Join the community! Sign in
Remember Me Invisible
 
Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

GameReplays Site News
United Nations Countryball...
Happy Holidays!
Stellar Warfare - Brand new...

[R]Grenns vs B13banned

#1Grenness  Aug 17 2006, 17:32 PM -
Posts: 5,543
Replays: 40 Game:
Awards:
i think both need some tips in this matchup wacko.gif plz review
#2Grendel|6  Aug 17 2006, 18:49 PM -
Posts: 139
Replays: 3
Saw the replay, you won vs qm #1 so easily, because your Isen in this match was great. Wy you need some tips in this matchup?

or is that a joke?
#3spanner  Aug 17 2006, 20:28 PM -
Posts: 3,111
Replays: 5 Clan: Teh Memberz Game:
Awards:
^maybe to not give away the result before anyone has seen the game (sigh)
#4Grenness  Aug 17 2006, 20:52 PM -
Posts: 5,543
Replays: 40 Game:
Awards:
QUOTE(Grendel|6 @ Aug 17 2006, 08:49 PM) *

Saw the replay, you won vs qm #1 so easily, because your Isen in this match was great. Wy you need some tips in this matchup?

or is that a joke?


its a joke tbh. i just want to c my score in this game banana.gif
#5shaulin  Aug 17 2006, 21:26 PM -
Posts: 2,280
Replays: 2 Clan: [ChoseN] Game:
Awards:
are you submitting this just to show a match you dominated vs a good player?

if you actually want a review i will do it.

Mine.
#6Grenness  Aug 17 2006, 21:34 PM -
Posts: 5,543
Replays: 40 Game:
Awards:
biggrin.gif thx shauling wacko.gif i wont post it if i dont want it reviewed tbh wacko.gif
#7shaulin  Aug 18 2006, 22:44 PM -
Posts: 2,280
Replays: 2 Clan: [ChoseN] Game:
Awards:
IPB ImageB13BannedIPB Image
VS
IPB ImageGrennessIPB Image

Map: Fords of Isen
IPB Image
Patch: 1.03

--------------------------------------------------------------------

IPB ImageB13BannedIPB Image

Starting Bo: Blacksmith+Farm--> 2 outer farms
PP progression: Elven Wood ~ Heal ~ Rohirim allies
General Strat: Cavalry ~ Farimir ~ Archers ~ Combos

Pros
smile.gif Got most of the creeps
 smile.gif Produced the right counter units for his pikes
 smile.gif kept all your horse batts until very late game

Cons
sad.gif Placed Elven Wood before he had used Warchant
 sad.gif Lost both of your farms early game
 sad.gif Should of produced some Tower Guards to counter his wargs

Comments
i found it hard picking on specific flaws in your play, you generally knew the strat and knew what to do to counter him, you just coudln't seem to pull it off, isen pushed you back early and you seemed quite content on staying there, you had the units to push back but you just didn't get out of your base enough.
your micro was actually quite good, you kept your three horses throughout most of the game, losing them very late.
you got 4 out of the 6 creeps which helped your early economy ans took money away from isen.
You lost farimir in the final battle but i got the feeling you had given up by this point.
you should of harrassed a lot more and i think forged blades would of really helped your harrassment.

Rating: 4/10

--------------------------------------------------------------------

IPB ImageGrennessIPB Image

Starting Bo: pit --> 2 mills
PP progression: Warchant ~ Industry
General strat: Uruks ~ Xbows ~ Pikes ~ Upps ~ Wargs ~ Siege

Pros
smile.gif Good formation use
 smile.gif Took both his farms down, slowing his horses nicely
 smile.gif Armoury at back of base, then replacing with warg pit
 smile.gif vStopped his HS harrassment
 smile.gif Killed fara

Cons
sad.gif Could of got your pikes out faster
 sad.gif Idle units at times
 sad.gif the outpost your siege was coming from was completely unguarded

Comments
You played a good solid game, although you seemed to push greatly through the middle of the map and the upper and lower areas of the map were very much up for grabs, a few more pikes would of secured complete MC for you.
You lost very little units and never lost a hero, you managed to steal 2 creeps right from under knights which i really liked and the money gave you a little boost.
you didnt harrass too much in mid-late game, i think 1 batt of pikes with FB would of taken all his farms and given you a great eco.
you could of finished the game a lot sooner if you hadnt played as passive in mid game.

Rating 6/10

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Comments
The isengard had a good game and was never in any critical situations and the win felt a certaintinty throughout the game. the gondor never seemed to be aggressive enough and never pushed back after being pinned into his base. this game would of been a lot shorter if the isen had made the seige faster as gondor couldnt have stopped it. Was an ok game and seemed a pretty easy win for isengard.

Entertainment Rating: 4
Game rating: 4
Reply to Comment
 
10 user(s) active in the past 15 minutes. 10 guests and 0 members.
About | Privacy Policy | Contact | Help System
© 2024 GameReplays.org -- Invision Power Board © 2024 IPS, Inc. Licensed to: GameReplays.org