Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth 2 1.06

[Silver] raC´AddEyron vs CF|Manson

#1uMg-Manson  Nov 29 2006, 14:49 PM -
Replays: 2
Hi Guys,

can anyone review my rep?

i played orcs against AddEyron, he played dwarves!

it was a very good game and i had a lot of fun!

thank you

Manson
#2Mortal  Dec 7 2006, 08:50 AM -
Replays: 2 Game:
Review coming up(ill watch replay onight to review tomorrow.
#3Mortal  Dec 7 2006, 09:29 AM -
Replays: 2 Game:
Just watched one of the best matches ive seen. Definately doing review first thing aftr school.
#4Mortal  Dec 8 2006, 03:26 AM -
Replays: 2 Game:
REPLAY REVIEW

IPB Image

IPB Image vs IPB Image

RaC^Eyron vs CF|Manson


RaC^Eyron


BO-Mine,HoW,Mine,Mine,Pikes
PP route-RC,Heal,SummonMoD,Rebuild,Bombard,Earthquake.
Starting strategy-Creeping,guardian harass.

First note-You played very well but did a couple of things that got you the loss.

PROS

thumb.gif -Troops out fast and creeping.
thumb.gif -Good use of stances.
thumb.gif -Good clumping.
thumb.gif -Great first hero (Gloin).
thumb.gif -Expanded.
thumb.gif -Good harassment.

CONS

u0udiablo.gif -Not enough pikes.
u0udiablo.gif -Never build BW.
u0udiablo.gif -Put everything into one attack.


banana.gif summary/tips banana.gif

You played a good game and really dominated the first half but it really started to go downhill when you put everything into one attack.
You had no back-up plan of what to do if your attack fails, you should always have at least something so your attack isn't a win/lose thing. When matched up with gobs always build lots of pikes as most there units are monsters and pikes are strong agaisnt monsters. Lastly you never build BWs Battlewagons are a huge help early-mid game and can destroy whole armies if microed propaply.

Thats all for you.

Player Rating-7/10


CF|Manson


BO-Tun,Tun,Cave,Cave,Soldiers.
PP route-Bats,Wildmen,Watcher,Balrog.
Starting strategy-Goblin spam.

First note:You played very well but could have done a few things better.


PROS

thumb.gif -Guys fast and spam.
thumb.gif -Great first hero(gobking).
thumb.gif -Harassment.
thumb.gif -Expanded.
thumb.gif -Clumping
thumb.gif -Stance use.

CONS

u0udiablo.gif -Let enemy get all creeps.
u0udiablo.gif -To focused on destroying fortress.
u0udiablo.gif -Cashfloat.

banana.gif summary/tips banana.gif

You played a great game and did alot of things right but also a couple wrong. First is creeping goblins(this map especially) is quite hard right away as they have weak starting units and must upgrade to get there pikes, However this does not mean you can not stop the enemy from creeping. I reccomend rushing then sending some guys to fend off your creeps until you get pikes/trolls to deal with them. I noticed that when you were in his base you were super focused on killing his fortress,although it worked this time with a good economy he could rebuild it(which he did). Lastly is cashfloat you had a few thousand in your belt and you needed to spend it on upgrades or even more troops(this was after drogoth).

Besides that there isnt much else.

Player rating-7/10


w00t.gif Game summary w00t.gif

Very intesting well played match by both players,lots of action. Looked like one player could have won then suddenly his fort dies. Both players did most things right one player just did a couple of things better that stood out and got him the win. Well worth the download,Silver.

Game Rating 7/10

Hope this helped.

IPB Image
#5Mortal  Dec 8 2006, 03:27 AM -
Replays: 2 Game:
if you see anything wrong with the review^ tell me and I will change it.


thanks
#6Mortal  Dec 8 2006, 03:31 AM -
Replays: 2 Game:
if another reviewer could rate this to a 7 that would be great biggrin.gif
#7Sidddhu  Dec 8 2006, 10:25 AM -
Replays: 27 Game:
Awards:
didnt watch the replay but im surprised the goblin didnt get owned with the build order
#8Radiohead  Dec 8 2006, 18:15 PM -
Replays: 6 Game:
Awards:
i think a 7 is to high personally
#9CraZer09  Dec 10 2006, 01:03 AM -
Replays: 19 Game:
Awards:
silver rep or normaly rep?
#10uMg-Manson  Feb 3 2007, 09:04 AM -
Replays: 2
nice nice!
thist game is a silver replay :-)
Reply to Comment