Battle for Middle Earth

[attachmentid=150856]was a good game fast ups caused problems early on but the siege it self was very nice
review would be apreciated

thanks Ace

mine

tagged for stone who seemed to forget to do so

yes u r right
more details in the PS: section of this post....read it carefully!!!! U'll laugh, im sure


Randommizer vs. xRedWolf

map: Southern Ithilien
version: 1.03




Randommizer

start: farm, Merry, 4 outside farms
PP porgression: draft - andùril - heal - EW - ents - AotD
creeps: 1/4




GC, late, but still it prevented u from losing
killed fara and GtW with ara's last whack of his sword, when GtW was 1 kill b4 rank 10



lost 2 batts of ranked rohirrim unnecessarily in the beginning
lost all heroes at least once....for example u could've saved ur lego in the beginning with just 1 simple heal
late upgrades
cash floating mid and late game



comments: I wasn't very impressed of this game. Ur starting phase was ok, when u took 4 farms, but the reason for this was mostly ur enemy. Then u built up and army, waited for ur heroes and then u often stood around and did nothing. Try to harass much more and attack his farms. Check out the Rohan strat forums for better strats in this MU, for example ent-rush. What was bad as well was that u needed around 20 ents to get his base finally down. Then be aware of his catas. They killed ur peomen and even ur horses when they stood in front of ur ents. And finally when he killed one of ur camps u just stood in front of his base and did nothing but waiting....prolly for a brighter weather (i dunno)
rating: 3




xRedWolf

start: BS, farm, Pippin, 1 outside farm
PP progression: heal - EW - GtW - rohirrim - eagles - AotD - elves
creeps: 3/4



good creeping, start
fast upgrades
killed all his heroes at least once



bad starting with only 1 outside farm of 5 available
except from 2 BS u just built farms in ur base....built just BS after having stables for cheaper upgrades!
deleted stables without buying HS then re-built it again
lost 1 batt of FU horses vs lego....never attack lego with only 1 single batt
u often stood around, in ur base or anywhere on the map, sometimes with NO harassing at all
cash floating
no statues when u bought GtW....destroy 4 buildings in ur base and build 4 statues to get a 1800 cheaper GtW
FU knights > FU rohirrim.....u often fled
lost all heroes, GtW right b4 WoP
bad AotD usage



comments: Good start (creeps)....bad ending. U wasn't playing good as well, but u always had the better chance of winning when u didn't just defend. U had the bigger army, but there was no advantage, because mostly u were just standing around: Check out our pro gondor strat forums! Ur catas were always standing in ur base and u never attacked. In the end the bad use of AotD made u lose the game vs his GC horses and ents.
rating: 2



match comments: A rather decent Rohan vs. Gondor. Not much entertaining stuff in it. Nothing special. No surprises. Nearly a break in mid game. Both armies were standing in front each other for around 1 minute (watch my first SS) with noone moving. In the end Rohan won it, because Gondor used AotD on a camp. Rohan ran in his base, GC rohirrim, ents, AotD and gg.
match rating: 3
entertainment rating: 2



both armies facing each other...no moving for around 1 minute
[attachmentid=152802]


one of the attacks on gondor that failed horribly
[attachmentid=152803]


most entertaining thing for me to watch in this game
[attachmentid=152804]



PS: ffs, what an effort to get this fucking review done. First i wrote it and in the meantime i was chatting in another window
I clicked on close the chat window, but only my firefoy disappeared
I thought "damn!" but nvm i tried it again.
I wrote it again and went to the toilet
When my mum came by, sat down, closed all windows and checked out her e-mails...

Finally it's done...sorry for taking so long
oh, and genral...i didn't tag it, because normally the review is ready in at least 2 hours

That last screenshot seems insulting. hard to tell if ur being sarcastic...

I also find it annoying when 2 people just sit there with 2 full armies and do nothing.

guardian....just for u
the next time ill post such a SS ill write "sarcastic" next to it....ok?

ffs don't take it so personally, its not a big deal...

lol
i was just joking around
who changed the rating ffs?