Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

2vs2 Cw Pros GI vs RI

#1Dunedain`  Aug 16 2018, 21:34 PM -

Replays: 277 Game:
Awards:
My gondor shanks isen
vs
stiwie rohan alan isengard
#2StiWie`  Aug 17 2018, 00:15 AM -
Awards:
Brag
#3suturbs  Aug 17 2018, 07:56 AM -
Replays: 189 Game:
Awards:
There is a slight difference between "proud" and "brag"...

It is the "attitude". Averagely I find shanks & dunedain ok/fine. (no braggers, or no self-promotion-oriented people).. I will ReView this one asap..
#4suturbs  Aug 19 2018, 11:23 AM -
Replays: 189 Game:
Awards:
Review GI vs RI

Gondor early balde, lost one horse but while killed uruk pit
Isen right side; pretty compatible with Gondor, with chants, palas etc.

Rohan early 2 horses and upgrades, effectively harrasses Isen
Isen left side; had upgrades early, but was not ready to attack yet due to lack health I guess. Thank Gondor mayb.

then...

4 horses, rushs of gondor, active in both defence and simultaneously rushing, getting few towers and a furnace down, etc. Good action.
Isen was rushed by rohan, not enough pikes. Pikes were folowing units, where they should play "region based", not "long distance chasing based".

Rohan had theo 3 till the end, its not something wanted because of late game gaydi and treb.
Isen had lack leadership due to the rain at the time aragorn arrived to the battles. thats because Gondor had fast powerpoints, with good simultane battles across the map, frequently.

btw...

Gandi usage and the way of kiling attempt of rohan's mid was great. Gandi did not use heal at low health, gone to the well, then came back to rush again; Gandi blasts were also fairly good.
Isens ppt's were pretty head to head.

IMHO Rohan should have theo earlier. If Rohan doesn't have a powerful (i.e. Gondor-gaydi ALONE counterable rohan army by theo 4 or alot of Rohirrim Achers), it should be already lost; Aragorn is not balancer/counter stake in such "rain vs rain" games...

Ratings & Reasons

Gondor 9.2/10 -frequent & simultane battles & gandi+horse usage made the point higher. (point 9 requires action pack with results, usage of units 0.1, gandi 0.1 after 9... if he didint lose horse with same results, it could be 9.3 imo )
Isen 8.1/10 need to have enough units to counter horse rushes, and region based pike defence.

Rohan 8.6/10 -everything very good, but 3trd and 4th horses should be switched to theoden i think. he is needed early.
Isen 8.5/10 fast ups, I am not sure if they could rush fast too, but hard due to lack healths they had. needed well, and probably thets why theoden was decided to be later; and 2 mor horse to supress other isen.

* * *

Note 1: Pointage is "coherent into a single game" amap, but it is not yet standardized, for example "compare points between two unrelated games" wouldn't be surely meaningful....
Note 2: Moreover, some of the comments were relied on small observations, and followed generalizations; which may not always reflect the "througout true occurance", thats why I would be happy if the players don't take any evaluation or prejudge personal.
Note 3: Brag or Proud? Be proud but humble and kind too, afterwards doesn't matter how it looked. Congratulations GI team, and thanks to RI; they sure didin't do their best but I am sure they had fun throughout the game...
This post has been edited by suturbs: Aug 19 2018, 11:43 AM
#5RyanLane  Aug 19 2018, 14:27 PM -
Replays: 0
Awards:
QUOTE(suturbs @ Today, 11:23 AM)
Review GI vs RI

Gondor early balde, lost one horse but while killed uruk pit
Isen right side; pretty compatible with Gondor, with chants, palas etc.

Rohan early 2 horses and upgrades, effectively harrasses Isen
Isen left side; had upgrades early, but was not ready to attack yet due to lack health I guess. Thank Gondor mayb.

then...

4 horses, rushs of gondor, active in both defence and simultaneously rushing, getting few towers and a furnace down, etc. Good action.
Isen was rushed by rohan, not enough pikes. Pikes were folowing units, where they should play "region based", not "long distance chasing based".

Rohan had theo 3 till the end, its not something wanted because of late game gaydi and treb.
Isen had lack leadership due to the rain at the time aragorn arrived to the battles. thats because Gondor had fast powerpoints, with good simultane battles across the map, frequently.

btw...

Gandi usage and the way of kiling attempt of rohan's mid was great. Gandi did not use heal at low health, gone to the well, then came back to rush again; Gandi blasts were also fairly good.
Isens ppt's were pretty head to head.

IMHO Rohan should have theo earlier. If Rohan doesn't have a powerful (i.e. Gondor-gaydi ALONE counterable rohan army by theo 4 or alot of Rohirrim Achers), it should be already lost; Aragorn is not balancer/counter stake in such "rain vs rain" games...

Ratings & Reasons

Gondor 9.2/10 -frequent & simultane battles & gandi+horse usage made the point higher. (point 9 requires action pack with results, usage of units 0.1, gandi 0.1 after 9... if he didint lose horse with same results, it could be 9.3 imo )
Isen 8.1/10 need to have enough units to counter horse rushes, and region based pike defence.

Rohan 8.6/10 -everything very good, but 3trd and 4th horses should be switched to theoden i think. he is needed early.
Isen 8.5/10 fast ups, I am not sure if they could rush fast too, but hard due to lack healths they had. needed well, and probably thets why theoden was decided to be later; and 2 mor horse to supress other isen.

* * *

Note 1: Pointage is "coherent into a single game" amap, but it is not yet standardized, for example "compare points between two unrelated games" wouldn't be surely meaningful....
Note 2: Moreover, some of the comments were relied on small observations, and followed generalizations; which may not always reflect the "througout true occurance", thats why I would be happy if the players don't take any evaluation or prejudge personal.
Note 3: Brag or Proud? Be proud but humble and kind too, afterwards doesn't matter how it looked. Congratulations GI team, and thanks to RI; they sure didin't do their best but I am sure they had fun throughout the game...



sick ratings mate, why only 1 wub doe
Reply to Comment