Battle for Middle Earth

[attachmentid=185531]
pretty decent match up here, some foolish mistakes on both sides but a gg none the less
review would be nice thanks

Ill do this 2morrow
Tagged.

thx gammy

Review by Gamroth:
AutO{ZONE} (Gondor) vs whowhatme (Isengard)
Map: Fords of Isen

AutO{ZONE} (Gondor)

BO/Strat: Farm, Farm, Merry -> Stables -> Knights -> Soldiers -> HS -> Upgrades -> TG's -> Archers -> Fara -> Gandalf
PP: EW -> Elven Allies -> Heal -> GtW -> Rohirrim
Creeps: 4/6

PROS:
+ stole creep from pikes
+ soldiers to keep MC from harassing pikes
+ nice EW spam
+ horse micro
+ finished off warg batt using Gandy's IL

Positive Comments:
A very well executed game from you. You used a nice strat and played it very well. Very nice horse micro throughout the game - you never lost a batt. Nice spamming of EW in key locations. Nice elven summons.

CONS:
- not a great start - defensive EW
- Rohirrim allies poorly used

Negative Comments/Points for improvement:
If i were you i would consider using a double soldier rush to isens mills. Send both your starting soldiers forwards and place EW offensively. Using this you should, most of the time, take down an isen mill. Other than this, and a couple of questionable uses of Rohirrim allies, you played a very nice game. GJ.

Player Rating: 7


whowhatme (Isengard)

BO/Strat: Pit+uruk -> mills -> furns -> pikes -> wargs -> upgrades + lurtz
PP: WC -> Palantir -> Industry -> TL -> rain
Creeps: 2/6

PROS:
+ stoppped soldiers creeping
+ quick wargs + palantir
+ killed boro with ballistas

Positive Comments:
A nice start going to his side of the map and using an offensive War Chant, BUT remember War Chant is still active once you come off the wood so you could have still beaten his soldiers. Quick wargs was a good idea and you made several attempts to kill knights with palantir.

CONS:
- didnt make use of your offensive chant (see above)
- lost a near whole batt of xbows to a warg creep
- formation use for pikes
- Used TL when you knew he had EW

Negative Comments/Points for improvement:
As mentioned before about your chant, remember that it is still active you just cant see it anymore. Make sure you make use of it. You were a little quick to use palantir on your wargs, it is not permanent so dont use until his knights start to run, then nail them. Also you were very slow with pike formations and you missed a few chances to kill off some knights. Id recommend making more pikes next MU and leaving some at your base for defence as knights just ripped it apart.

Player Rating: 4

Game Summary:
A well played Gondor vs Isen. Gondor was on top for most of the game and kept pressure on isen making it difficult for isen to assemble an army. Isen could never quite get back into the game and was subdued by gondor knight, Gandy, combos and brothers. GG Guys

Overall Game Rating: 5
Entertainment Rating: 5

thanks for the review gammy