Battle for Middle Earth 2

Will there be a Battle for Middle-Earth 3?

Closed Topic Start new topic
# 1TDA Sep 17 2008, 09:07 AM
Read Will there be a Battle for Middle-Earth 3? on our portal.
Group Icon

Posts: 21,654

Clan: Prisoners Of War

Game: League of Legends

+
# 2Standard` Sep 17 2008, 10:00 AM
Hey Celebnor and his mates created a topic named "BFME3 is in ur hands" they went to a expo and met EA. So wats going to happen now?
Group Icon

Posts: 2,866

Clan: [SdL]

Game: Supreme Commander 2

+
# 3TDA Sep 17 2008, 10:02 AM
Nothing, they presented their mod to some EA guys, that's it.
Group Icon

Posts: 21,654

Clan: Prisoners Of War

Game: League of Legends

+
# 4Standard` Sep 17 2008, 10:08 AM
hmmm then i gues we have to w8 until the release of the 2 Hobbit moves (2 movies right?) to see wats going to hapen.
Group Icon

Posts: 2,866

Clan: [SdL]

Game: Supreme Commander 2

+
# 5FreedomX10A Sep 17 2008, 10:25 AM
I wouldn't count EA out with a BfME3 so fast yet, they're quite popular for hammering people with the same game every year.

I'm quite sure they're simply just too busy to make BfME3 yet and also its not a good time to release one though it would be excellent if they did it before SC2 so it has a chance of higher sales therefore larger community.
Group Icon

Posts: 8,759

Clan: Prisoners Of War

Game: Battle for Middle Earth

+
# 6FrosTzYy Sep 17 2008, 13:12 PM
QUOTE(FreedomX10A @ Sep 17 2008, 12:25 PM) *

I wouldn't count EA out with a BfME3 so fast yet, they're quite popular for hammering people with the same game every year.

I'm quite sure they're simply just too busy to make BfME3 yet and also its not a good time to release one though it would be excellent if they did it before SC2 so it has a chance of higher sales therefore larger community.

Couldnt agree more.
Group Icon

Posts: 2,018

Game: Rise of the Witchking

+
# 7TDA Sep 17 2008, 13:27 PM
QUOTE(FreedomX10A @ Sep 17 2008, 12:25 PM) *
I wouldn't count EA out with a BfME3 so fast yet, they're quite popular for hammering people with the same game every year.

I'm quite sure they're simply just too busy to make BfME3 yet and also its not a good time to release one though it would be excellent if they did it before SC2 so it has a chance of higher sales therefore larger community.


EALA is busy with RA3 atm, after this they are most likely gonna make an expansion pack.
Earliest release date for another LotR franchise RTS by EALA is 2010 in all honesty.
I personally think they won't release another title before "The Hobbit" movie anyways.
Group Icon

Posts: 21,654

Clan: Prisoners Of War

Game: League of Legends

+
# 8Skylin3 Sep 17 2008, 13:46 PM
QUOTE(TDA @ Sep 17 2008, 15:27 PM) *

EALA is busy with RA3 atm, after this they are most likely gonna make an expansion pack.
Earliest release date for another LotR franchise RTS by EALA is 2010 in all honesty.
I personally think they won't release another title before "The Hobbit" movie anyways.



yeh prolly not dry.gif
Group Icon

Posts: 150

Game: BfME2 BT2DC

+
# 9Týr Sep 17 2008, 14:05 PM
I'm expecting LotR: Conquest to take the front in EA's LotR arsenal, with a sequel to that game more likely with the Hobbit 1 & 2 (respectively). BfMe3 would be nice though.
Group Icon

Posts: 7,143

Game: RotWK Unofficial 202

+
# 10Thorin Sep 17 2008, 17:49 PM
Problem is that there is not really a basis for it unless it would severely alter the gameplay in which case it would lose it's BFME feel.
Group Icon

Posts: 4,101

Clan: Corruption of Light

Game: Rise of the Witchking

+
# 11William WaLlace Sep 17 2008, 18:39 PM
I suppose theres every chance they make one in like a year or so but alot of players will have grew out of this game lol.
Group Icon

Posts: 685

Game: League of Legends

+
# 12Taterz Sep 17 2008, 18:49 PM
Why does it take us to this section from the NP laugh.gif.

I hope there wont be a BfME3. It's gotten to the point where they've ran out of idea's, so now they're making up creatures. Just imagine them trying to think of yet another 2-3 factions, new maps, new units for all 7 existing, and another story line for campaign. It'll be so diverse from the world Tolkein created that it'll be a regular 'magic' RTS, no different from the AoE games.
Group Icon

Posts: 22,748

Clan: Corruption of Light

Game: FPS

+
# 13Ivan Sep 17 2008, 19:19 PM
A very interesting article. I will maybe take a look into it better tomorrow when I find time.

Anyhow there is a lot of unresearched yet stuff and material which can be used for BFME 3.
Group Icon

Posts: 6,146

Game: None

+
# 14Taterz Sep 17 2008, 19:45 PM
Having things like Arnor/Rhun/etcetc as factions is a joke. They will be making shit up.
Group Icon

Posts: 22,748

Clan: Corruption of Light

Game: FPS

+
# 15FreedomX10A Sep 17 2008, 20:01 PM
QUOTE(TDA @ Sep 17 2008, 13:27 PM) *

EALA is busy with RA3 atm, after this they are most likely gonna make an expansion pack.
Earliest release date for another LotR franchise RTS by EALA is 2010 in all honesty.
I personally think they won't release another title before "The Hobbit" movie anyways.

I believe Blizzard is "hoping" to release SC2 before 2011 and knowing Blizzard they'll give it plenty of time.

I agree with you TDA, they should release the game around the time or after "The Hobbit" is released.
QUOTE(Taterz @ Sep 17 2008, 18:49 PM) *

Why does it take us to this section from the NP laugh.gif.

I hope there wont be a BfME3. It's gotten to the point where they've ran out of idea's, so now they're making up creatures. Just imagine them trying to think of yet another 2-3 factions, new maps, new units for all 7 existing, and another story line for campaign. It'll be so diverse from the world Tolkein created that it'll be a regular 'magic' RTS, no different from the AoE games.

LoL taterz if you read tolkeins books, they've got PLENTY of ideas in fact the war of the ring was quite a weak war compared to some of the other ones.
Group Icon

Posts: 8,759

Clan: Prisoners Of War

Game: Battle for Middle Earth

+
# 16Curlyfriez Sep 17 2008, 21:09 PM
Well gamereplays has been able to make abajillion different factions for lotr. why dont they just buy out some of those ideas and work from there?

and EALA is schweet

they have a basketball court in the back xD

I never got to go in but I marvel it from outside.
Group Icon

Posts: 5,430

Clan: Nemesis

Game: Graphics

+
# 17Desktipper Sep 17 2008, 21:24 PM
i hope bfme3 comes out biggrin.gif
and they should make it like 10/10 goodness - unlike bfme2
and a decent campaign this time!!1! VeryFunny.gif that is actually slightly challenging

nice article btw
Group Icon

Posts: 7,194

Clan: vKo

Game: BfME2 BT2DC

+
# 18Thorin Sep 17 2008, 21:28 PM
In my opinion it should have some new gameplay aspects rather than entirely new lore. BFME2 was different from BFME in terms of gameplay as it had free base building, bigger hordes, a builder system, etcetera. BFME3 should have some new revolutionary gameplay in my opinion.

The lore is a problem as I stated in the article, because a lot of the books can't be accessed as the rights just won't be sold nor is there a large enough community behind to back it up. Would EA have made the BFME series if there hadn't been the successful LotR trilogy? I think not, because there just wouldn't have been enough guarantee that they would profit from such a project. The Hobbit does not provide the lore a new game needs as it covers a time 60 years prior to the LotR books, which is by far not enough to have enough different lands and peoples in Middle-Earth. For that you need to move back an Age or two and there either is the problem of inaccessible rights or not a large enough guarantee or fanbase.
Group Icon

Posts: 4,101

Clan: Corruption of Light

Game: Rise of the Witchking

+
# 19BlackKnightofEa Sep 17 2008, 21:57 PM
Buy the right s to the silmarriloin.

BFME3=War of the first age, cmon Wars between the Valar? THat would be kick ass, and how many fucking expansions could you get out of that?!?!?! Elves/dwarves/MEn of Beleriand. Only with heroes liek Feanor and such. CMon dudes TONS of new gameplay right there.
Group Icon

Posts: 6,572

Clan: Knights of Ea

Game: Rise of the Witchking

+
# 20Thorin Sep 17 2008, 22:17 PM
First sentence is the greatest problem, the rights to it are not for sale, that's just it for now. Secondly, I doubt the Silmarillion community is as large as the LotR community.
Group Icon

Posts: 4,101

Clan: Corruption of Light

Game: Rise of the Witchking

+
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)