Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] Gamroth vs stEINway

#1Gamroth  Nov 22 2006, 21:21 PM -
Awards:
Was a gg, could i get a review plz tongue.gif

[attachmentid=169198]
#2Guardian  Nov 26 2006, 19:35 PM -
Replays: 34 Game:
Awards:
Tagged for me. Guess the other rrs missed it?
#3Guardian  Nov 26 2006, 20:32 PM -
Replays: 34 Game:
Awards:
|GoD|G4MROTH vs iL'stEiNwAy'
Fords of Isen


G4MROTH

Start BO: Pit, Furn

PP Progression: Warchant>Industry>Rain>Balrog

Strategy: 3 uruks>Xbow creeping>pike spam with some beserkers>wargs>lurtz>ups>seige

Creeps: 2/6

Pros:
*Harassment/map control
*Killed fara and gandi with lurtz
*ballista protection and big battle micro

Cons:
*Should've claimed mills with your initial uruk
*PP floating: should have bought industry alot sooner
*minor cashfloating
* Empty base spot for a while
*Late rain useage. It would have hurt his sneak base attack. There was no real need to save it for your attack on his castle since he had only boro.

Comments: You played a pretty solid game imo. Nice job intercepting his soldiers before they got to your mills and killing them. I thought you could have went even bigger with your pike spam and expanded with them to his 2 farms. Wargs were pretty much useless since he had upgrades when you got them but they did an ok job harassing what farms he had.

Overall Score: 6


iL'stEiNwAy'

Start BO: Blacksmith, farm

PP Progression: elven wood>heal>gtw>elves>rohirrim>eagles

Strategy: 2 horses and faramir>gandalf>soldiers with boro>late trebs

Creeps: 4/6

Pros:
*harassment
*creeping
*Kept your horses alive for a long time

Cons:
*initial ew placement was horrible and didn't help you take down his mills
*never deleted farms
*ran alot of horses around in wedge formation
* didn't get horseshields unitl late game (an earlier rush on his base would have been effective)
*minor cashfloating

Comments: You had an ok game considering your strategy. It would be a better idea to go 3 horses so you can get horseshields and attack his base. That way you cripple him and get power points for yourself. You were just stuck trying to harass and make sneak attacks on his base. You also didn't utilize soldiers to thier pike-killing potential. Your passiveness lost you the game.

Overall Score: 5

Game Comments: Average game where isen appears to be in control for most of the game. Gandalf makes things interesting but is killed in the end.

Overall Score: 5
Entertainment Value: 5


#4Gamroth  Nov 26 2006, 22:27 PM -
Awards:
Thx for review happy.gif
Reply to Comment