Battle for Middle Earth

kk

is tr still active in bfme 1 cw?

no imo

yes

TR|Hosaf (Isengard):

BO: Pit,uruk spam,pikes spam,zerks,furnances,armoury,wargs, seige, lurtz,combos
PP: Chant,Industry, TL,palantir,rain,Balrog

Pros:

scouting early game
extra labourers
good harrasment
good creeping 4/6
good mc most of the game
killed Gandy 2x
Got Lurtz LD
some good formation use


Cons:

very slow building
Lost lots of units unneccesarly
lost Lurtz 3x
Only bought blades and armour then demo armoury then rebuilt it later for the rest
Cash float mid-game
poor unit micro


Notes: your early game was good you put good pressure on him but yout took very long before you get 1 furnance in your base, if he had vision he'd just rush your base with his first batt of knights came out and you will suck the rest of the game but you were lucky. So now you saw him just spamming TGs and rax why you kept making pikes? just spam uruks and you will smash him easily. Don't tell me he had knights coz uruks with warchant > knights. This game shoul have ended sooner.

Player rating: 5/10



MUD|tommynt (Gondor):

BO: 3 farms in, 2 out, stable, knight,knight,Barracks,BS,knight,sheilds,upgs,TGs,Gandalf
PP: EW, heal, elves, GtW,Eagles

Pros:

Good harrasment
maintained good mc through the game
good use of elves summons sometimes


Cons:

Unit micro
Empty spot in Base the whole game
upgraded units with 3 BS only
Lost gandalf 2x
poor creeping 2/6


Notes: i liked the way you used your knights, true sometimes you get into crazy fights but you escape with 1,2 horses left. But you missed some stuff, Vs isengard you do 3 knights, sheild rush, then combos along with heroes LD, you didnt get a single hero till very late in game, well thats bad coz you were only harrasing you didn't do any damage to his base at all and you lacked vision because his base had only the uruk pit and nothing else when you got your 2 knights and your rax. If you had map awareness you'd just rush him then have all the time to creep and to make combos,haarras,etc.... Also you need to know that pikes >>> TGs you were fighting pikes with TGs almost in every small battle.

Player rating: 4/10



Game notes: The game was basically harras harras and harras the only entertaining part when isen attacked gondor base 2 times the whole game and i believe gondor didn't see how isen's base looks like till very late in game.

Game rating: 5/10
Entertainment: 5/10

KaiTo`K1D

U don't know this game so much dude. Knights with upgrades > uruks even if uruks r warchanted(don't trample just melee). In fords of isen u should always spam pikes. And also i have not poor unit micro tbh
I told this many times -> U should get Wargs as fast as possible so if u w8 for all upgrades vs. fol u will lose

Bad review

u posted this game and asked for a reveiw. Its only the rr who decide the rating. I would say this is almost flaming vs a staff member.

(i watched this game, and the review is very good)

ok fu ban me

its no point to get angry. you got 5 and u wouldnt be angry if u got 7

first the game was boring tbh you must be happy that i gave u this rating and didnt quit and flame you for wasting my time

second your counter was poor you saw he only had 1 knight left and its easy to counter with uruk spam and you just made pikes and kept loosing them

oh well game reviewed so this topic shud be LOCKED