Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

Rohan VS Gondor CW

#1Musikguy  Sep 6 2006, 20:42 PM -
Replays: 16 Game:
Awards:
Was a good game vs Wegway that turned out being my gondor vs his rohan from a random mirror. He had me at start getting a few of the creeps before i even knew he was creeping. Was a fun game with no flaming involved. n1qshok.gif
A review would be nice.
[attachmentid=141317]
This post has been edited by HumanSpecies: Nov 15 2006, 08:57 AM
#2Chen  Sep 6 2006, 22:51 PM -
Replays: 5 Game:
Awards:
n1
#3Ston3R  Oct 4 2006, 16:44 PM -
my 4th app review
gogogo
lol
ready in about 2 hours
#4Ston3R  Oct 4 2006, 18:03 PM -
4th application review by Stone



IPB Image [OoE]MusiKGuy vs. B2P|Wegway' IPB Image
map: Fords of Isen
game version: 1.03




[OoE]MusiKGuy

start: pippin, 2 inner farms, 2 outside farms
PP progression: Heal - GtW - elves - eagles
creeps: 4/6



thum.gif Pippin micro ( bowdown.gif tbh)
thum.gif stable deletion right after buying HS
thum.gif mostly MC



wacko.gif friendly fire of catas sometimes


comments: A very good performance....congratulations. At first i thought what were u doing, but then Gandy popped out sooo fast, and he was white as well. That turned the game to your side very fast. You went out on the battlefield and took MC back and started pwning his batts of horses. Then FU knights with Gandy and finally the catas with combos & Fara were unbeatable.
match rating: 8/10



B2P|Wegway'

start: Merry, 2 inner farms, 2 outside farms, extra peasants
PP progression: draft - heal - andùril
creeps: 2/6



thum.gif faster upgrades than gondor
thum.gif deleted stable very fast to build armory and right after having all upgrades deleted it right away as well
thum.gif Merry micro


wacko.gif lost Theo (2 times), Eomer, Aragorn


comments: I have to say that u played good as well, but Rohan has this huge disadvantage of not having catas wacko.gif. Musikguy played a very good game and vs Gandy u were always 1 step behind. I'm afraid i can't help u very much to improve, prolly u should try more rohirrim in the beginning and then delete stable to go for grades, but i think best would be if u contact a SM if u really need help....sorry.
rating: 7/10



match comments: A very good game of both players. Gondor went for knights to fast Gandalf, which helped him a lot to save MC. For all new players out there: That's a good strat and BO for this MU. Rohan tried everything to prevent the gondor invasion on the base, but in the end there was nothing to win any more.
match rating: 7/10
entertainment rating: 7/10



gondor's army on their way to the final battle....
[attachmentid=149768]


rohirrim trying to destroy catas....WB
[attachmentid=149770]


a spear on his way to Gandy
[attachmentid=149771]


the ending of the battle
[attachmentid=149772]
#5tommynt  Oct 4 2006, 19:09 PM -
Replays: 23
Awards:
This Rohan strat just dont work even when it s suggested from Rohan strat mod, even my noob Gondor was able to own it.

Gandalf so much >>>> then Rohan, so every strat allowing Gondor to get Gandi is the wrong
#6Musikguy  Oct 4 2006, 19:14 PM -
Replays: 16 Game:
Awards:
I didn't suggest that....
Nice review stone.
pRo ss's. tongue.gif
#7tommynt  Oct 4 2006, 19:18 PM -
Replays: 23
Awards:
oh sry then
#8Ston3R  Oct 4 2006, 19:35 PM -
QUOTE(Musikguy @ Oct 4 2006, 09:14 PM) *

I didn't suggest that....
Nice review stone.
pRo ss's. tongue.gif

thx
pro SM imo
#9FelLbEasT'  Oct 4 2006, 19:43 PM -
Awards:
I've said it before and i will say it again, rohan will not loose with 4 farms>stavble>5 horses>ents.

5 horses come out quick enough to prevent him creeing more than 2 with the hobbit.

And then you just own him map control wise because no creeps=no GTW and when you have ents he has FU horses. Still end of game.
#10Guardian  Oct 4 2006, 22:36 PM -
Replays: 34 Game:
Awards:
Promoted to silver and rotw contender biggrin.gif
Reply to Comment