Battle for Middle Earth

Gondor vs Mordor, good game.


Cant touch him with those ******** trolls w/trees!!

*bumped for review

omg mass trolls is unstoppable.

bump.

lol a very old one
I am just watching for the oldest replays, because there are lots of them, then I saw this one.

MINE (up mayB tonight, else tomorrow)

Version > 1.03
Map > Fords of Isen
Races > Gondor & Mordor


Player 1 > [EPIC]Krysler

Starting BO > 2 IF, 2 OF, 1 BS, stable
Strategy > horses, faramir, archers, horses, rangers, horses, rangers, gandy
PP progression > heal, summon elves, summon eagles, EW, GTW

Pros

+ harassing (but could be more
+ used formations almost correctly
+ saved your horses when HS rushed him
+ ekilled his first nazgul with fara + fire archers
+ saved your faramir with help of your OP and killed some nazgul too


Cons

- didn't use your soldiers at the start
- poor creeping
- lost all your horses to a nazgul after your HS rush (maybe you could destroy his citadel, but i'm not sure about that)
- lost all your FU archers to his trolls when attacking his base (suicide )
- lost some horses to his rhuns
- lost your rangers when not watching at it, cause you were busy with trying to save faramir


Player summary

It was not a bad game for you. Early game was a bit weak. He had MC and crept almost everything. You harassed him sometimes, but it could be more. Also the HS rushes caused you a poor harassement at some moments, because you lost your horses. Never the less it were some good HS rushes. You saved you horses several times, but also lost them. You farmir micro was really good. You killed several nazgul with it and saved your faramir once really nice at OP. When there were 3 nazguls it was just to much for you and you lost your micro on your other units too and you lost. The last raid on his castle was actually suicide, because he had 3 nazgul and a full towered base. Maybe you could better defend your own castle, but that would be very difficult too.


Player rating 5


Player 2 > LordDrakenofMog

Starting BO > haradrim palace ~ 2 mills ~ 6 SHs ~ troll cage
Strategy > haradrim ~ trolls ~ rhuns ~ drum trolls ~ nazgul ~ trolls ~ rhuns ~ nazgul ~ catas ~ WK ~ trolls
PP progression > eye of sauron ~ TL ~ industry ~ darkness


Pros

+ extra labourers
+ creeping
+ good first troll rush on his walls
+ killed all of his horses with your nazgul
+ killed his faramir in the end with three nazgul
+ nice PP use
+ a good well balanced army


Cons

- lost several buildings to his HS rush (not a shame, but you could spread your towers in your base)
- lost your nazguls several times really stupid
- lost all your catas
- poor harassment (because you had no orc pit)


Player summary

You started really good with creeping. U used your haradrim very good. After that you had not very much to harass with, but you used the no orc spam strat (or whatever ) Your rhuns were a good choice, but you didn't had to defend anything actually, only you could defend your mills with it, but you didn't hardly do this. Afterall you killed some horses of him with them and they took some arrows instead of your trolls. After the first attack didn't succeed you had some catas which got destroyed without use. You also didn't look really out for his faramir. He was really a pain in the ass for you. After the first raid didn't succeed I thought you lost, but you could make a new even stronger army without much LD and could easily win after all. You choose for this strat, but you could also orc spam him for MC, cause now you saw you didn't had MC while you could have that easily. You were the most focussed on his army, never the less you had a good eco and could kill all his horses, so he din;t had a very good eco


Player rating 6


Entertainment rating 6


Overall rating 6