Battle for Middle Earth

Sonk hosted, thanks for the comments guys and for the review velv was a very enjoyable game to play. I needed to try and nab another creep early on with some orcs, I think that was my main mistake. I did push out with trolls a fair bit to begin with but sonks horses did a very good job and i needed a lot in the base to defend

well played sonk

Some of you people are impressed way too easily. GOLD someone said? This is very lucky to scrape silver. I'll leave it at silver though, and it is a rotw contender.

i said gold but if the game wopuld have lasted more i think it would of been a gold rep,,,but its cool if they get silver...this is a good replay just to show average players how pros play

Most pros don't go so many horses because straight up it isn't as effective, whether you can micro them or not.

Not taking anything away from this rep ofc.

its not about being pro, just the fact that he kept them all alive thats what makes the gmae so good, n he used them really good

thx for comments and nice review,gg mate

For me this was an easy silver, but gold never crossed my mind. So if this barely scraps it, what are we looking for in a silver replay then? I'm guessing sonka knew 3 horse to GTW laming is a surer path to victory, but this game had some amazing micro in it. Thats what sets the best appart, anyone can learn a set of build orders. 2 silver replays in 6 months doesn't really tell the truth about this game tbh. Skill levels havn't fallen, expectations have just got higher. Personaly I'm interested to here (honestly) everyone else's opinion on this replay's silver status.

ok silver it is,

Yeah, I totally agree.
If it was a good game, than it was a good thing to make it Silver. We really have to few Silver games. Gen you need to turn down your expectations a bit. No offense but what should be a Silver game in your opinion and remember, after Silver there also is Gold!

I'll watch it now.

This has been discussed thousands of times in this section. We are not going to promote games "For the sake of having silvers" . Totally dumb fucking idea that I never agreed with.