Please vote on whether you feel this replay deserves to be a Gold Replay (formerly known as Hall of Fame).
This poll will be closed once the discussion has reached it's end in this topic (Admin discretion applies).
Gold Replays
Gold Replays are replays that are really entertaining and show a very fun match. The match does not have to be on a pro level and mistakes are allowed to be made. It is all about having a really fun and intense game to observe. This is also the place for outstanding new strategies and wtf-moments.
Note that Gold Replays do not have to be perfect. It is all about entertainment value.
We will also have a Staff only vote for this Replay in the Staff section.
concretely this game is so boring that shut down the replay on the 24y minute. and it goes over an hour. so the vote - no. boring games have no place in the tops.
This map make AIR-Z. It is a beautiful and symmetrical map. Although, if we talk about balance - its design by itself predisposes to GLA-mirror match positional game, because we have two narrow passages at the base on each side, which are easy to defend and one pass through the middle, medium size. With regard to the USA - this map encourages players to play in the "no eco" strategy (this is bad) becose second SC is in the center, which makes it impossible resource extraction (or spend money on SC the edge for a few thousand money). I think all the matchups type "USA-China" this offset on the balance in the direction of the USA. So that, with regards to the balance - I do not think this a good map, yes. But we are not talking about the map now, especially considering the match GLA vs Tox (in which the balance been respected, although towards the Toxin, obviously). As far as my maps - I'm not even sure whether you know what maps I have done, and which maps are not my job. Maybe - it is, and maybe - my maps are boring, just like this battle. But we are again - Now do not look at map - but on replay, which should be of value in entertainment.
I respect Size and Rage, i know that now they best players on ZH. But, WTF - Why should I vote "YES", if I see absolutely a typical position GLA-Mirror, in which there is exactly the same as in the hundreds of other ordinary replays.
This poll will be closed once the discussion has reached it's end in this topic (Admin discretion applies).
Gold Replays
Gold Replays are replays that are really entertaining and show a very fun match. The match does not have to be on a pro level and mistakes are allowed to be made. It is all about having a really fun and intense game to observe. This is also the place for outstanding new strategies and wtf-moments.
Note that Gold Replays do not have to be perfect. It is all about entertainment value.
We will also have a Staff only vote for this Replay in the Staff section.
Posts: 10,862
Game: