Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] [Review]Gondor vs Rohan

#1Jase  May 24 2007, 11:17 AM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
Hi all, im trying to improve my skills with Gondor at the current moment so i need advice so i can improve vs Rohan, this game basically was short but i am not camping with gon no more and i gotta find away to beat this MC type of game. Fair enough it lagged so i coudnt do as good but no excuses for this performance, i defended ents they took 2 walls down then i tried to save for gtw but didnt work so i lost in the end post-13661-1143531603.gif
Thanks Jase
critcism of the game is ok just gotta get good in this MU
#2whersmyspacebar  Jun 2 2007, 00:34 AM -
Awards:
Ill review this as my 3rd review application smile.gif .
#3PuReBuRn  Jun 2 2007, 01:20 AM -
Replays: 16 Game:
Awards:
Jase:"I quit bfme, full time rofwkfor me"

wink.gif

does this mean ur playing more bfme now J ohmy.gif
banana.gif banana.gif banana.gif
#4whersmyspacebar  Jun 2 2007, 01:32 AM -
Awards:
Review by: whersmyspacebar

Starting Positions:

[EFF]WinRy - left
[BD]BattleWar - right

Overview:
A quick paced and entertaining Rohan vs Gondor with Gondor heavily on the backfoot after a failed ent rush. Rohan then attacks after with FU rohhirim and theo and this proves to much for Gondor.

[EFF]WinRy – Rohan

A very strong start from you, you managed to get both Gondor farms down by doing a clever start with peasants and defending with merry very effectively. Your Merry micro was exceptional managing to save your farms against pippin and 1 bat of soldiers. You had very fast rohhirim after 2 farms in and 2 out and you creeped quick as possible getting 5/6 of the creeps which is very impressive. You then went theo when I think maybe ups would have been better but making theo paid off very well and strait after u went ent rush and managed to break down the wall then with FU rohhirim and theo finished him off.

Tips for Improvement:
• Ups instead of Theoden is probably a better option seeing as he wouldn’t have had power points for GTW.
• Don’t heal horses when they aren’t in battle go 2 the well instead.
• Don’t leave Theoden so open in battle if Fara targeted him he would have died.
• Don’t place EW when Gondor will definitely have it.

[BD]BattleWar – Gondor

You hade a pretty bad start because its hard to micro hobbits on their host, and when your soldiers where fighting the peasants they got stuck and didn’t do anything and it took u a while to realize. You didn’t manage to creep very well because your horses came so late and u left them stationary for quite a while u need to set a rally point for your horses at the gate so they r always moving. U did extremely well defending from the ent rush, good idea getting Fara and Blades but after that attack u really needed to get heavy armour so that u could 1v1 the rohhirim when theo wasn’t around. After the ent rush u couldn’t withstand the FU rohhirim and theo but I think if u had have used faramir and your knights to target theo u could have killed him and maybe had a change in the battle.

Tips for Improvement:
• Ignore hobbits if they aren’t attacking u.
• Always keep and eye on your soldiers.
• Set a rally point for your stable at the gate.
• Don’t trample peasants in wedge.
• Needed armor because u didn’t really have much chance of getting GTW.
• Use fara and knights to target theoden.

Overall Rating: 5 was a good game to watch, Jase defended well smile.gif .
This post has been edited by whersmyspacebar: Jun 2 2007, 01:33 AM
#5Jase  Jun 2 2007, 12:03 PM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
ty for the review smile.gif
#6LastGenesis  Jun 6 2007, 18:11 PM -
Replays: 2 Game:
Awards:
For future reference jase when you post a rep put [Review] in front of the topic title instead of in the topic description to make it easier for us RR's. smile.gif
#7Jase  Jun 6 2007, 18:35 PM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
k npz ty
Reply to Comment