Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

Major and Dinn III

#1Dinn  Mar 20 2006, 09:52 AM -
Replays: 7 Game:
Awards:
Well, Major gave me the go on this one too, so might as well smile.gif

In this one, Major had a distraction when he attacked my outpost...so he didnt quite control any of the units there.

gg nonetheless... review please smile.gif

(It's named with a (re) cuz this was the first game we played that day)[attachmentid=82499]
This post has been edited by Daemonette: Mar 28 2006, 16:16 PM
#2Jobbies  Mar 20 2006, 17:56 PM -
Spammers sleep.gif wub.gif
#3IVERSON  Mar 22 2006, 02:22 AM -
Replays: 18 Game:
Awards:
MINE biggrin.gif ill have it by tommorow or tonight. I love rohan vs isengard's most interesting match up IMO.
This post has been edited by danthedangerous: Mar 22 2006, 03:59 AM
#4IVERSON  Mar 22 2006, 23:13 PM -
Replays: 18 Game:
Awards:
[WISE]MAJ0R VS Dinn

Review by: DanTheDangerous



Map: Fords of isen
Duration: Medium
Version: 1.03
[WISE]MAJ0R-Isengard vs Dinn-rohan


[WISE]MAJ0R

Build Order: Pit, Furnace X5, Armoury.
Powerpoint Progression: Warchant, Plantir, Industry, Devastation.
Strat: 3 uruk strat.


Pro's

smile.gif Used formation on uruks
smile.gif Made extrat labourers for extra resources.
smile.gif Fast creeping with X-Bows
smile.gif Sent berserkers to deal with peasents.
smile.gif combined X-bows and Uruki for bonus.
smile.gif Put X-bows in outpost to protect them.
smile.gif No cash floating.


Con's

sad.gif Wasted a WC on 1 berserker.


Comment's

Great game biggrin.gif. You showed the 3 uruk strat perfectly. And had outstanding micro and macro. but the lack of creeps taken on your side and his theoden finding your battalions of unprotected units lost you this game. IMO if you would have pumped out about 5 berskers to run around and take creeps you could have prevented his theo from getting GC. And a faster seige works, for ballistas to kill cripled heros and deal with those powerfull yeomen may have saved you this game.

Overal rating for [WISE]MAJ0R: 7


Dinn

Build Order: Farm X4, Stable, Farm X2, (demo stable), Archery range, (demo farm), Armoury
PowerPoint progresion: Draft, Heal, Anduril, Summon Ents.
Strat: 4 rohirm/Theo - Archery range - 4 yeomen - Armoury


Pro's

smile.gif Good pip harrasement.
smile.gif Made extra peasents from base.
smile.gif Stole one of isengards creeps.
smile.gif Got GC
smile.gif Combined peasents + Yeomen for bonus
smile.gif Got a squad of horses rank 10.


Con's

sad.gif Should have gotten Summon elves to kill Pikes when yeomen were not around.


Comment's

GG Dinn you showed amazing micro and macro skills and made barely any mistakes. You perfectly counterd anything he threw at you. But remember to put horses in formatin while in GC to maxout its affect. And to put those elves inside your outpost to protect them from any of those smelly Uruki while under attack biggrin.gif.

Dinns overal rating: 9


Summary

A farily entertaining game that shows lots of skill deffinitly a ROTW conntender.

Entertainment value: 6

Overal rating: 8

PS-Going to whatch again to see if its worth a silver.
This post has been edited by danthedangerous: Mar 22 2006, 23:14 PM
#5Major  Mar 22 2006, 23:52 PM -
Awards:
2 things: Dinn really deserves the 9, he made no mistakes, always made good choices and amazing micro.
second: there was a bug where the xbows in the tower do not shoot (early on)-dunno how this would've changed the match.

I think this would be a 7, since 8 is usualy gold wink.gif (no such thing as 10).
This post has been edited by Major: Mar 23 2006, 00:01 AM
#6Daemon  Mar 23 2006, 00:06 AM -
I watched this match and I think there is enough ambiguity for it to be put to a gold poll in the promotion contenders staff forum. We can all have a look and decide in the poll.

I think dan's review is an excellent one. Well done dan thumb.gif , a blinding review for a first one out of the box in your RR career. I watched the game straight after I saw your rating wondering if it was a noob rating mistake but I think this game is definitely a Silver Replay and possibly an 8.

dan, go to the place where the replays of the week are posted and in that forum make a gold poll with this replay thread linked in that poll. The poll should just be: Should this replay be a gold replay, yes or no.

Go for it. We might have our first 1.03 Gold replay.
#7Major  Mar 23 2006, 00:08 AM -
Awards:
QUOTE
I watched this match and I think there is enough ambiguity for it to be put to a gold poll in the promotion contenders staff forum. We can all have a look and decide in the poll.

I think dan's review is an excellent one. Well done dan , a blinding review for a first one out of the box in your RR career. I watched the game straight after I saw your rating wondering if it was a noob rating mistake but I think this game is definitely a Silver Replay and possibly an 8.

dan, go to the place where the replays of the week are posted and in that forum make a gold poll with this replay thread linked in that poll. The poll should just be: Should this replay be a gold replay, yes or no.

Go for it. We might have our first 1.03 Gold replay.


omg, Daemonette really thinks it's worth an 8 ohmy.gif
wonder what Elven thinks of this biggrin.gif

wub.gif
#8WISE Architect  Mar 23 2006, 00:21 AM -
Awards:
Major and Dinn pwn biggrin.gif

Ill wach this one tomorrow ^^
#9Jobbies  Mar 23 2006, 00:23 AM -
I'll deffinatly watch, since it's my job and i've already sayed i want to do the newspost if it's a gold biggrin.gif

GL major and dinn wub.gif
#10Daemon  Mar 23 2006, 00:24 AM -
*cough* I'm sure danthedangerous should have picked an OLDER replay to review first though. whistling.gif
Reply to Comment