Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] fod}Phanthom v |PLOW|Wiz4rD

#1Gerrard  Sep 7 2006, 02:30 AM -
Replays: 31 Game:
Awards:
i dont usually post games i lose, but this was very good. I allowed him 2 get 2 late game sad.gif and i thought i did some very good damage vs him, didnt lose gandalf untill very end. Managed 2 push him back with aod but he kept coming back, then fuck balrog...GG tongue.gif

cheers 4 the game mafia smile.gif aka bt stone aka la apollo...lol[attachmentid=141429]
#2sjosty  Sep 7 2006, 06:47 AM -
Replays: 35 Game:
Awards:
Gj stone wink.gif

FoD is back on track with 3th place wink.gif
and both warriors top 10 happy.gif

and you know what
if i could watch it i would have biggrin.gif tongue.gif
#3Infinity`  Sep 7 2006, 21:23 PM -
wow gg guys smile.gif
#4Grenness  Sep 7 2006, 21:34 PM -
Replays: 40 Game:
Awards:
how can mordor loose to gondor?
#5LiGhT`  Sep 7 2006, 21:44 PM -
Awards:
We're not all uber pro like u grenn tongue.gif
#6sjosty  Sep 8 2006, 06:53 AM -
Replays: 35 Game:
Awards:
Phantom won right?

at least thats what our stats at .cc said tongue.gif
and thats what gerrard says i think tongue.gif
#7tommynt  Sep 8 2006, 13:16 PM -
Replays: 23
Awards:
v review by tommynt

|PLOW|Wiz4rD (Gondor on left) vs fod}Phanthom (Mordor on right)
Verion: 1.03
Map: Fords of Isen


|PLOW|Wiz4rD (Gondor on left):

Bo/Strat: 3 Horses to Gandlaf to archerarmy with brothers to bunker

Pros:
+ did some damage with soldiers
+ fast and effective creeping
+ harrasment by trampling workers
+ never lost Gandalf (untill ..)
+ tried to kill combos before bird summon
+ maximum damage with aod

Cons:
- lost track of horses including lvl 10 horse
- floating money after Gandalf
- too slow with attacking
- no/uneffective use of elve summon
- catas used without fire uprade
- didnt get rdy at all for balrog

Comments: Your early game looked promising, even when pressure with soldiers on mills is usually better as on base. But you just gave him too much time and eco resulting in WK and death of your army. A more early Fara would imo help to maintan mapcontrol by protecting Knights from single Trolls. No Mumaks gave u easy time for your Gandalf, but u did surly nice microing him and looking for nonls Trolls to kill. While microing Gandalf u lost far too often track of other units.
In end u never had chance to win as all u did was waiting for aod, but aod usually = Balrog and Balrog = gg. IN fact all what Aod should do is killing Balrog or u just cant counter him

Rating: 5


fod}Phanthom (Mordor on right):

Bo/Strat: Masstrolls to WK to doublecage and double Cata spam

Pros:
+ allways tried to use ls
+ massing Trolls untill WK
+ got combos to counter bird summon
+ full mapcontrol

Cons:
- no towers to counter his soldier attack fast
- got only 1 creep (and that made u loose 2 slaughters)
- no outpost/mumak pit protection (twice)
- no mumaks gave his Gandalf a easy time
- siegemicro

Comments: A kinda decent game from u where u allways tried to make best out what your fraction got .. ls. But there were a lot of micro and macromistakes in your game, not protecting outpost with mumak pit at all was really sad. U managed to survive even with this lot loss of money untill wk what was surly not bad but mainly Gondors fault. I d allways mix 2-4 mumaks into siege army - 1 at each side of your stack to trample Gandi as soon he does a single spell. In end all u had to do was waiting for Balrog to end game.

Rating: 5


General Notes on the game: Game looked promising in start with Gondor doing good creeping and harrasing and Mordor spaming trolls fast. But instead using his momentum Gondor was too busy with Gandalf micro and lost control of all other stuff a bit. Mordors siege lacked mumaks and micro a bit. Bunker play isnt too entertaining for me - espacially with Gondor not having a single horse left to do some counterattacks.

Entertainment: 4

Overall Score: 5
#8LiGhT`  Sep 8 2006, 13:24 PM -
Awards:
Nice to see you helping us noob RR's out tommy smile.gif
#9Gerrard  Sep 8 2006, 16:56 PM -
Replays: 31 Game:
Awards:
ty 4 review
#10Grenness  Sep 8 2006, 20:02 PM -
Replays: 40 Game:
Awards:
I would say gondor should win this game imo, but mordor recovered nicely
Reply to Comment