Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

Win with brain [ For Valsa ]

#1Dunedain`  Nov 11 2021, 20:19 PM -

Replays: 263 Game:
Awards:
MVP : Fishy
#2Fishy  Nov 12 2021, 13:44 PM -
Thorin + Felixanius - Mordor + Rohan

++
- Good early strategy - going 3 farms for Mordor, double pit and not messing up with middle and pushing straight for WK pushing your own Mordor far ahead
- Coordinated 1st middle push
- Going straight for Mordor cage with the WK and saving him with heal - great stuff, almost got it before drummer

+
- Not going for any cattas, focusing on important stuff
- Picking 2nd land
- Giving rohan one farm back after Mor has all he needs.
- Nice try with the gollum in Mor base.


Neutral:
- Im not sure about the Scavenger I think the Industry would give more and reliable money

-
- Coordination of moves was lacking. Sometimes it felt like left hand doesnt know what the right hand doing
- Not enough scouting on bottom. Top side had constant flow of orcs so you could see what is going on there but bottom was missing. Hobbit chilling uncloaked in the middle...
- Leaving scouts behind your bases so the other team has open window to see what you cooking.
- Drummer just wanders into enemy army.
- Eowyn die in middle and never comes back.
- Spacing in battle - I think in this MU Mordor combos should work as a buffer which the other trolls have to kill first so the elves have time to snipe them down but you keep both armies together so one land has massive effect because suddenly no LD for elves - they have to go back - trolls catch them.
- Bit too risky with the horses, troll lair wasnt worth the risk imho.

- -
- NO DRUMMER with Rohan army, no drummer in Rohan base.
- Indecisive as hell. Felt like you are hoping for Mordors to push and go for middle. Chilling in middle when you were ready (all spells and units needed) only giving time to Mordors to get the extra units needed (more trolls, 2nd WK and nazghuls)
- Why Legolas? It would be fine if you would be expecting fast Naz or WK but had to be obvious after Mordor took mid that you wouldnt have much use for him. Should have went straight for Archers + Elves in this matchup IMHO.
- Land usage - the other team ends up with 2 lands even though they landed first in both fights. First fight you cover each your lands (rohan should land 1st because you can clearly see when they cover that land) and 2nd big fight Rohan doesnt even cover or use it elsewhere.


Verdict: Sound strategy and unit usage in the first half got you where you needed. Indecisivness and weird build orders from Rohan lost you the advantage. Slopy cooperation was your doom.

Thorin + Felixanius = 5/10


Dunedain + Fishy - Mordor + Mordor

++
- Great cooperation.
- Using industries for biggest advantage (both on one Mordor so he can catch up).
- Best plan after they got mid. In theory should still lose but gives most pressure on R+M pushing them to make mistake if they are weak.
- No pussy build orders - troll domination, big balls. Great trolls usage overall.
- Great scouting - could see what is cooking in both bases.

+
- Not losing anything to the hidden gollum in base
- Getting both troll lairs.
- Going double pit thus keeping some map control and getting important powers fast (Indu + Dark)
- Good base harrasment with nazghuls from Dunedain.

Neutral
- taking middle was kinda ok?? Didnt slow the WK too much because double industry + with faster double siege could work pretty good but in the end went down for free basically + potentionaly it could be more risky. Undecided about this move.


-
- Mor combos going out of base without banner and fire + free food for WK.
- No trolls without tree so Legolas and Theo escapes.

--
- Blue Mordor cashfloating heavily.
- Nazghul wtf - dies in a minute after he is born. Waste of money which should have went to double cage in middle or faster double cage in base.


Verdict: Probably could be easier game for you if it wasnt for the small mistakes but great recovery after losing mid, good team fights and using the free time R+M gave you for maximal profit. Teamwork makes the dream works thumb.gif

Fishy + Dunedain = 8/10


MVP - If I wasnt playing the game I would say Fishy was the MVP due to winning big fights but as I know Dune was telling me what to do and was making the calls it has to be him.

MVP: Dunedain
#3LATINO  Nov 12 2021, 18:50 PM -

Awards:
I am happy you took action after our words of today Fishy.

Good job.
#4Dunedain`  Nov 12 2021, 19:54 PM -

Replays: 263 Game:
Awards:
QUOTE(Fishy @ Yesterday, 19:14 PM)
Thorin + Felixanius - Mordor + Rohan

++
- Good early strategy - going 3 farms for Mordor, double pit and not messing up with middle and pushing straight for WK pushing your own Mordor far ahead
- Coordinated 1st middle push
- Going straight for Mordor cage with the WK and saving him with heal - great stuff, almost got it before drummer

+
- Not going for any cattas, focusing on important stuff
- Picking 2nd land
- Giving rohan one farm back after Mor has all he needs.
- Nice try with the gollum in Mor base.


Neutral:
- Im not sure about the Scavenger I think the Industry would give more and reliable money

-
- Coordination of moves was lacking. Sometimes it felt like left hand doesnt know what the right hand doing
- Not enough scouting on bottom. Top side had constant flow of orcs so you could see what is going on there but bottom was missing. Hobbit chilling uncloaked in the middle...
- Leaving scouts behind your bases so the other team has open window to see what you cooking.
- Drummer just wanders into enemy army.
- Eowyn die in middle and never comes back.
- Spacing in battle - I think in this MU Mordor combos should work as a buffer which the other trolls have to kill first so the elves have time to snipe them down but you keep both armies together so one land has massive effect because suddenly no LD for elves - they have to go back - trolls catch them.
- Bit too risky with the horses, troll lair wasnt worth the risk imho.

- -
- NO DRUMMER with Rohan army, no drummer in Rohan base.
- Indecisive as hell. Felt like you are hoping for Mordors to push and go for middle. Chilling in middle when you were ready (all spells and units needed) only giving time to Mordors to get the extra units needed (more trolls, 2nd WK and nazghuls)
- Why Legolas? It would be fine if you would be expecting fast Naz or WK but had to be obvious after Mordor took mid that you wouldnt have much use for him. Should have went straight for Archers + Elves in this matchup IMHO.
- Land usage - the other team ends up with 2 lands even though they landed first in both fights. First fight you cover each your lands (rohan should land 1st because you can clearly see when they cover that land) and 2nd big fight Rohan doesnt even cover or use it elsewhere.


Verdict: Sound strategy and unit usage in the first half got you where you needed. Indecisivness and weird build orders from Rohan lost you the advantage. Slopy cooperation was your doom.

Thorin + Felixanius = 5/10


Dunedain + Fishy - Mordor + Mordor

++
- Great cooperation.
- Using industries for biggest advantage (both on one Mordor so he can catch up).
- Best plan after they got mid. In theory should still lose but gives most pressure on R+M pushing them to make mistake if they are weak.
- No pussy build orders - troll domination, big balls. Great trolls usage overall.
- Great scouting - could see what is cooking in both bases.

+
- Not losing anything to the hidden gollum in base
- Getting both troll lairs.
- Going double pit thus keeping some map control and getting important powers fast (Indu + Dark)
- Good base harrasment with nazghuls from Dunedain.

Neutral
- taking middle was kinda ok?? Didnt slow the WK too much because double industry + with faster double siege could work pretty good but in the end went down for free basically + potentionaly it could be more risky. Undecided about this move.


-
- Mor combos going out of base without banner and fire + free food for WK.
- No trolls without tree so Legolas and Theo escapes.

--
- Blue Mordor cashfloating heavily.
- Nazghul wtf - dies in a minute after he is born. Waste of money which should have went to double cage in middle or faster double cage in base.


Verdict: Probably could be easier game for you if it wasnt for the small mistakes but great recovery after losing mid, good team fights and using the free time R+M gave you for maximal profit. Teamwork makes the dream works thumb.gif

Fishy + Dunedain = 8/10


MVP - If I wasnt playing the game I would say Fishy was the MVP due to winning big fights but as I know Dune was telling me what to do and was making the calls it has to be him.

MVP: Dunedain


nice review fishy! good job
#5Fishy  Nov 12 2021, 20:48 PM -
QUOTE(LATINO @ Today, 19:50 PM)
I am happy you took action after our words of today Fishy.

Good job.


Speak to me like this again and I will never come back to this site again. I am not joking.
Reply to Comment