Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] Gondor vs Rohan

#1Jase  Dec 22 2006, 11:07 AM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
ok here it is SONIC|BOOM vs ^S1N1ST3R^ gg in all ownage game till someone comes biggrin.gif review would be appreciated if any could give up there time thanks Sinister
This post has been edited by ^S1N1ST3R^: Dec 22 2006, 11:07 AM
#2THUGZ  Dec 23 2006, 14:04 PM -
Replays: 36 Game:
Awards:
Sonic here on thugs account. Tbh i cant believe u posted this game. You won fairly but it was hardly epic. Any other day things might of turned out diffrent but as soon as gondor lame the white its not hard to win. Anyways gg but not worth review cos its only bout 20 mins long.
#3esa|TurtleTucke  Dec 23 2006, 14:17 PM -
Replays: 43 Game:
Awards:
I dunno much about this mu but i played some games and i really thought that this game isnt as imba as all ppl say sad.gif Rohan gets Rohirrim faster and they only coast 450. THey can creep alot faster and they will get mc if they go 4 Rohirrim. Also once they get ara + theo + fu rohirrim its hard to do anything with gandi. THan they can get ents and gondor cant do much with gandi imo. Tell me if i am wrong laugh.gif
#4Philmightyone  Dec 23 2006, 16:13 PM -
Replays: 3 Game:
QUOTE(esa|TurtleTucke @ Dec 23 2006, 02:17 PM) *
I dunno much about this mu but i played some games and i really thought that this game isnt as imba as all ppl say sad.gif Rohan gets Rohirrim faster and they only coast 450. THey can creep alot faster and they will get mc if they go 4 Rohirrim. Also once they get ara + theo + fu rohirrim its hard to do anything with gandi. THan they can get ents and gondor cant do much with gandi imo. Tell me if i am wrong laugh.gif


Have got any replays of you as Rohan beating pro Gondor players, preferably on maps other than FoI?

If you have I will watch with great interest. What you say sounds good in theory but....
#5Jase  Dec 23 2006, 20:37 PM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
beat him on fangorn also so any other day not really its very easy with gondor anyway it was a ggbye
#6Mad^Monkey  Dec 24 2006, 11:19 AM -
After watching the rep i thought gondor had an easy time, no peasant spam and harrassment, not enough rohirrim to creep and get map which handed the game to gondor.
#7THUGZ  Dec 24 2006, 12:59 PM -
Replays: 36 Game:
Awards:
sinister u have a silly attitude imo. who r u btw since copied my name? tongue.gif
#8Gamroth  Dec 24 2006, 15:53 PM -
Awards:
I'll take for my 3rd application review as i havnt covered this MU yet happy.gif
#9Gamroth  Dec 24 2006, 17:49 PM -
Awards:
3rd Application Review by Gamroth:

^S1N1ST3R^ (Gondor) vs SONIC|B00M (Rohan)
Map: West Emnet

^S1N1ST3R^ (Gondor)
BO/Strat: Bs, Farm, Pippin -> Stables -> Knights -> Gandalf -> more Knights + Upgrades + HS
PP: Heal -> GtW -> EW
Creeps: 3/8

Pros:
+ Protected farms from peasant rush
+ crept trolls with 2 knights (luring troll away with 1 and killing lair with the other)
+ Good uses of LS - killed Lego in early game and Eomer later on
+ bought more knights to regain MC

+/- sacrificed a knight batt to kill troll lair. This would not usually be worth it but it got you the PP required for GtW so i'll let you off laugh.gif

Positive Comments:
After struggling a bit early game, Gandalf came at just the right time for you. You were just starting to get pinned into your base. Once Gandalf arrived however, you turned the game around and using Gandalfs powers very effectively, you won the game. GJ.

Cons:
- misjudged statue building slightly - start building earlier
- losing knights to lego + eomer, but as i said above you got the PP so...

Negative Comments/Points for improvement:
You played a very solid game, not much you can do to improve. Just try and be a bit quicker with your creeping, you were lucky to get GtW PP in this game. Very well played however.

Player Rating: 7


SONIC|B00M (Rohan)

BO/Strat: Farm, Merry -> Stables -> Rohirrim -> Statues -> Theo -> Eomer -> Lego -> Eowyn -> Upgrades
PP: Draft -> Heal -> EW
Creeps: 5/8

Pros:
+ stole a warg creep from knights
+ good creeping overall
+ combined use of Lego (HS) and Eomer (Spear) to finish off a batt of Knights

Positive Comments:
A nice early game from you, took most of the creeps and had good MC. You were starting to lock Gondor into their base with your superior horses and heroes.

Cons:
- relativaly poor peasant spam - accomplished nothing really
- didn't give warg lair to theo despite him being nearby
- lost your heroes a few times
- didn't notice your opponent laying over your EW (neither did i the first time i watched tongue.gif)

Negative Comments/Points for improvement:
Try to be more effective with your initial peasant rush - either send peasants forward together and aim to kill one of his farms, or send 1/2 forwards to distract him (run around and make him follow) while another group of 3 with Merry start creeping (on this map you could also start creeping with Merry and 1 peasant - goblins). You were unable to stop Gandalf, and from this ultimately lost the game. Whenever they get Gandalf out try to aim for Aragorn asap, However this was difficult for you as you were already replacing the heroes that you lost.

Player Rating: 5

Game summary:
An entertaining Gondor vs Rohan were Rohan uses a different strat from the one usually seen. Rohan was ontop until GtW arrived and Rohan was not able to produce a sufficent counter to Gandalf. GG guys thumb.gif

Overall Game Rating: 6
Entertainment: 6








#10Krys1er  Dec 24 2006, 17:50 PM -
Replays: 22 Game:
its jase..
Reply to Comment