif

Good job killing all those trebs in late game, Jase, wp thum.gif
#9Church  Jun 18 2008, 21:29 PM -
thanks for deleting other posts

this ones shorter casue sebra wanted me to change format
#10Jase  Jun 20 2008, 19:39 PM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
cheers mate
Reply to Comment