Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] Dbl rohan vs gondor/isen 2v2 cw

#1Mavs  Nov 1 2006, 19:42 PM -
The first time I posted this game it got locked because some ppl thought it was necessary to get it locked again and I was dumb enough to keep replying to them. So I would be thankful if you guys could give this game another shot. post-13661-1143531603.gif
#2general grievous^  Nov 1 2006, 21:41 PM -
How come some people have a * next to their name in the replays? I noticed this with the other game you posted in the 1on1 section
#3Mavs  Nov 2 2006, 05:45 AM -
yeah that's the 2nd time I've seen it now. tbh I have no idea
#4LiGhT`  Nov 2 2006, 18:55 PM -
Awards:
Gen go read in the central staff rooms..... Kiltec or someone made a topic stating it smile.gif
#5PhoenixPrince  Nov 2 2006, 22:19 PM -
Mine, I will do it tonight. and yes this is in order, only two games arn't reviewd on the last to pages, 1 of them I don't think the person wants a review, and the 2nd one is daemon's 3v3 and both striker and gen have said they would do it at one point or another so I'm leaving it to them.
#6Mavs  Nov 3 2006, 11:39 AM -
alright cool. Thanks a lot phoenix smile.gif
#7PhoenixPrince  Nov 3 2006, 23:35 PM -
B2P|MaVsIPB Image & B2P|Wonder’IPB Image
V
esa|QuiGonIPB Image & esa|Pr0haNIPB Image


Map: Anorien

IPB Image

Patch: 1.03


_____________________________________________________________________________


Team 1

B2P|MaVs IPB Image

Power point progression
Draft>heal>Anduril

Basic build order
2 farms in>1 farm out>2 extra peasant>fill base with farms>archery range>peos>armory>ara>lego


B2P|Wonder’IPB Image

Power point progression
Draft>Heal>elves

Basic build order
1 farm in> 3 farms out>1 farm in>1 extra peasant>stable>2 cav>fill base with farms>theo>rohirrum archer>armory>lego>ra’s


Creeps
1/4

Pros

biggrin.gif Hobbit micro

biggrin.gif Good starting rush

biggrin.gif Good harassment

biggrin.gif Good horse micro


Cons

frusty.gif A little bad build spot management (deleting farm for well when you had an extra build spot)

frusty.gif Not much harassment late game.


Team summery

You guys played excellently. Mavs you cash floated a bit early game, not buying farms right when you got enough money. Wonder you didn’t harass quiet enough late game, but other than that pretty solid. Great strat, one that I will try in the future.

7/10


Team 2

esa|QuiGonIPB Image

Power point progression
Warchant>tainted land

Basic build order
Pit>mill>extra uruk>2 mills>uruk>xbow>3 furnace>xbow>pikes>fill base with furnace>armory>swordsman spam with a few pikes


esa|Pr0haNIPB Image

Power point progression
Heal>gtw

Basic build order
2 farms in>farm out>2 farm in>bs>stable>3 knights and 2 bs>Gandalf>Farameir>trebs>>remake stable and knights


Creeps
3/4

Pros

biggrin.gif Good creeping

biggrin.gif Extra labs

biggrin.gif Good harassment early-mid game


Cons

frusty.gif Cash floating

frusty.gif Bad build spot management

frusty.gif No harassment mid-late game

frusty.gif Bad micro whenever there was a large battle


Team 2 summery

You guys played pretty good. Gondor you were indecisive with your starting soldiers, and you made one more farm then you should have before stables. Isen you cash floated really bad, you had like 2000 when you bought armory, you also didn’t make enough pikes at any point of the game. Gondor gandy rush just doesn’t really work anymore; I wouldn’t of used that strat. You guys also seemed to fall apart during bit battles, losing many key units. Other than these things you guys played very well though.

6/10



Game summery

Early game B2P did a great job of keeping the pressure on. They cloaked their hobbit next to isen’s mill, which severely crippled his econ for much of the game. When horses came out wonder showed he was no slouch and managed to out-micro prohan. B2P then executed a very good rush on isen’s base with mavs combos and crippled him, esa had no chance of fending the attack off as prohan was rushing gandy and hadn’t got him yet. Once prohan did get gandy B2P made the wise decision to back off and play it smart. Another large battle ensued after both sides had build up armies; esa’s micro was sub-par and B2P won with ease. After this it was gg esa.

Overall game rating 6/10
Entertainment rating 5/10

#8Mavs  Nov 4 2006, 11:51 AM -
Great review. Like the colors biggrin.gif
thanks wub.gif
#9PhoenixPrince  Nov 4 2006, 16:18 PM -
Your weclome, I like the colors to biggrin.gif

Was a nightmare to keep track of though, I had to watch the whole thing 3 times!
#10Mavs  Nov 4 2006, 18:25 PM -
lol laugh.gif
Reply to Comment