Battle for Middle Earth

[attachmentid=153406]

lots of battles in this one, some small skirmishes to
hopefully the entertainment value will be better than my last replay blunder uh 2

gfhknightlight versus pelanoir

Ace=pelanoir

review would be nice
thx

Ill have a look for you, tho i cant get to my game disk till saturday, but i still will, promised

Tagged for Playtsoma

seing replays younger than mine getting reviewed so ill bump

Map: West Emnet
Version: 1.03
Match up: Gonder verses Isengard



Pelanoir (Gondor)
Bo: Farm+Blacksmith +pip, 3 farms out

Strategy: knights-->Boromir-->Faramir-->del stable for siegeworks (no HS)-->soldiers-->ups-->Tg+trebs-->archers+fire--> soldiers-->knights-->combos-->shields

PP-Tree: EW-Heal-Elves-Rohirrim-Eagles-AotD

Pros
Map knowledge
Good harasment
Good Creeping
Very nice shooting of clumbed uruks with trebs, when he ladderrushed you, good defence overal
Good use of counters
+Hero Micro-you got both faramir and boromir to lvl 9.
Used CoG from both Faramir and Boromir

Cons
Purchased EW, but took a while to use it
Got 3 knights, but no shields (this was v important when you attacked the upper outpost
Could have skipped horse summon for Eaglesàending the game right there
Trebs merely used for defence, could have tremenduously helped against the outpost with fire.

Comments- You played a pretty solid game, with nice micro and a very nice diversity in units.
Perhaps you could have bought Gandalf, and like mentioned above skip Rohirrim summon and be more on the field with the trebs. Overal gg from you

Rating 7

________________________________________________________________


GFHKnightLite (Isen)
Bo: furn+pit+2mills

Strategy: urukspam-->2x pike-->xbow (lvl3 pit)-->wargs-->lurtz-->expanding-->siege-->ups

PP tree: WC-Industry-TL-Rain-Palentir

Pros:
Well defended
Strong expander, allowing for fast siege
Fast siege, hadnt it been for his trebs, you could have hit him very hard there
X-bow+fire in outpost, very strong
Pike/Uruk combo, worked out pretty well vs his infantry army
Variety in your army
Good mine use, altough it didnt matte anymore at that point

Cons:
Ran into tg too often with wargs, Tg =Pike, you rly don’t want to do that
Lost lurtz twice, the moment you got him
you could have skipped TL and gone straight for rain imo, might have won you the fight atthe upper outpost.
saruman, at one moment you had close to 5000àget saruman
Rain, when you attack, be sure you have a fresh rain ready to use, you attacke dtoo early on the lower left outpost.

Comments- I loved your style, you were very aggressive troughout. You could have gottten saruman and watched your rain-attack timing a bit better. Try to avoid tg at all cost with wargs. When you are building lurtz from an outpost and it gets attacked, cancel lurtz and rebuild him at mainbase, it was a shame seeing him die twice upon arrival. Overal well played, strong attacks, and good map awareness.

Rating 6.5


Final Comments: An entertaining Gondor-Isen match, on a less often used map. Strong play from both, excellent use of counters, good back and Forth action. A good watch for players, who have difficulties in this Mu, both ways.

End rating 7

Entertainment 6

RotW Contender

~Platy~

Note: Do note Iam an applicant, ratings might get altered.

Please post it in the applicants topic if you want this to be your first application

I did

GG, Pelanoir/Ace. Hey, thanks for the review, Platy. You're the first reviewer that's ever said anything good about my game, so I'm not sure that bodes well for your application! But, gl!

GFHKnightLite

A great first application. I've watched the game myself and the official ratings for the game are :

Pelanoir - 6
GFHKnightLite - 5

Entertainment - 5
Overall Rating - 6

Not RoTW Contender