Battle for Middle Earth

nice game imo although he played crap in his own host. Nvm, a review is needed
mu is : me mordor him gondor

claimed for me

omg noooo my worst ive ever played

review by HALdir


Map: fords of isen
Starlita upper left
Hosaf bottem right



Starlita
(4 creeps)
BO: 2farms in, pip, outer farms, stable,well,BS,rax,range,sisters,Gtw
strat: Hs rush, sisters, combos, Gtw

PP: heal,elves,Gtw

PROS:
u managed to destroy his cage
decent harass early-midgame
fara micro


CONS:
horrible hero and combo micro late game
poor hobbit micro early game
lossed all 3 high ranked knights
u should have known that after a while that hosaf was building a troll army and that boromir rank 3 and 4 rank 1 combos with HA and FA wont stand a chance. u lossed them all at ur outpost
cashfloat between mid-late game

comments: ur early game was ok. pippin should have been more agressive in harass or (what u tried) creep and if orcsis come then u intercep them. nice HS rush. however u needed Gandalf after hS rush.
he could have won the game for u back then. first take back MC then attack or w8 and make combos. u stopped harassment mid-late game and thats y mordors econ grew very big. mordor late game>>>>all so gg from u by then.


rating: 5



Hosaf
(2 creeps)
BO: pit+gollem, SHs, cage, twers,troll army,Wk,combos and mumaks
strat: orc spam,troll,naz,mass troll with LD ,WK and combos +mumaks
PP: eye,land,industry,darkness

PROS:
creeping with orcs
took back MC with orcs
nice harassment orcs whole game
no major mistakes
extra towers to delay his HS rush


COnS:
no extra labs from all the mills mid-late game(besides the 2 near base)
bad naz micro
could have bought darkness earlier and casted it

comments:u played well i must say. no big mistakes. orc micro was good. didnt waste much trolls. u managed to hold off a HS rush and got back MC. 1s u killed all his men at that outpost it was GG for him. nice played

rating: 7

overall comments:
Starlita started well with his knights and got MC. HS rush however didnt work that well and lossed all his 3 batts of high ranked knights later on: result: thats bye MC. HOsaf kept MC with his orcsis. a good rep. for players that need help on this matchup.


GG GUYS

Entartainment: 6

overall rate: 6

thx good review

Good review for his second application. I agree with all his ratings except the entertainment which should be made a 5. Nothing serious though. I will post these ratings as official.