Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[Review] Poose vs Sammy

#1Poose  Sep 11 2007, 15:40 PM -
Awards:
This was a really good game featuring all Rohan heros and some big battles. Back and forth action at beginning trading map control, and I really had to turn my concentration up a bit when gtw came out so damn early post-13661-1143531603.gif.

It was a really gg, someone should review it tbh biggrin.gif

My host, decent lag for Sam though, I think one lag heal for Gandy.
This post has been edited by Poose: Sep 11 2007, 15:43 PM
#2RamRaider  Sep 11 2007, 17:39 PM -
It was ok, good in patches but Sammy's strategy was a bit off in places:

- Why did he camp when he had map control? wacko.gif He should have sieged from the outpost. He just sat back waiting for Gandy level 10 or the AOTD summon which was disappointing post-13661-1143531603.gif
- He destoyed his soldiers with his own treb, he also destroyed a few TGs too tongue.gif
- He upgraded his horses with forged blades at the beginning with 2 blacksmiths.

As for the heal lag, he never even used heal when you killed his Gandy..

#3FlashJack  Sep 11 2007, 17:44 PM -
Replays: 41 Game:
Awards:
QUOTE(MightyRam @ Sep 11 2007, 18:39 PM) *

It was ok, good in patches but Sammy's strategy was a bit off in places:

- Why did he camp when he had map control? wacko.gif He should have sieged from the outpost. He just sat back waiting for Gandy level 10 or the AOTD summon which was disappointing post-13661-1143531603.gif
- He destoyed his soldiers with his own treb, he also destroyed a few TGs too tongue.gif
- He upgraded his horses with forged blades at the beginning with 2 blacksmiths.

As for the heal lag, he never even used heal when you killed his Gandy..


this was a really good game poose? ohmy.gif
#4HorsemansReturn  Sep 11 2007, 18:35 PM -
Replays: 0
QUOTE(MightyRam @ Sep 11 2007, 18:39 PM) *

It was ok, good in patches but Sammy's strategy was a bit off in places:

- Why did he camp when he had map control? wacko.gif He should have sieged from the outpost. He just sat back waiting for Gandy level 10 or the AOTD summon which was disappointing post-13661-1143531603.gif
- He destoyed his soldiers with his own treb, he also destroyed a few TGs too tongue.gif
- He upgraded his horses with forged blades at the beginning with 2 blacksmiths.

As for the heal lag, he never even used heal when you killed his Gandy..



I completely dis agree with this. I skipped shields because I was afraid of a ent rush so I sold my stable and played for GTW map control. This meant that my horses had to be careful. My GTW died once all game and the reason I did not use heal is because My gandy jumped from one place to another and I could not place a Heal correctly or select the units he was with.

Poose played very well with his micro. I was going to make a stone worker and win that way but i tryed to win without one as it was only ffg.

I was 3 power points from aod at the end of the game and that was winning the pp race. I refused to make a stone worker knowing i would of won with it so I think i deserve some credit for that!
#5FlashJack  Sep 11 2007, 19:08 PM -
Replays: 41 Game:
Awards:
QUOTE(HorsemansReturn @ Sep 11 2007, 19:35 PM) *

I refused to make a stone worker knowing i would of won with it so I think i deserve some credit for that!


so you need SW to win?

why are you still posting? don't you get the message? YOU ARE BANNED.
#6HorsemansReturn  Sep 11 2007, 19:12 PM -
Replays: 0
QUOTE(AniMatoR @ Sep 11 2007, 20:08 PM) *

so you need SW to win?

why are you still posting? don't you get the message? YOU ARE BANNED.


No didnt quite catch the message sorry.
#7Gerrard  Sep 11 2007, 19:20 PM -
Replays: 31 Game:
Awards:

'I refused to make a stone worker knowing i would of won with it so I think i deserve some credit for that!'


well done
This post has been edited by Gerrard: Sep 11 2007, 19:23 PM
#8FlashJack  Sep 11 2007, 19:41 PM -
Replays: 41 Game:
Awards:
sammy people beat rohan without SW, so the fact your saying that doesn't earn you any credit at all

now if everyone needed SW to beat rohan and you beat poose without SW then that will earn you some credit, but since you didn't win and NO-ONE needs SW to beat rohan you deserve nothing smile.gif

btw i watched the replay, man you look like you bought the game a month ago, i would link you to the gondor strat section if you weren't banned
This post has been edited by AniMatoR: Sep 11 2007, 19:43 PM
#9Guardian  Sep 11 2007, 19:44 PM -
Replays: 34 Game:
Awards:
As fun as it is to ban your smurf accounts......

Stop doing it thumb.gif
#10RamRaider  Sep 11 2007, 20:57 PM -
QUOTE(HorsemansReturn @ Sep 11 2007, 19:35 PM) *

I completely dis agree with this. I skipped shields because I was afraid of a ent rush so I sold my stable and played for GTW map control. This meant that my horses had to be careful. My GTW died once all game and the reason I did not use heal is because My gandy jumped from one place to another and I could not place a Heal correctly or select the units he was with.

Poose played very well with his micro. I was going to make a stone worker and win that way but i tryed to win without one as it was only ffg.

I was 3 power points from aod at the end of the game and that was winning the pp race. I refused to make a stone worker knowing i would of won with it so I think i deserve some credit for that!

I never even mentioned shields in my post eyebrow.gif , I just think you should've got more blacksmtihs before equipping forged blades. Poose's micro was very good, I agree with that. I did notice you deleted your SW but really you were sitting in your base with about 8-10 trebs behind your wall, you could've just made an outpost and sieged from there.
Reply to Comment