Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] Rohan vs Gondor

#1Jase  Mar 27 2007, 15:21 PM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
I thought this was a gg on my newest Rohan name this guy did a weird strat anyway thanks for review if any can ^^

thanks in advance

[attachmentid=226670]

Review by: Thrandy

Starting positions:
(Gondor) agirbmol - West
(Rohan) MoTw|Numenorion - East

Overview:

Both players played pretty well but the strats were very standard, there were no actual fights and it was a little one sided so the entertainment value is low.


Gondor Commentary:

Start was pretty average due to micro. Don't cloak Pippin at a farm, especially on this map because Rohan will be spamming everywhere and you need early game defense while your soldiers are harassing/defending elsewhere. Again, this map is too big to go for a Faramir rush. He was useless. You could've taken out Rohan's peasants just as easily with some knights and you couldn't do any useful creeping without those horses. I suggest to stay with the three knights --> ups strategy for early game and then you decide what strat you want to go for when your status is decided in mid game. So since you had no map control Rohan got the ent moot very early and you were totally unprepared for it.

Tips for Improvement:
  • When Ents are storming your base, be sure to move your heroes a little bit right as the Ents try to hit them. If you move at the right time then the Ents' hits will miss and you can get a few more shots in before you have to dodge again.
  • Harass the opponent more, especially on this map. If you had the correct start, as described, then you wouldn't have been on the defensive the whole match.
Rohan Commentary:

Pretty much a flawless game here considering your opponent never made any aggressive moves. Creeping was good, peasant harassment was good, etc. Even though you got caught up at that one warg lair and Gondor's knights beat you off, that looked like lag on your part. Nothing to really comment on though, got Ents quickly and used them nicely.

Tips for Improvement:
  • Might wanna be a bit more aware of your rohirrim while you are setting up an Ent rush. You almost lost a batt or two due to getting caught between lair wargs and Gondor's knights.
Overall Rating: 3
This post has been edited by Thrandy: Mar 29 2007, 22:06 PM
#2Thrandy  Mar 28 2007, 21:40 PM -
Replays: 6 Game:
Awards:
Replay reviewed. smile.gif
This post has been edited by Thrandy: Mar 29 2007, 22:05 PM
Reply to Comment