Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] Good Gondor mirror

#1Krys1er  Dec 9 2005, 15:44 PM -
Replays: 22 Game:


Good game vs a good Gondor. We made a no stoneworker agreement at the start.

We both made mistakes, like the stupid pathing of my knights being concentrated so the troll owned them all in 3 hits.

any reviews/comments would be helpful.



*sorry for the crapness, dont play many 1 vs 1's away from Fords.


SindarinElf7
#2maveric_duc  Dec 10 2005, 13:21 PM -
Replays: 5
Awesome decision made by agreeing not to go for stoneworkers/Trebs camping would have spoilled the game. banana.gif

Maveric's Replay Review

Gondor (Epic Krysler)

Started: 2 Farms + Hobbit
PP: Heal -> GTW -> Elven Allies

Pro's

smile.gif Harassed enemy farms
smile.gif Creeped the map well again PP
smile.gif Cloaked hobbit in front of your gate to prevent LS didn't prove sucessful first time. You were prepared second time with hobbit + boromir
biggrin.gif Destoried some of opponents building slowing down his gate repair
thumb.gif Killed enemy gandulf with well placed LS, winning you the game
biggrin.gif Rushed his citadel, stopping the return of his gandie once you broke through his gate

Con's

sad.gif Loss knights to a troll, came a bit to close whying trying to go for his hobbit
sad.gif Didn't take totally control of map, need to make sure opponent doesn't get outside farms since you were leading at a stage
sad.gif Initial LS on opponent's gate failed
WTF.gif Leave knights standing around sometimes, find farms to harass or join them up with your army

Gondor ( AOV CromGdansk)

Started: BS + Farm + Hobbit
PP: Heal -> GTW

Pro's

smile.gif Creeping of map was good
biggrin.gif Good use of well to heal a gandulf that was on his death bed
smile.gif Place boromir on top of wall to prevent LS
smile.gif Good micro of gandulf getting out of tricky places at times

Con's

WTF.gif Took long before getting postern gate, should really come quicker in future
wacko.gif Got first tower way to early, cash could have been better used
sad.gif Need to harass opponent way more, let him control to many farms
sad.gif Although it is useful to creep, starting off creeping in the begining slowed farms and thus knight down plus let opponent keep his farms
sad.gif Wasted istari light on knights, should target opponets gandulf
sad.gif Felt if you were camping to much you need to take the fight to him

Good game, i am so pleased it didn't go the camping way. Was entertaing to watch and some things can be improved upon by both players but over all good

Rating: 6/10
This post has been edited by maveric_duc: Dec 10 2005, 13:23 PM
#3Krys1er  Dec 10 2005, 14:58 PM -
Replays: 22 Game:

Thanks for the review mate.
Reply to Comment