Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth 2

[R] VGG PoW vs PmK [Review]

#1LightninG  Jan 6 2007, 19:18 PM -
title says it all, have fun! epic battles too smile.gif review please.

[attachmentid=188752]
This post has been edited by LightninG: Jan 18 2007, 00:35 AM
#2Drizzt Do'Urden  Jan 6 2007, 19:20 PM -
Awards:
Aww, Max got pwnt tongue.gif Watching smile.gif
#3LightninG  Jan 10 2007, 00:26 AM -
bump..
#4LightninG  Jan 14 2007, 22:14 PM -
im thinking this is at the least a silver worthy replay or higher..would appreciate a review after waiting a week post-13661-1143531603.gif
#5Warlock553  Jan 14 2007, 22:18 PM -
Replays: 18 Game:
Awards:
QUOTE(LightninG @ Jan 14 2007, 04:14 PM) *
im thinking this is at the least a silver worthy replay or higher..would appreciate a review after waiting a week post-13661-1143531603.gif

Ask for a review in the title next time smile.gif, I will review after the game i currently have tagged.
This post has been edited by Warlock553: Jan 15 2007, 01:18 AM
#6LightninG  Jan 14 2007, 22:37 PM -
oh yea i keep forgetting, thanks warlock.
#7LightninG  Jan 18 2007, 00:36 AM -
can someone add [review] in title box? ty
#8keyd  Jan 18 2007, 01:09 AM -
looking forward to watching it...
#9  Jan 23 2007, 13:33 PM -
Replays: 63
Mine.
#10  Jan 23 2007, 13:58 PM -
Replays: 63
IPB Image

IPB Image
Game version BTP v1.1

Game summary

A pretty good game between two mainly evenly matched players, although some mistakes were made this is still a good game smile.gif

IPB ImagePoW|LightninG*

Your game was mainly good but imho you should've done some things better.

Firstly, when playing as dwarves, it's pretty much essential to get few battlewagons to counter enemy harass. You should get these as early as possible tbh, to kill soldier spam and to harass enemy better.

Your harassment could've been a bit better and I feel that you could've succeeded better by getting some pressure into his initial base. Get some guardians and phalanxes harassing his base and also remember that siege hammers can be lethal for enemy, getting them is a good idea.

Prefer to get MoD over ATs as axe thrower deals slash damage and is tbh shit vs soldier units, and MoD does better anyways in this MU. MoD is very good in killing enemy soldiers and TG, also vs heroes with their black arrow.

Try to get some harassing force continuously attacking his base before getting heroes.

Also try to keep heroes alive better, I suggest getting heal earlier as keeping Gloin alive can be game saver sometimes.

IPB ImageDerKleineHoden


Your game was good but it relied too much on the soldier spam.

You should've mixed your troops better, mix in some rangers to kill enemy infantry and also some rohirrim to harass his mine network, their splash simply murders enemy defense in the mine network.

Try to get some pressure on enemy base by spamming soldiers from every direction possible to keep him defending his base.

Creep earlier to ensure that you get better income, you had bad creeping in this game, at least compared to your enemy.

Try to get upgrades earlier, they can be vital in order to annihilate enemy troops.


Ratings
PoW|LightninG*: 5/10
DerKleineHoden: 4/10

Game: 5/10
Reply to Comment