Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] [BD]VanShooter vs LAL|Maverick

#1FarMeR`  Jan 1 2007, 21:58 PM -
Replays: 30 Game:
well here you go , great match in vans and my opionion
i could of won it if i just waited a little longer and got trebs, but he is really against them so i gave him a break
review greatly appreciated biggrin.gif

*i advise rr to fast forward abit near the end *
#2PlaTy  Jan 1 2007, 23:57 PM -
This is the game you mentioned?

Ill watch, but i gotta say, make trebs if you can don't go be all fair tongue.gif
#3FarMeR`  Jan 2 2007, 00:25 AM -
Replays: 30 Game:
ya wish idid sad.gif
lvl 10 elves pwn :\
#4Krys1er  Jan 2 2007, 01:39 AM -
Replays: 22 Game:
maverick mate, its cw. its perfectly acceptable to lame fire trebs in cw.
#5FarMeR`  Jan 7 2007, 18:36 PM -
Replays: 30 Game:
#6FarMeR`  Jan 9 2007, 00:07 AM -
Replays: 30 Game:
anyone want to review?
#7OnFiRe  Jan 9 2007, 01:46 AM -
Replays: 14 Game:
I'll review

m m m m m MINE
#8OnFiRe  Jan 9 2007, 04:44 AM -
Replays: 14 Game:
LAL|Maverick (Gondor) VS [BD]VanShooter (Rohan)

Map: Fords of Isengard
Patch: 1.03

LAL|Maverick (Gondor)

Starting Bo: 2 Farms in and out
PP progression: Heal>Elven wood>Gandalf the white>Elven allies>Eagles>Rohhirm>Army of the dead>Cloud break
Strat> Cavalry>Horse shields>Gandalf>Forged blades and Armor>Faramir>Combos>Fire>Banner carrier upgrade>Tower guards>Trebs>Firestone>Boromir

Creeps 3/6


* Fairly good creeping
* Good formation use
* Killed a lot his hero's
* Good lightning sword casts

* Poor harassment at times
* Lost your hero's a lot middle-late game, sometimes to sloppy micro
* Attacked Rohan at his outpost where he had a well, statue and all ls, and lost all army, then did it again wacko.gif. If you got trebs you could won then.
* Bad use summons at times. Eg. running all rohhirm summon into aod laugh.gif

Comment: A fairly good early game for you, you got 3/6 creeps which was fairly good, and your harassment was good and you got all map control, but then you lost it all and didn't claim it back. The thing that lost you the game is because you attack rohan at the outpost when he had all ls fu, elves and horse archers and a statue and well, then you did it again wacko.gif. You should waited and got some trebs and you could won then. You also where clumsy with hero's at times, and with summons.

Rating: 4/10

[BD]VanShooter (Rohan)

Starting Bo: 2 Farms in and out
PP Progression: Draft>Heal>Elven wood>Anduril>Ents>Army of the dead>Elven allies>Cloud break
Strat: Peasant spam>Rohhirm>Eomer>Theoden>Eowyn>Legolas>Armor>Horse archers>Forged blades>Banner carrier>Yeomen>Fire>Elves>Aragorn

Creeps: 3/6

* Fairly good creeping.
* Good use of hero's special ability's.
* Killed a lot of his hero's.
* Good formation use.
* Good use of the spear throwers early game.

* Lost a lot of hero's sometimes to bad micro.
* Wasted some summons
* Lost some battalions of rohhirm to Gandalf

Comment: A good comeback from you this game, mainly because of Gondor major mistakes. Your creeping was ok, but should be better since you get rohhirm before Gondor gets cavalry, and your harassment was bad in parts of the game, where you stood outside base and didn't nothing with your horse. After you lost you main base, it looked like gg, but Gondor stupid mistake of attacking you at outpost losing him his whole army, then him doing it again, helped you out a lot. Good use of hero's ability's from you tho, and good comeback.

Rating: 5/10

Overall: An extremely long game, which gondor should won easily after he took Rohans castle, but made some stupid mistakes when he could got trebs and won. Lots mistakes made by both sides and some bits where both Gondor and Rohan lack harassment makes the game uninteresting at parts. A very long game to watch and not that entertaining.

Overall: 4/10

Entertainment: 5/10
This post has been edited by OnFiRe: Jan 9 2007, 04:48 AM
#9FarMeR`  Jan 9 2007, 22:27 PM -
Replays: 30 Game:
i agree i played crappy after watching, it seemed lot better while playing tongue.gif
he did very different strat
i hate host difference so much =( i won my host he won his host same mu.... thats in almost every match i play wacko.gif
This post has been edited by DanceAndRomance: Jan 9 2007, 22:30 PM
#10Grenness  Jan 9 2007, 23:22 PM -
Replays: 40 Game:
maybe the reivews are a bit too harsh laugh.gif i would give 5 sleep.gif
Reply to Comment