Battle for Middle Earth

We've just started a game, Rohan Isen mirror was it. I disconnected when I didn't even know their MU. I saw Isen, then I dc'd. Now they want us to report, and I really would like to know if we have to report it. I saw that he was Rohan in the statistic screen...

	RohanIsenMirror.rep
	Size: 9.58k
	Number of downloads: 0
	Player Name	Side	Team
	TT|Ermmmmm		1
	TT|HowardDonald		1
	Khazad|Owns^U		2
	Khazad|Az0G*		2

The disconnector must report according to the cw rules.
But some consider it as Bad Sportsmanship to insist on reporting when the game wasnt decided yet...

Report, its not my fault you keep dcing....

This post has been edited by Dogs: Nov 5 2009, 20:34 PM

hmm whay did you dc lol?
you cant report it coz cw.cc dont work and wont work thill they find money to fix it witch wont be that soon imo

well duh lol no one can report right now

Yes, you have to. All games have to be reported once both teams met each other. You're partner could have played on though. If he left or lost, you indeed have to report. If both teams agree on no report an exception can be made of course, but if not, then not.

Always keep in mind, not reporting is never the way to go. You better report a game and AM after, if you think something was unfair or whatever.

Maybe you don't have when CW stays down...

This post has been edited by Miho: Nov 5 2009, 20:39 PM

If you dc'd a lot of times, then I can see an insistance to report. As Miho said, just file an AM with the rep after reporting.

kk np, we just wanted to know what the rules say!
ive noted it and will report if cw goes up ever again

Problem is, most clans are online after 6 oclock and that's exactly the time I start disconnecting. I start games, enjoy hard games, then suddenly I dc and it pisses me off if the game was exciting and good to this point. If the enemy then tell me to report it's even more frustrating. I don't want to stop cw now because of that, but I'm only bringing losses to our team this way..

does suck indeed, theirs no way you can fix it?

No, I can be happy that I even have internet

Neighbours can't get an internet for whatever reason, we tried things out on our router already but my dad has the last word and he is satisfied with it because he doesn't use the Internet much so they won't change it so fast.

This post has been edited by Pallando: Nov 5 2009, 21:49 PM

u should ask them if they mean to report a game if u dc before starting cw. if they want to apply the rules at any cost (lame) then u can decide if u want to play or not against him/them

There are what, 4 clans? 5 maybe... (only 3 of which can be considered active) Dodge one of them, good idea!

Oh, and streex, you are all for applying the rules at any cost in qm when it benefits you, but when its cw its a different story

This post has been edited by Ryze: Nov 5 2009, 22:22 PM

last time when i saw it was more than 5 clans

This post has been edited by CENTAUER: Nov 6 2009, 01:09 AM

Seems like cw.cc will stay down for a long time now. We should think bout an alternative like getting cw action into gr section..

lool thats excatly I was sufering from when I was playing this game

Fix the network connection BEFORE you play Online. If not - find yourself another hobby. It's very unfair and unrespectfull to treat others like "oh well, we will play, as long as my net keeps working, then w/e..". Especially, when you can use this net-problem as permanent excuse to DC whenever you like.

Imagine a Premiere Football team playing for 20 minutes, then: "Oh, guys, sorry, we are tired now. We cannot play any more, cya and goodbye." - and they walk of the field. Or even more direct - they don't say anything, they just walk away.

well let me considere the 2 games me and palla had against u and dogs: the first one was in our hands and the second was not still decided. how do u think i can accept a double loss just because he lost connection?

ofc i'm not a cheater so the games will be reported but it is very lame, like pressing kick when ur opponed dcs and u were clearly losing.
so my advice to him is to dodge players like u and dogs just in the hours in which his cnnetion is weak.
waht is the purpose of playing game in which u risk to dc and take a loss without even playing 10 minutes? from my point of view it has no sense
i think there are other players who will let him play and won't ask to report if he gets dced.

let me put it like this..., if we make an exception to one we make an exception to all. If we say o its ok palla we wont count the game as a win then your gonna turn cws in QM having people dc in games talking about their connection. I understand palla has interent troubles, and im not gonna waste my time in a game that could end up in someone dcing and then just be like aww its oks dont worry about it lol, and you have no idea if you woulda won that game streex.

Well in my opinion it's bad sportmanship to insist on such reports if the game hasn't been decided yet or if the winning side dc's all of a sudden.

But if you know that you will dc you just should not play.