Kanes Wrath

Leownzall DQed from WCG for pushing

Reply to this topic Start new topic
# 1F-Boisier Aug 15 2008, 21:42 PM
That's sad:

http://www.timeofwar.com/news.php?id=6458

I'm french, then i'm going to sumup and translate the matter in english.

-According to TOW it's obvious that Leo has pointpushed to get into the top 8 helped with Bapor and redfury.

-Timeofwar, a famous french website about RTS games (which is also responsible of the french WCG qualifications for KW) has decided to DQ Leo , Bapor and redfury for PP (Point Pushing).

-The rules are simple about that special case:

"2. Les comptes EA des joueurs inscrits seront régulièrement vérifiés afin de détecter toute manoeuvre illicite (=pushing) visant à doper votre classement. Tout comportement suspect ou illicite sera synonyme de disqualification. "

Translation:

"2. EA accounts of any registered players are regulary checked in order to detect possible pushing aiming a ranking improvment. Any suspicious or illicit behaviour will end up as a disqualification"


Group Icon

Posts: 84

+
# 2Dackel Aug 15 2008, 21:58 PM
I guess knolz will be happy...
Group Icon


Posts: 1,407

Game: None

+
# 3DiZpoZableHero Aug 15 2008, 22:09 PM
lOl this is getting funny now.
Group Icon

Posts: 1,084

Game: Command and Conquer 3

+
# 4F-Boisier Aug 15 2008, 22:19 PM
Now i don't know which french player will qualify for WCGs...
Group Icon

Posts: 84

+
# 5JuDgEpowr Aug 15 2008, 22:22 PM
leownall you just ruined it, thats what you get for cheating.

seriously cheaters deserve that.
Group Icon

Posts: 393

Game: StarCraft 2

+
# 6KhuFu_OwNz Aug 15 2008, 22:29 PM
Some random person PM'ed me with evidence that indicated Leo had point pushed. I had not made any conclusions thus far, but on the surface it looks slightly like point pushing. I am NOT going to jump to a conclusion though, because people (espically Leo) deserves the benefit of the doubt, innocent until proven guilty. I would like Leo to release an official statement to us here. - Khufu
Group Icon

Posts: 2,136

+
# 7Lepidosteus Aug 15 2008, 22:47 PM
For what it's worth, bapor admitted in one of the french forums that he lost his games on purpose to leo, those were not real games but freewins.
The real shame here is that since unleashed got kicked out leo didn't even need those freewins, and we all know he's good enough to deserve that spot anyway - without this push he would probably have crushed the competition in the french wcg like he did last year.

This post has been edited by Lepidosteus: Aug 15 2008, 22:48 PM
Group Icon

Posts: 292

Game: Red Alert 3

+
# 8-Tireur- Aug 15 2008, 23:21 PM
Leownzall need to be DQed from ladder season 2 because he push to be top 8.

F4N4TIC need to be on the ladder season 2!

F4N4TIC is the real top 8 player ...

Please translate it and give it to apoc NO PUSH for the ladder season 2 LEO OUT! u0udiablo.gif

This post has been edited by -Tireur-: Aug 15 2008, 23:24 PM
Group Icon

Posts: 83

+
# 9BaPoR Aug 15 2008, 23:26 PM
It's an error, i will explain tomorow. No prove, Leo have no speak, leo no need points etc... Timeofwar dont want see the rank 1 & rank 2 fr in wcg. Why, i dont know actually.
More explain tomorow (night).
P.S. : U know tireur ? Cheater, pusher etc...

This post has been edited by BaPoR: Aug 15 2008, 23:27 PM
Group Icon

Posts: 176

Clan: †PrO†

Game: Red Alert 3

+
# 10KhuFu_OwNz Aug 15 2008, 23:45 PM
QUOTE(BaPoR @ Aug 15 2008, 19:26 PM) *

It's an error, i will explain tomorow. No prove, Leo have no speak, leo no need points etc... Timeofwar dont want see the rank 1 & rank 2 fr in wcg. Why, i dont know actually.
More explain tomorow (night).
P.S. : U know tireur ? Cheater, pusher etc...


I disagree with you Bapor. I think Leo needs to make a statement. If he is innocent than there is no reason he can't publicly say so and explain the situation himself.
Group Icon

Posts: 2,136

+
# 11D1g1TaL Aug 15 2008, 23:46 PM
Leo did get 3 free wins from point pushing but it was after the season 2 deadline, in other words he would have qualified without it and this had no impact on him qualifying for season 2.

As a result the players involved in this have been banned from the French WCG qualifying stage as its stated in the WCG French organiser's rules that all personas will be verified regually.

Its a shame because Bapor and Leo were favourites to win it.

It was an error of judgement on Leo's part and at the worst possible moment, but I think he will learn from it and move on and hopefully we'll see him for next years WCG.




Group Icon

Posts: 3,305

Game: StarCraft 2

+
# 12bbq199 Aug 15 2008, 23:58 PM
QUOTE(EuRoAce @ Aug 16 2008, 01:46 AM) *

Leo did get 3 free wins from point pushing but it was after the season 2 deadline, in other words he would have qualified without it and this had no impact on him qualifying for season 2.



It doesn't matter, it's still against the rules.

And using the "the quali was over" excuse will get him nowhere, seeing as it's not over at all (still got 2 qualis to go, and the points he got from those games will obviously help him)

Leo never struck me as a guy who would cheat, but oh well.

This post has been edited by bbq199: Aug 15 2008, 23:59 PM
Group Icon

Posts: 575

Game: Command and Conquer 3

+
# 13KhuFu_OwNz Aug 15 2008, 23:59 PM
QUOTE(EuRoAce @ Aug 15 2008, 19:46 PM) *

Leo did get 3 free wins from point pushing but it was after the season 2 deadline, in other words he would have qualified without it and this had no impact on him qualifying for season 2.

As a result the players involved in this have been banned from the French WCG qualifying stage as its stated in the WCG French organiser's rules that all personas will be verified regually.

Its a shame because Bapor and Leo were favourites to win it.

It was an error of judgement on Leo's part and at the worst possible moment, but I think he will learn from it and move on and hopefully we'll see him for next years WCG.


How do you know when the actual games are played though>? They could have easily been played prior to the deadline and due to server lag, not registered on the official ladder until after the deadline.
Group Icon

Posts: 2,136

+
# 14bbq199 Aug 16 2008, 00:01 AM
QUOTE(KhuFu_OwNz @ Aug 16 2008, 01:59 AM) *

How do you know when the actual games are played though>? They could have easily been played prior to the deadline and due to server lag, not registered on the official ladder until after the deadline.

In my opionion it doesn't matter in the slightest when the games were played. The ladder isn't over yet.

This post has been edited by bbq199: Aug 16 2008, 00:01 AM
Group Icon

Posts: 575

Game: Command and Conquer 3

+
# 15D1g1TaL Aug 16 2008, 00:10 AM
QUOTE(bbq199 @ Aug 16 2008, 00:58 AM) *

It doesn't matter, it's still against the rules.

And using the "the quali was over" excuse will get him nowhere, seeing as it's not over at all (still got 2 qualis to go, and the points he got from those games will obviously help him)

Leo never struck me as a guy who would cheat, but oh well.


Me neither, but it doesn't suprize me in the slightest what people would do for money and I'm not going to judge him for that. But like I said I think he will learn from it and move on and I don't think he will do it again, I'm pretty confident about that.

QUOTE(KhuFu_OwNz @ Aug 16 2008, 00:59 AM) *

How do you know when the actual games are played though>? They could have easily been played prior to the deadline and due to server lag, not registered on the official ladder until after the deadline.


Thats a good point, but I was just pointing out they way it worked out in the end was that those matchs didn't count for qualifying for season 2 but the points will help for for the following season as BBQ pointed out.
Group Icon

Posts: 3,305

Game: StarCraft 2

+
# 16LeOwNzAll Aug 16 2008, 00:18 AM
QUOTE(KhuFu_OwNz @ Aug 16 2008, 01:59 AM) *

How do you know when the actual games are played though>? They could have easily been played prior to the deadline and due to server lag, not registered on the official ladder until after the deadline.


It's joke.

I went offline for 3 days.
I connect today, and what i see "Leo is Disqualified".
I dont even talk with any guy.
I can't understand this thing. They kicked me before talk about it with me. And at the moment i still dont talk with them.
I hope tomorrow we could talk and we could see what is the problem.
I'm n1qshok.gif blink.gif
Group Icon

Posts: 202

Game: Command and Conquer 3

+
# 17KhuFu_OwNz Aug 16 2008, 00:41 AM
I have just had a long talk with Leo. He explained his position and what exactly transpired. As you can see in the chat, he did something unethical, openly admits it, and is very sorry for it. Here is the chatlog of my conversation with Leo over MSN. I think* I posted all of it-hopefully I didnt' leave any out - took forever to copy and paste.
*******************
(8:19:11 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: You know what the problem is though yes?
(8:19:24 PM) LeOwNzAll: they said about pushing
(8:19:26 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: They are saying that Bapor and Redfury used smurf accounts
(8:19:30 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: to give you freewins
(8:19:37 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: and also
(8:19:43 PM) LeOwNzAll: just omg
(8:19:46 PM) LeOwNzAll: they dont talk with me
(8:19:47 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: There was a screenshot
(8:19:49 PM) LeOwNzAll: they kicked me
(8:19:53 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: of you asking someone for a freewin
(8:20:07 PM) LeOwNzAll: i deny freewin of bapor and redfury
(8:20:14 PM) LeOwNzAll: yes i asked for freewin, but i dont get it
(8:20:20 PM) LeOwNzAll: i was in panic in last hour
(8:20:34 PM) LeOwNzAll: but finally
(8:20:38 PM) LeOwNzAll: i played some automatch
(8:20:46 PM) LeOwNzAll: and played dukenukethem
(8:21:00 PM) LeOwNzAll: and i heard about tooobeyislife and unleashed pushing
(8:21:03 PM) LeOwNzAll: so i was confident
(8:21:09 PM) LeOwNzAll: and i knew that i'll go to top8
(8:21:10 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: Why did you play
(8:21:15 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: bapor and redfury though
(8:21:24 PM) LeOwNzAll: they would play...
(8:21:25 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: Your games log showed that you played both of them
(8:21:27 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: on smurf accounts
(8:21:39 PM) LeOwNzAll: they would not play with their own account
(8:21:42 PM) LeOwNzAll: and i've only on
(8:21:42 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: ah
(8:21:44 PM) LeOwNzAll: one
(8:21:54 PM) LeOwNzAll: and it could train me for WCG france
(8:21:59 PM) LeOwNzAll: i would see their trick
(8:21:59 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: why were the games
(8:22:03 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: under 2 minutes long ?
(8:22:26 PM) LeOwNzAll: refury
(8:22:31 PM) LeOwNzAll: just moto rush
(8:22:37 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: ah
(8:22:39 PM) LeOwNzAll: then i played bapor in 1st game
(8:22:45 PM) LeOwNzAll: he tried a rush rocket wacko.gif
(8:22:54 PM) LeOwNzAll: then i played bapor second game some minutes later
(8:23:00 PM) LeOwNzAll: he came back with another strat
(8:23:04 PM) LeOwNzAll: rush disintegrator
(8:23:22 PM) LeOwNzAll: i just scouted soon
(8:23:23 PM) LeOwNzAll: with rifle
(8:23:30 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: ahh so the games ended early because they rushed you
(8:23:31 PM) LeOwNzAll: then just spam buggy
(8:23:31 PM) LeOwNzAll: hh
(8:23:32 PM) LeOwNzAll: gg
(8:23:42 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: well that explains the shortness of the games
(8:23:42 PM) LeOwNzAll: nah first game i rushed redfury
(8:23:45 PM) LeOwNzAll: with bikes
(8:23:47 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: ah
(8:23:58 PM) LeOwNzAll: it's incredible
(8:24:03 PM) LeOwNzAll: they took a incredible decision
(8:24:09 PM) LeOwNzAll: i played all french tourny
(8:24:12 PM) LeOwNzAll: all won it
(8:24:14 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: As far as you know
(8:24:26 PM) LeOwNzAll: i'm asking myself if they WANT kick me
(8:24:32 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: do Bapor and Redfury know that they arent't suppose to play with 2 or more ranked accounts ?
(8:24:33 PM) LeOwNzAll: for let him another guy win...
(8:24:46 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: I mean you certainly knew they weren't suppose to be playing with those accounts
(8:24:52 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: Why did you play them ?
(8:24:52 PM) LeOwNzAll: i dont know
(8:25:04 PM) LeOwNzAll: i think they know that they can't play 2 account top 100
(8:25:20 PM) LeOwNzAll: to make seed in French
(8:25:25 PM) LeOwNzAll: it's top 8 French players
(8:25:36 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: ah ok
(8:25:43 PM) LeOwNzAll: http://www.xp3rt.com/ladder-ea-francophone-1v1
(8:25:43 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: Well this sounds reasonable to me
(8:25:50 PM) LeOwNzAll: here the french ladder
(8:26:01 PM) LeOwNzAll: they would not play me with their true account
(8:26:14 PM) LeOwNzAll: because they was scared to lose points and lose position
(8:26:16 PM) LeOwNzAll: for seed
(8:26:17 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: ahhh
(8:26:21 PM) LeOwNzAll: only top8 is seeded
(8:26:27 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: ok I'm going to post this conversation
(8:26:28 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: on Gr.org
(8:26:31 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: in your defense
(8:26:51 PM) LeOwNzAll: i'll send email to french orga
(8:26:59 PM) LeOwNzAll: i want to talk with them tomorrow
(8:27:04 PM) LeOwNzAll: french qualifier starts sunday
(8:27:11 PM) LeOwNzAll: and they kicked me now without talking with me
(8:27:18 PM) LeOwNzAll: it's incredible
(8:27:21 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: yeah
(8:27:22 PM) LeOwNzAll: bad organisation
(8:27:24 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: they should have talked to you first
(8:27:27 PM) LeOwNzAll: sure
(8:27:31 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: I will try and defend you
(8:27:35 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: thank you for talking with me
(8:27:46 PM) LeOwNzAll: it's like i said you killed someone, and police send you in prison without you can't defense
(8:28:18 PM) LeOwNzAll: i played a lot for top8 so since 2-3 days i was often offline
(8:28:29 PM) LeOwNzAll: i just came yesterday and watching you play some game
(8:28:37 PM) LeOwNzAll: and tomorrow, i just connected now
(8:28:49 PM) LeOwNzAll: and see "disqualified"
(8:28:51 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: what ??
(8:28:55 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: oh
(8:28:59 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: ok
(8:29:10 PM) LeOwNzAll: i spent too many times for top8 and wcg france
(8:29:14 PM) LeOwNzAll: and now i'm screwed
(8:29:20 PM) LeOwNzAll: incredible
(8:30:05 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: Do you mind if I post this "(8:20:14 PM) LeOwNzAll: yes i asked for freewin, but i dont get it
(8:20:20 PM) LeOwNzAll: i was in panic in last hour
(8:20:34 PM) LeOwNzAll: but finally
(8:20:38 PM) LeOwNzAll: i played some automatch"
(8:30:16 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: I think it would be good for you to admit that
(8:30:25 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: since they already have a screen shot of you asking for it
(8:30:38 PM) KhuFu_OwNz: It's good to admit to your mistakes when you make them
(8:30:54 PM) LeOwNzAll: ye
(8:30:56 PM) LeOwNzAll: it's true
(8:31:00 PM) LeOwNzAll: you can post it
(8:31:31 PM) LeOwNzAll: i asked but then i think and go back to play some automatch, you can see my match history i played "dukenukethem"
(8:31:38 PM) LeOwNzAll: i would won some points
(8:31:55 PM) LeOwNzAll: then i saw in lobby it was talking about pushing for unleashed
& tooobeyislife
(8:32:28 PM) LeOwNzAll: i think 3rd and 4th French player want see us (me and bapor) be kicked
(8:32:36 PM) LeOwNzAll: like this they can win












Group Icon

Posts: 2,136

+
# 18Lepidosteus Aug 16 2008, 01:29 AM
Since most people here can't read the french forums and as such can't separate facts from "someguy told me that", I'm going to correct a few errors in what leo says in this msn conversation (these are facts supported with a link to the corresponding message each time, and if you can't understand french at all there is still google translate or whatever). This should also help with the fact that most french players can't speak english very well.

- There have been 5 french tournaments on KW since release, four 1v1 and one 2v2. Leo won only two of the 1v1 tournament (he played in four of the tourneys). This one is a nitpick, but still.
One, two, three, four, five.

- Although it's true that leo didn't have a live chat via msn/teamspeak/whatever with the WCG admin yet, he did comment on it already on the french forums, his defense being that these pushed games weren't the reason for him being part of the 8 qualified players. (Leo's message about it, + all his messages in the thread)
The french WCG admin thought just like bbq: even if it wasn't usefull to get him qualified this round, it was still cheating. Please also note that the french qualifiers starts this sunday and they couldn't wait indefinitely for leo to be available to make their decision.

- The way they (mostly bapor since leo wasn't online and redfury stayed quiet) justified these fake games changed a lot throughout time;
* at first they said point pushing is a fair move for this season since the whole top 9 do it (link to post)
* then bapor did admit it was freewins, the reason he gave for these freewins was that since there is a smurf rule he needed to lose points on his smurf to avoid it being top 100 and being reset, so he gave some wins to leo on purpose. (link to his message, and another one here where he explain the details of why)
* then bapor learns that this breaks the rule and the written result for that is DQ, so he reverses into full denial mode "it never happened", "others do it to", etc (here)... And leo start false accusing other french players because they have one isolated win in less than 2 minute (here and here).

If I forgot something in between, then please correct me.

If you guys are going to judge then at least now you can do it with all the cards in your hands.
I think it's a shame that leo's DQ since he's france best and only luck at any wcg result on kw plus he's not really the kind of guy used to cheat at any given occasion, but that's no reason to lie and/or hide facts.

This post has been edited by Lepidosteus: Aug 16 2008, 01:30 AM
Group Icon

Posts: 292

Game: Red Alert 3

+
# 19knolz Aug 16 2008, 03:35 AM
QUOTE(Dackel @ Aug 15 2008, 21:58 PM) *

I guess knolz will be happy...


Not really, Leownzall is in Epsilon team like me... I didn't play a lot to KW because WCG is not my priority, i'm not sure to win it in France. So "happy" is a big word for that, specially for Bapor who i appreciate a lot.

QUOTE(KhuFu_OwNz @ Aug 16 2008, 00:41 AM) *

(8:32:28 PM) LeOwNzAll: i think 3rd and 4th French player want see us (me and bapor) be kicked


hum.... France against Leownzall & bapor ? Please...

This post has been edited by knolz: Aug 16 2008, 03:36 AM
Group Icon

Posts: 240

+
# 20LeOwNzAll Aug 16 2008, 08:47 AM
QUOTE(Lepidosteus @ Aug 16 2008, 03:29 AM) *

Since most people here can't read the french forums and as such can't separate facts from "someguy told me that", I'm going to correct a few errors in what leo says in this msn conversation (these are facts supported with a link to the corresponding message each time, and if you can't understand french at all there is still google translate or whatever). This should also help with the fact that most french players can't speak english very well.

- There have been 5 french tournaments on KW since release, four 1v1 and one 2v2. Leo won only two of the 1v1 tournament (he played in four of the tourneys). This one is a nitpick, but still. I WON ALL TOW TOURNAMENT (TOW are frenchs orga)
One, two, three, four, five.

- Although it's true that leo didn't have a live chat via msn/teamspeak/whatever with the WCG admin yet, he did comment on it already on the french forums, his defense being that these pushed games weren't the reason for him being part of the 8 qualified players.
LOL? I never speak with orga, i dont care to speak with others french players who wants win at Paris...
(Leo's message about it, + all his messages in the thread)
The french WCG admin thought just like bbq: even if it wasn't usefull to get him qualified this round, it was still cheating. Please also note that the french qualifiers starts this sunday and they couldn't wait indefinitely for leo to be available to make their decision.

Lol they can't until Saturday ? I just sent mail yesterday before go to sleep.
Answer from French orga :
1st : I can't be there saturday, so you can't argue. But i'll try come some minutes the night
2nd : I'm not in my house, it's not sure...

Can't defend me. drol.gif


- The way they (mostly bapor since leo wasn't online and redfury stayed quiet) justified these fake games changed a lot throughout time;
* at first they said point pushing is a fair move for this season since the whole top 9 do it (link to post)
* then bapor did admit it was freewins, the reason he gave for these freewins was that since there is a smurf rule he needed to lose points on his smurf to avoid it being top 100 and being reset, so he gave some wins to leo on purpose. (link to his message, and another one here where he explain the details of why)
* then bapor learns that this breaks the rule and the written result for that is DQ, so he reverses into full denial mode "it never happened", "others do it to", etc (here)...

And leo start false accusing other french players because they have one isolated win in less than 2 minute (here and here).

Yes because you are accusing for us for short games drol.gif

If I forgot something in between, then please correct me.

If you guys are going to judge then at least now you can do it with all the cards in your hands.
I think it's a shame that leo's DQ since he's france best and only luck at any wcg result on kw plus he's not really the kind of guy used to cheat at any given occasion, but that's no reason to lie and/or hide facts.

QUOTE

hum.... France against Leownzall & bapor ? Please...


Knolz you are the first who said "I think it's my birthday today w00t.gif "
Group Icon

Posts: 202

Game: Command and Conquer 3

+
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)