Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[Review]Gondor vs Rohan

#1Jase  Jun 23 2007, 21:49 PM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
This involved micro + skill, heroes used from Rohan like Lego,Theo,Eomer and Eowyn very interesting how they were used.
rohan took a early outpost without me knowing as MC was hard to keep, when gandi came out they were parts where i thought i would lose him but i kept my cool. No laming from SW/Trebs inside base as i've stoped that nonsense.


All in all a very gg enjoy ! plz tell me if i laid the topic description out right thanks jase
This post has been edited by ^JASOMAST3R^: Jun 23 2007, 21:49 PM
#2FarMeR`  Jun 23 2007, 21:54 PM -
Replays: 30 Game:
Awards:
QUOTE(^JASOMAST3R^)
No laming from SW/Trebs inside base as i've stoped that nonsense.

Good boy.
#3Jase  Jun 23 2007, 22:51 PM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
biggrin.gif
#4whersmyspacebar  Jun 24 2007, 01:56 AM -
Awards:
Jase u wont get topics locked for putting [Review] after the name but u might aswell put the [Review] at the front instead of the back.
#5BcVcB  Jun 24 2007, 12:39 PM -

Replays: 46 Game:
Awards:
good game! thumb.gif
Some nice hero kills by Gondor and a good rush thum.gif But you made some outposts that you couldn't protect in early/mid-game. And why did you replace a farm with a BS when you already had 6 BSs?
#6Jase  Jun 24 2007, 16:05 PM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
mmm, BS's r stronger thats why i did it
This post has been edited by ^JASOMAST3R^: Jun 24 2007, 17:06 PM
#7EV1L  Jun 26 2007, 11:15 AM -
Replays: 46 Game:
Awards:
Tagged ! wub.gif rolleyes.gif
#8EV1L  Jun 26 2007, 13:50 PM -
Replays: 46 Game:
Awards:
[indent]review by: EVIL

^S1N1ST3R^ [Gondor] - North
Despair|n|Peace [Rohan] - South

Overview:

Gondor started with a bs -> stable wich was very good because he had his first horse only a sec later out then rohan thumb.gif . rohan made 2 farms -> stable. a few good fights. mid game gondor lost mc, but he brought gandy wich was a turnaround, and only becuz good gandy micro u won the game thumb.gif


^S1N1ST3R^ [Gondor]

ur bs -> stable worked very good because you had your first horse only a sec later out then rohan thumb.gif
u didnt get enough creeps 3/8 what was a bit low: a bit better micro couldve bring u the troll creeps 2. U got fb wich is normally used to get MC till gandy, this didnt work though cuz he had eomer and he ranked like a ( u know sleep.gif ) luckily for u not further then rank 3.75. u tried 2 get an outpost wher u would build stats, but it was all thrown away cash beceause u couldnt defend it well ( this happend 2 times cry.gif ) when u gandy came the game made a turnaround and u killed alot of heros wink.gif u made 2 outposts, 1 in north west and 1 in south west. on the northwest side u build nothing.. huh.gif ... watch that better next time. on the southwest u made workshop and archery range -> 4 trebs -> 4 archers + fu ( both) and attacked his base. when the last fight came u won it with good gandy micro ( like whole game) got eagles and gg!

- If u buy an outpost, take care that u can defend it well!
- Try 2 get more creeps!
- U had no advantage of Fb, if u didnt bought them u had gandy earlier, or u go all ups bef4 gandy!
- The outpost without buildings cry.gif keep watching whole the map!

Despair|n|Peace [Rohan]

Ur early game wasnt fantastic, u lost the early fight, although u maneged 2 keep ur farms alive. ur horse micro in mid game was gr8, u got alot of the creeps thumb.gif u get a extra outpost wich brought u xtra money and a well. u made eomer theoden ther what brought u MC for alot of time, when gandy came u started 2 lose more and more, and beceause bad hero micro u didnt managed 2 kill gandy once! meanwhile in ur base, u made ups and an archery range.. u bought 3 yeomens but u didnt buy fu so that building stands ther useless WTF.gif u tried 2 kill gandy whole mid game, but he only killed horses and heros from u post-13661-1143531603.gif . when he attacked ur base u already lost. remember this, if eagles are used put ur important heros in building because ur ara died very easy because of eagles, heros are very vurnerable 2 eagles. imo i recommend no yeomen or later RA but more heros like ara, gimli, when gandy come all use special, if gandy's dead immediatly ent his camp and his cita!

- Work on ur early game, it can help u alot!
- Watch out that ur heros dont stay behind! ( hero micro)
- Try more heros and kill gandy, because hes the key, without him gondor hasnt got alot 2 defend, ent him directly after!



Overall rating: 6
#9LastGenesis  Jun 28 2007, 02:37 AM -
Replays: 2 Game:
Awards:
Alright mate someone will give you a more in depth review of your review but here are just a few things that i would like to comment on. smile.gif

QUOTE(EV1L @ Jun 26 2007, 06:50 AM) *

- Work on ur early game, it can help u alot!

- Try 2 get more creeps!


Go more in depth into this, tell him what he could do better to get more creeps. And tell him what he needs to do improve his early game.

QUOTE(EV1L @ Jun 26 2007, 06:50 AM) *

- U had no advantage of Fb, if u didnt bought them u had gandy earlier, or u go all ups bef4 gandy!

This is not necessarily true, it could allow him to win fights where eomer was not involved thus making him micro his eomer better, and you dont have to go all ups before gandy if you get fb.

The other thing is the rating is a bit too high imo, having not seen this game I cant make any final decisions or anything but from what the review says and just looking at the type of game it seems to be i would put this more at a 5 at best. Also try and use fewer abbreviations, things like fb or RA are fine when your talking about units or upgrades since the majority of ppl will know what your talking about. But try and actually write out things like, great and you to make it look better. thumb.gif

#10EV1L  Jun 28 2007, 06:57 AM -
Replays: 46 Game:
Awards:
k thx.. wub.gif
Reply to Comment