Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

GC vs Alpha|BeronHawk

#1GloriousCharge  Jan 9 2007, 19:13 PM -
Replays: 7 Game:
Awards:
OK this was on one of my many smurfs just random QM'ing and drew rank number 3 beorn hawk i thought i was done for when i saw that but was kind of suprising.... REVIEW PLEASE biggrin.gif
This post has been edited by GloriousCharge: Jan 9 2007, 19:14 PM
#2Grenness  Jan 9 2007, 22:09 PM -
Replays: 40 Game:
Awards:
ohmy.gif did u beat BeornHawk?
#3GloriousCharge  Jan 9 2007, 23:38 PM -
Replays: 7 Game:
Awards:
ye on my host my gondor is almost flawless sleep.gif nah j/k i made a few minor errors but was still good enough to win.

This post has been edited by GloriousCharge: Jan 9 2007, 23:42 PM
#4LiGhT`  Jan 10 2007, 00:01 AM -
Awards:
QUOTE(GloriousCharge @ Jan 9 2007, 11:38 PM) *

ye on my host my gondor is almost flawless sleep.gif nah j/k i made a few minor errors but was still good enough to win.


Now you just gotta beat me biggrin.gif wub.gif
#5Grenness  Jan 10 2007, 00:08 AM -
Replays: 40 Game:
Awards:
oww post-13661-1143531603.gif dam i cant download the replays for some reason sad.gif

ill try tomorrow cry.gif
#6GloriousCharge  Jan 10 2007, 00:25 AM -
Replays: 7 Game:
Awards:
QUOTE(LiGhT` @ Jan 10 2007, 12:01 AM) *

Now you just gotta beat me biggrin.gif wub.gif

ur light pro we both know thats impossible tongue.gif, but we can give it a go on my host tomorrow dry.gif wub.gif light pro
#7LiGhT`  Jan 10 2007, 00:56 AM -
Awards:
Go for it, practice makes perfect biggrin.gif
#8x.mitten  Jan 10 2007, 11:06 AM -
Replays: 9 Game:
ok i will take this as my 6th application review

@ glorious charge plt rename the rep next time a last replay is useless if you hav +100 reps
This post has been edited by x.mitten: Jan 10 2007, 11:08 AM
#9x.mitten  Jan 10 2007, 13:12 PM -
Replays: 9 Game:
|TreeOfKings|(Gondor) vsAlpha|BeronHawk(Rohan)

Map: Fords of Isen

Top:|TreeOfKings|
Bottom:Alpha|BeronHawk(Rohan)



|TreeOfKings|(Gondor):


Buildorder:

blacksmith<farm<stable

Powerpointroute:

heal<gandalf the white<elven wood<elven allies

Creeps: 2/6

Pros:

+You were able to get mapcontrol pretty fast and the more important thing was,that you were able to keep it nearly the whole game

+When your gandalf came out you abused his spells very effective so you got total mapcontrol

+You used your trebutchets to destroy enemy hero statues so rohan got no leadership anymore

+You could manage to get one enemy farm down at the start which can hurt rohan really badly

Cons:

-You didnīt get a 3rd economy building inbase before stable which delayed your horses a bit because he could get one of your outside farms down

-Sometimes you had a real poor build-spot management (after you got blades you had three empty spots)

-When you finished him off your combos and towerguards stood outside and didnīt do anything


Playercomments:

You played a very good game with only a few mistakes ,but you should try to avoid those few ones .
Always check out if peasants are sneaking around behind a warglair so you can prevent rohan from killing your outsidefarms.
Also a little mistake was not to make a 3rd economybuilding inbase this wold have helped to buy horses a bit earlier.
Some tips who could help you to improve your rohan vs gondor:
If you destroyed one of rohans outside farms then cloak a hobbit there so rohan canīt reclaim it .
Next time also try to buy horseshields before you demolish your stable so you can secure that you knights are stronger than his rohirim, even full upgraded. And try to use your build spots all the time.



Alpha|BeronHawk(Rohan):


Buildorder:

2xfarm<2 sets of extra peasants<stable


Powerpointroute:

draft<heal

Creeps: 4/6


Pros:

+You used eomers/eowyns/legolas special abilities as often as possible so you could earn some pp

+Good creeping at the beginning so you could prevent gondor from getting more powerpoints



Cons:

-Very bad strat ,it was posted in the rohan strat rooms and the rohan strat mod said that it is useless on small maps vs decent gondors but you used it which destroyed all your chances to win ths game

-You ruined your economy totaly because you had only two farms inbase and hardly any mapcontrol

-Bad micro you exposed your units and heroes to much ,try to keep an eye ont them next time

-You lost mapcontrol very fast because two-three sets of unupped horses arenīt enaught to keep mapcontrol vs gondor

-Bad build-spot management (those four early staues and then you didnīt even demolish buildings after you didnīt need them anymore)



Playercomments:
You choosed an extremely bad strat which has no real chance to be sucessful on this map. There are tons of sucessful strats vs gondor
one of the best at the moment you can find HERE.
They key is to get fast upgrades and then you should siege gondor as soon as possible so he hopefully cant get an op army with upgrades and gtw. Always keep an eye on your heroes and units his gandalf could use lighteningsword on them without problems.
One last tipp : If you are running around in wedge formation ganadlfs istari is only able to kill one rohirim instead of three to four.



Ratings:


Entertainmentrating: 4

Because there were some nice battles at the start but it was an ownage game at the end.


Playerratings:

Alpha|BeronHawk(Rohan) 4

|TreeOfKings|(Gondor) 6



Overall rating: 5
This post has been edited by x.mitten: Jan 10 2007, 13:17 PM
#10GloriousCharge  Jan 10 2007, 16:21 PM -
Replays: 7 Game:
Awards:
thanks mate banana.gif

however i actually destroyed both of rohans farms and i did cloak a hobbit there lol tongue.gif watch it more carefully wub.gif
Reply to Comment