Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] Gren vs Promero

#1Grenness  Dec 3 2006, 13:32 PM -
Replays: 40 Game:
Awards:
i just lost a game vs romero. rrs how could i win this???

plz review blush.gif
#2tommynt  Dec 5 2006, 11:30 AM -
Replays: 23
Awards:
Green vs Romero

Green (Isen):

pros:
+ could hold some mapcontrol with pikes
+ decent fast wargs and ups
+ u rly had the combos when he used egales - but way to late
+ took out his army once, decent micro there

cons:
- horrible unit micro thoughtout all game wacko.gif
- go attack Gondor farms after chant in start, once he tries defend own him
- way too many xbows, 1 is more then enough, u got like 4; what was their use?
- lacking pike spam
- pikes not dodging elves and soldiers
- wargs fight high lvled horses, even in wood
- lost loads of warg bats - giving Gondor pp for eagles
- no formation switch when running away with pikes
- hero micro/ exposing Saruman
- formation use
- not upgrading pikes = loosing em in melee
- 35 workers at 1 mill non at another
- way too passive, never got siegeworks
- defense use of Balrog

I was about to quit game several times, as i know that u can micro your units way better.
In fact your long con list says it all, u did so mayn horrible fights with wargs and also with pikes where u just had not even a slight chance to win. By that u levled his horses and gave him pp like crazzy.
Get at least 1 more uruk in early game to take out Gondor Farms, and kill off his soldiers so that they cant anoy your pike spam!
Dont get xbows early game, get em late midgame when Gondor is close to eagles, before upgrades combos kinda suck.
U was lucky that he waited ages to use eagles or the game might have ended way more early.
Try take out Gondor Castle with balrog, it possible with pro Balrog micro.

Rating: 4


Romero

pros:

+ hobbit micro
+ mixing soldiers and Knights
+ decent use of elves
+ Firacatas very good unit choise to attack Isen base

Cons:

- defending with ew dont work vs pro Isen
- open gate
- Knight micro wasnt rly good
- no ew spam
- no use of eagles when u got pp for em - they d have owned
- generaly no too good summon use
- riding right into pikes multiple times

Oh well u wont listen to me anyway, but i see 0 reason not to use egles when u got PP for em.
U rly gotta watch your Knights better, even high lvled horses die when u let em ride right into pikes as u did multiple times.
Your best part is surly your unit mixing

Rating: 6

Comments: Both players had really unexpected bad micro. Isen got serval combos early game which all died. Wargs fighting high leveld horses way too often gave Gondor easy time to gather pp and play it kinda the save way. Kinda entertaining as it was action packed but then the bad micro did really hurt.

Entertainment: 6

Overall rating: 5
This post has been edited by tommynt: Dec 5 2006, 12:08 PM
#3AloneLord  Dec 5 2006, 15:05 PM -
Replays: 21 Game:
Awards:
QUOTE(Grenness @ Dec 3 2006, 01:32 PM) *

i just lost a game vs romero. rrs how could i win this???

plz review blush.gif

u cant cause bowdown.gif promero bowdown.gif
#4FelLbEasT'  Dec 5 2006, 21:03 PM -
Awards:
Yeaahhh...
#5romero318  Dec 6 2006, 23:55 PM -
Replays: 60
could someboyd tell me y r i a noob ?
#6PlaTy  Dec 8 2006, 02:36 AM -
Awards:
You just are mate, Practise makes perfect laugh.gif
Reply to Comment