Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] [Review] Jubie(Isengard)/Sjosty(Gondor) vs Robben(Isengard)/Wonder(Isen

#1WonderTruls  Apr 10 2007, 16:29 PM -
Awards:
Its quite a long time ago since ive played a 400kb rep, and its action from the start to end.
Would realy like review by smile.gif

gg guys and realy wp !

[attachmentid=234074]

Review by: Thrandy

Starting positions:
Team 1: (Isengard) WonderTruls + (Isengard) Arjen_Robben - West
Team 2: (Isengard) Master^Jubie + (Gondor) [FOR]s3xyw0m4n - East

Overview:

A long game due to numerous mistakes, some due to lag but mostly ones that cost Team 4 the game. WonderTruls is really the only player worth paying attention to as he had to completely carry his teammate and the others didn't know what to do.

Team 1 Commentary:

Wonder you played pretty well, good job carrying your teammate but nothing could really be produced from you since you were protecting your side the whole game. I thought your team's start BO was ok but things fell apart in mid game, maybe because you had the uP MU. Arjen should make more pikes to stop Gondor's knights instead of making so many uruks. Wonder can make wargs to counter the enemy Isen's uruks but Arjen should've had more combos and pikes to start out with. Your rush attempt was good but Arjen wasn't using WC correctly throughout the match. Wonder should probably have made some siege earlier since you had the money so that Gondor wouldn't have bothered you for so long with summons. Also, what was with the Rain? You used it when the enemy team didn't have Gandalf or Lurtz or lvl 5 Faramir or anything, but since late game didn't come down to mass Ld armies this didn't really affect the outcome.
  • Use Industry right after it recharges, I noticed it hadn't been used very much when it was available.
  • Make extra labs always so that you will have a more productive economy.
  • Don't forget to put your units in formation, a lot of times your uruks were rushing in default form.
  • Arjen be more proactive with your units, you had some batts sitting behind your base for a long time.
Team 2 Commentary:

Pretty average game here. Start was pretty good but your unit micro was a mess. Jubie had his uruks in default form the whole game and should've had them in block form, especially in those fights. I dunno why you were spamming uruks in the first place, you should've massed into some combos and made some siege but those uruks were simply feeding the opponents PP. WC was used incorrectly a few times and you shouldn't get Fuel the Fires until AFTER Balrog, having Rog definitely would've saved you the game if you had it when the enemy Isen had only his citadel left. Gondor should have two farms in late game instead of only one, one of you should've taken the initiative to take the camp but because of this Gondor couldn't do anything with a bad econ. Gondor was cash floating also. Trebs were used pretty badly and the knight spam was very weird. You kept running them into pikes and not being careful enough with them during the base rushes. You lost sooooooo many knights because of this, and was a waste of money since you had to keep the stable up. Anyways, the last point is that when the enemy Isen Rog rushed Gondor, Gondor had 237 resources left but not enough to rebuild his citadel. He might've been able to stay alive if Jubie deleted a mill so Gondor could build a farm. Again, it all came down to bad teamwork and incorrect unit development.

Tips for Improvement:
  • Don't feed the enemies PP, it's a really bad habit.
  • Work on formation use.
  • Use trebs correctly, instead of firing them all on one spot make them target different combos.
  • Don't forget to reuse Industry immediately after it recharges.
Overall Rating: 4
This post has been edited by Thrandy: Apr 14 2007, 02:53 AM
#2Gerrard  Apr 10 2007, 18:15 PM -
Replays: 31 Game:
Awards:
sjosty, lol w/e
#3WonderLoo  Apr 11 2007, 17:02 PM -
Replays: 4 Game:
sexy woman is sjosty? bowdown.gif

i saw you yesterday in chat with this guy and the other both unsure.gif

wacko.gif
#4Luân^  Apr 11 2007, 19:52 PM -
Replays: 23 Game:
Awards:
It's not Sjosty.
#5 Kamal  Apr 11 2007, 20:05 PM -
Replays: 6 Game:
theres no proof that this is sjosty

i'd like to know which strat wonder and sammy used ...
#6WonderLoo  Apr 12 2007, 13:55 PM -
Replays: 4 Game:
QUOTE(Luân^ @ Apr 11 2007, 21:52 PM) *

It's not Sjosty.



agreed
#7StuntedAzrael  Apr 13 2007, 13:12 PM -
Replays: 4 Game:
Great game, fun to watch.

First time that I have seen a lvl10 Saruman. You dont get to lvl him up so often.
#8Thrandy  Apr 13 2007, 20:43 PM -
Replays: 6 Game:
Awards:
Tagged. smile.gif
#9Thrandy  Apr 14 2007, 02:54 AM -
Replays: 6 Game:
Awards:
Replay reviewed. *Yawn*
Reply to Comment