Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] PooseIsenvsPlow|B9KillerGondor

#1Poose  Dec 1 2006, 00:25 AM -
Awards:
gg!
#2Deterex  Dec 1 2006, 00:30 AM -
Replays: 12 Game:
I already posted
nvm urs was first sad.gif
in this game my main problem was losing horses I lost all three by the end and really couldnt count Uruks that well
but all in all a vgg
I need a re tomorrow on my host smile.gif
This post has been edited by Deterex: Dec 1 2006, 00:40 AM
#3Deterex  Dec 2 2006, 23:55 PM -
Replays: 12 Game:
bump
#4Deterex  Dec 5 2006, 14:42 PM -
Replays: 12 Game:
bump plz some1 review sad.gif
#5DunedainStriker  Dec 6 2006, 22:35 PM -
it will get one eventually, once it is oldest unreviewed rep sad.gif sorry about the waits atm guys
#6acerrak  Dec 8 2006, 22:37 PM -
Replays: 16 Game:
Mine for review
#7acerrak  Dec 9 2006, 04:33 AM -
Replays: 16 Game:
Checkbook (Isengard) [attachmentid=175965] VS Plow|B9killer (Gondor) [attachmentid=175966]
Fords of Isen
Top: Gondor
Bottum: Isengard


Plow|B9killer(Gondor)[attachmentid=175966]

B.O. 2 farms in > 2 out > 1 in stables > horses > brothers combos/tg's
P.P Elven wood > Heal > Rohirrim > eagles > Aotd > elves

Creeps 2/6

Pros
+Horse mircro in the begining was good, till the seige on your base started were you lost them, good zig zag to avoid palantir wargs
+Good use of summoned Rohirrim to kill catas and finish off saruman Eagles the same
+Placed a statue in base to help defend againt attacks from Isengard
+Kept a creep for boramir to lvl up for damage bonus
+Killed Isengards heros multiple times

Cons
-running horses in wedge, and trampling through pikes with them
-stopped spamming Ew after the second one, you could have squeezed one more free bee out there
-Combined TG with gondor archer, also spammed a few more Tg's but never rebuilt a archery range after you lost half of your combos
-late to rebuild stables plus you could have taken that bottum outpost earlier to help with cash

Player Summary

You played a good game overall, you brought a variety of units into play and was holding back Isengards wave of attacks, you could have made more attempts at Isengards base once you got Hs on your horses but didnt, used summons to help defend but in the end Money became your problem and the constant spam of Cata's from Isengard slowly ate away at you, Till he got Balrog to Finish off your main base.

Player rating 6


Checkbook (Isengard)[attachmentid=175965]

B.O. Pit > 2 mIlls 5 Uraks to pike spam > lurtz > wargs Seige/ combos
P.P. warchant > Industry > Palantir > Rain > Balrog

Creeps 4\6

Pros
+Stole a creep with lurtz using carnage on his horses then killing creep, also level 6 for full abilities
+4/6 creeps good work
+using palantir, howl and warchant on wargs to try and kill gondors knights
+use of wormtongue on some of gondors combos
+kept spamming catas to his base to keep pressure
+Good balrog use to finish off Gondors base

Cons
-built 2 warg pits at the same time? you bought one from each then they sat there for a bit before u demolished one
-during first seige attempt all 4 bats of wargs chased knights into gondors base and they were all lost
-poor cata protection mostly early on
-also took you a little while to rebuild warg pit and get some more wargs out

Player Summary
Good game by you, initial spam in the beginning destroying one of gondors farms and taking a almost destroyed creep from pipin, one thing i suggest is your first set of pikes send them to the enemy side then up to your mills. You did Isengard by text, spamming initial units to wargs upgrades and seige. Once you layed seige to gondor you kept the pressure on him even though he used summons very well to keep you back. He played a good defense but your balrog useage finished off the base and left him with one outpost.

Player Rating 6

Game Summary
This was a good match-up some mistakes on both sides but overall a good dispaly of each faction, I think Gondor should have tried to do some more hit and runs on Isengards base but Isengard came with fast seige and gondor was ready for it, In the End it took the Balrog to finish off gondors main base

Entertainment 6
Overall Score 6

[attachmentid=175967]
Isengard Victory

Rotw Contender
This post has been edited by acerrak: Dec 13 2006, 02:56 AM
Reply to Comment