Battle for Middle Earth

this guy seemed pretty good... nice early game, fast cavalry and legolas at same time as lurtz i managed to win tho.

would like to see where im at and how much i need to improve.

Rename your replay

renamed

Good .

mine

lynxthechosen chose the much older ones please and don't pick the 'might best replays', cause that's not how it works

map-Fords of isen

MiniPurplecow(Isengard)

bo- pit, lumber mill
PP- Warchant,Industry

pros

Extra workers
Scouting with worker
Used formations correctly
Nice creeping

cons

Should use industry on 3 farms every use
Armoury at front of base
Poor lurtz micro
Not the best harrassment

summary-You played a good game and had ok early orc rush resutling in one of his farms destroyed and alot of his peasants you used warchant ok at times but at otehrs you usedd it poorly.Also every time you use industry you should use it on 3 furnaces to get more eco instead of 2 whihc you did a couple of times.You shouldnt build an armoury at the front of the base beacuase in a rush it is the main thing to look for and at the front it will get destroyed first costing you alot of money to rebuild.At times you had poor lurtz micro when you lsot him to legolas when legolas was crippled which is very poor as he cannot move.You didnt have the best harrassment as the farm next to his base was still there.

rating-6



Lemmewin(Rohan)

Bo-2 farms in,Pippin,2 farms out
PP-Draft,Heal

pros

Nice creeping
Killed lurtz with legolas when he was crippled
Used correct position for postern gate
Used formations

cons

Poor early peasant spam
Poor knight micro at times
No worker harrassment with merry
Demolished stable and 5 farms and then rebuilt just for legolas
Should of demolished armoury quicker
Left

summary-You had an ok game by getting fast legolas but i have never seen this before as i didnt really see a point of demolishing a stable and 5 famrs getting legolas and then rebuilding the same again when your old farms would have lvl 2.Also Your early peasant spam was poor as you didnt even get to attack his base you should send one set of peasants down each sides and 2 sets and merry down the middle.Against an isen and mordor player it is a good ideal to use merry to attack his workers forcing him to waste eco rebuying them.When you finished with your armoury you should of demlosished it quicker not just leave it there.You still could of won this game but you left.

rating- 4



Match comments-This was not the best of games where the isengard player and most/total map control resulting into faster upgrades and making the rohan player leave.

entertainment rating- 5

overall rating- 4

thx for review...

i keep left clicking for wc/industry then i usually just rush the right click coz u cant leave ur units for too long.

i think my harassment was very good considering i had all mc.... i almost always leave that 1 farm of rohans coz they can easily bring out fire troops/lego to kill any raiders then get back to base

armory at front isnt that bad of a thing because its next to pit and pikes candefend it much faster if necessary also. i dont know why every1 sees this as a negative

I would only see this as a negative for against Gondor because Isen are most vurnarable to a HS rush.

ya, its more of an issue vs gondor. but iv had it killed like once ever.