Battle for Middle Earth

For fun game VS light bull and rank 11

Some decent action in this one.

Review please!

review plz i need all the feedback i can get o.0

Istari=Maverick btw.

mine

raivuki is rank 4 now, if im not mistaken

You forgot this one....come on guys, dont tag replays and then forget about them, this is the 3rd ive found ( not all from you axcell )

Team 1

Half|Zero (Gondor)

Starting BO: 2 farms in, Merry, 2out
Strat: 3 knights-> HS-> middle-> Faramir + ups-> trebs-> Gandalf-> soldierarchercombo's
PP: Heal - GtW

MaVerick727 (Rohan)

Starting BO: 2 farms in, Merry, 2 out
Strat: 3 extra peasents-> 2 rohirrim + Theoden-> ups-> peasentyeomancombo's-> Aragorn-> Entmoot
PP: Draft - Heal - Anduril

Pros

Kept them under pressure
Got middle quick when you had the advantage
Harassing
Deleted stable after HS
Nice rush on isen's base
Killed Gandalf with IL + WA (classicer)


Cons

Didn't give Theoden the exp from the troll creep
Theoden got easily pinned during the baserush
Didn't aim for Saruman, he easily converted the peoman, even with some little delay
Sloppy treb protection during fight

Comments
You did an ok job. You had no trouble taking the middle and keeping it because isen didn't interfere at all. Rush on isen was good, though theoden should be kept a little more behind in order to avoid Lurtz. Good choise of units for ur siege army. Not really much to say, you were given an easy win.

Overall gameplay Team 1: 5,5



Team 2

PL4YBOY (Isen)

Starting BO: pit, 2 mills, uruk
Strat: 2 uruks, 2 xbows-> pikexbowcombo's + ups-> Lurtz-> Saruman-> ballista's
PP: WC - Industry

Raivuki (Gondor)

Starting BO: BS, Farm, Pippin, 1 out
Strat: 3 knights-> HS-> Faramir-> ups-> Gandalf-> trebs
PP: Heal - GtW

Pros

Isen 3 farms
Destroyed armory right after you bought allups
Kept using WA to get your Faramir lvl 5 (though his leadership didn't really became useful)
IL + WA gandy kill
Decent use of Saruman

Cons

Cash floated a bit early game and huge end game
Kept on the defense, you had the oppurtunity to make a better rush then theirs
Far to passive early, they got middle too easily
Slow in response to counter the baserush
Spreaded out your army's, made them vulnerable at he end

Comments
Being to passive and waiting for them to make mistakes cost you the game. Early, Isen should have spammed some pikes to help fighting against their horses. When they got the middle isen still would have been able to reclaim it with the help of Gondor within a few minutes. They had only horses, they had not much defense against pikes or pikexbowcombo's. That's easy for me to say but you could have known that they couldn't have archers that early or you could have scouted. Eventuelly Gondor gained profit from the midlle and was able to make trbes and gandalf as well. In the end you waited for them too make a mistake so you could finish their trebs of. Eventuelly that did happen. Though the fight could have been won if isen had used it's money to reinforce his army during the fight. At the start of the fight you had already 3k i think. At the end you had 8k.

Overall gameplay team 2: 4


Entertainment
Alot of small early fights, after that some rushing. Team 2, especially isen keeping passive. The last fight was fun too watch, but overall the game wasn't that exciting

Entertainment: 4

Team 1: 5,5
Team 2: 4

Game rating: 5-