Too many mistakes and too little murder. The game was fucking long and full of fail. Next time upload replay where you play PERFECTLY and WITHOUT MISTAKES during the first 2 minutes and WIN without giving your opponent ANY chances. I want to see people getting murdered AS FAST AS POSSIBLE and WITHOUT MISTAKES. Can you do that?
This post has been edited by Boshy: Dec 29 2014, 06:33 AM
Boshy, you're getting confused. Nobody posts replays without mistakes. You must be thinking of HOF replays. Even then, it's only major mistakes that are unacceptable.
In a short summary, here is what makes a replay worthy of being in the Hall of Fame:
Neither of the players made any major mistakes, only minor mistakes made the difference
The replay shows a rarely seen strategy, which somehow was pulled off despite the opponent's best attempts to counter it
The replay is unusually entertaining, making this replay one of a kind
Replays are good if they are posted for the right reasons, i.e. to provide the members with replays of good, entertaining or educational games. If that is what the guy is trying to do by posting his replay, good on him.
Your suggestion also included you ordering him to not post replays unless he plays perfect.
I never told him not to post replays. But I told him to post replays where he plays perfectly in 5 minutes. I think that's an attainable goal since it's only 5 minutes.
Your suggestion also included you ordering him to not post replays unless he plays perfect.
I never told him not to post replays. But I told him to post replays where he plays perfectly in 5 minutes. I think that's an attainable goal since it's only 5 minutes.
OK, fine, but you must realize that he posts replays for everyone, not just you. When you share your opinion, don't speak for yourself only. It just seems rude and conceited. I am sure you're not wrong about the quality of his play, but there are some people who are even worse, and could actually learn something from this replay.
