Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] [Review] Gondor vs Rohan

#1Jase  Jun 5 2007, 21:00 PM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
This game was very stupid in the end 1/4 off gtw pp and i couldnt get it so i just wanna know how i can improve on this game thanks jase! i lost this one




Review by: whersmyspacebar

Starting Positions:
^S1N1ST3R^ - Right
TheNr1Noob - Left


Overview:
A quite short Gondor vs Rohan on a rather Rohan favoured map, a good peasant spam type thing giving Rohan the early advantage and taking 3 out of 4 of the creeps. Both players going ups rush then Rohan Getting theo and Gondor getting GtG due to Rohan keeping pps down very well. Rohan getting ents with the FU rohhirim Ara, eowyn, eomer and theo proving to much for the Gondor to handle but it could have all been different if the Gondor got the pps for GTW abit unlucky to not only really needed 1 or 2 more horse kills.

^S1N1ST3R^ - Gondor
A ok start from u but you always need to heal when there is 4 soldiers left you accidently missed the heal timing, the ok start kinda slipped while u were building the stable due to u looseing farms from peasants and u had nothing to defend with which wasn’t your fault but maybe concider a more defencive start on this map because its hard to attack a Rohan because there is so many places to spam peasants from and they get to u so quick. Some good hobbit micro helped you but you should have run for the bottom left farm earlier instead of targeting his hobbit. When your first knights came out you went for the creep but I think maybe ignoreing the Rohhirim and killing the lair was a better option because you had heal and you lost the fight to the rohhirim anyway. During the battle for MC you didn’t engage anough rohhirim, on this map u always are gonna struggle to get GTW vs good players so it’s the little things that count. When you got GtG you didn’t use him at all you could have gone out with heal and Istari lighted from just infront of the postern gate then run back which could have got u the pps for GTW. When defending from the ents I think GtG on the wall would have been a good idea you could Istart 1 of the ents or Lightning either would have atleast killed the ent if it was at half health which this 1 was, when he came into your base you healed your Knights when it was obvious they wouldn’t survive vs the FU rohhirim with Ara and theoden LD healing gandywas a better idea.

Tips for Improvement:• Heal when u have 4 left in a battalion not 3
• Don’t just leave lair money that they have missed.
• Occasionally there were un upped rohhirim around you should have targeted them.
• Engage more rohhirim even if you cant win because u can just keep getting heals.
• Be braver with Gandy.

TheNr1Noob - Rohan

A strong start from you, you got all 5 of the available farms before his first Knight, your creeping was very good taking 3 out of the 4 avalable but always make sure u get all the lair money. You did very well in the fight for MC getting ups before the Gondor and didn’t pp feed him which ended up winning you the game. You had a few moments where u forgot to upgrade your rohhirim and was still aggressive with them which might PP feed them but he didn’t realize which was lucky. I think u weiged your situation very well deciding to take extra time with the enting making a stronger army adding Aragorn, eowyn and eomer where were useful. You attack was smooth but you kept giving Faramir pot shots which could have turned out giving him GTW but luckily it didn’t. Some good army micro in the attack combined with army strength killing Gondors GTW which made him quit

Tips for Improvement:

• Don’t forget to upgrade all your rohhirim.
• Collect all lair money.
• Use eomer more, you should have been chasing knights instead of standing at the postern gate.
• Run from hobbits with sword not rock.

Overall rating: 5
This post has been edited by whersmyspacebar: Jun 10 2007, 10:41 AM
#2whersmyspacebar  Jun 8 2007, 10:44 AM -
Awards:
Tagged.
#3whersmyspacebar  Jun 10 2007, 10:40 AM -
Awards:
Replay reviewed, sorry 4 the wait smile.gif .
This post has been edited by whersmyspacebar: Jun 10 2007, 10:40 AM
#4Jase  Jun 10 2007, 18:07 PM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
thanks for the review mate biggrin.gif
Reply to Comment