Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] 1v1 ce vs elder|malex

#1Mavs  Sep 30 2006, 23:31 PM -
Man when my gandy died once my pulse was at 180 ffs. It was a really gg I think. Probably not on the highest standard, since I'm not a very good 1v1 player. Can someone give me any more tips on what I can do with gondor vs rohan? And what I could've done better
Review plz thanks

Light, I forgot to rename the rep on damned time....don't be so stinky about it just because you hate me dry.gif

renamed, HAPPY?
This post has been edited by Duke of Wellington: Sep 30 2006, 23:31 PM
#2LiGhT`  Oct 1 2006, 00:20 AM -
Awards:
1. yes im happy now smile.gif

2. no i dont hate you smile.gif

3. it is a rule that if a replay hasnt been renamed then we are permitted to lock it, and a member such as yourself who posts game regularly and has been told about it several times you should of known. sleep.gif
#3Mavs  Oct 1 2006, 02:49 AM -
I forgot, I am human after all.
#4LiGhT`  Oct 1 2006, 23:00 PM -
Awards:
Out of the kindness of my heart - I will take it, expect tomoro
#5Mavs  Oct 2 2006, 04:41 AM -
thanks smile.gif
#6LiGhT`  Oct 2 2006, 20:44 PM -
Awards:
PPFTW|PointPush (Gondor) v |elder|malex (Rohan)
Map - Fords of Isengard



PPFTW|PointPush (Gondor)

BO- 2 farms in, Hobbit, 2 farms out

PP Selection- Heal--> Land--> GTW--> Rohirrim--> Eagles--> AoD

Strat- Knights--> Fara--> Grades--> Horse shields--> boromir--> Soldiers--> tower guards--> Gandy--> Trebs


Pros
smile.gif Fast grades
smile.gif Good harassment
smile.gif Kill Aragorn fast
smile.gif Good use of Gandys powers
smile.gif All heroes ld

Cons
sad.gif Didn't let Fara take the lair kill
sad.gif Lossed fara easily
sad.gif Lossed Gandy easily
sad.gif Could of spammed land more

Comments- Good choice early to keep your soldiers nearby your farms which didnt cost you a thing. Then got your knights out pretty fast and began to creep, imo you should of harassed with your first knights seeing as you didnt touch his mills at the start. Nice abuse of fara early game making it hard for him to leave his castle without giving you some exp/PP but the second you seen him get Theo, you should of mounted Fara and ran like the wind. You had no chance to escape once he was attacking you, but you made a hasty recovery and it didn't seemto phase you. Nice choice to only get TG, alot of people wouldof got combos but it worked excellently for you. You lossed gandy pretty easily, but there was no pressure on you, Rohan didnt have the army or the econ to seige you, and once you had regrouped and gathered strength, you shown gondors full ld working excellently.

Rating- 6

___________________________________________


|elder|malex (Rohan)

BO- 1 farm in, hobbit, 2 farms out

PP- Draft--> Heal--> Anduril--> Land--> Elves

Strat- Rohirrim--> Grades--> Theoden--> Aragorn--> Legolas--> Yeoman--> Gimli--> Fire--> Combos--> Rohirrim archers


Pros
smile.gif Very fast Rohirrim
smile.gif Good harassment
smile.gif Fast grades
smile.gif Ranked Theo up fast
smile.gif Fast GC

Cons
sad.gif Horse micro
sad.gif Lost Aragorn straight after buying him
sad.gif Hero micro
sad.gif Gimli?!?! - an army first and then maybe gimli would of been far better

Comments- I have never seen your starting strat used before, but i think you shouldn't use it and stick to a normal rohan BO of 2 farms in, he had his knights 1/4 done and a good econ when your first rohirrim came out and your econ was bad. However, excellent harassment throughout the game and got fast grades to counter him, showing you know the MU good. Once you got your upgrades and theo, you should of instantly gone for ents imo, it may not of won you the game ( probably wouldnt of ) but it could of crippled him bad, took down a wall or 2 and allowed you to harass the castle at times and perhaps forcing him to rebuild the walls. Im not sure why you bought gimli, that late in a game he is pretty useless unless u can get slayer. Some poor hero micro by you tilted the game in gondors favour.

Rating- 5

Final Comments

Pretty nice game to watch with a couple little fights that were good, could of been a possible higher rating but the couple mistakes and hero losses took it down a notch.

Overall Rating- 5
Entertainment- 5


LiGhT`
#7Mavs  Oct 2 2006, 21:18 PM -
damnit! mad.gif

Thanks biggrin.gif
#8LiGhT`  Oct 2 2006, 21:24 PM -
Awards:
no probs smile.gif
Reply to Comment