Explore GameReplays...

Red Alert 3

January 2018 LWs results and replays

Reply to this topic Start new topic
# 1Inspector RaGe Feb 10 2018, 01:42 AM
IPB Image



Check out the January 2018 LWs Announcement for all the details.


January 2018 LWs Check-ins [CURRENTLY CLOSED]

BRACKET WILL BE SHUFFLED JUST AFTER CHECK-INS CLOSE, WAIT FOR MY CONFIRMATION (NOT OFFICIAL YET!)

BRACKET


Please post your results in the following format:

Player A 3-2 Player B


Twitter Image
Discord Image

Posts: 6,694

Clan: m8s

Game: Red Alert 3


+
# 2zokker13 Feb 10 2018, 14:46 PM
Dimon 3 - 1 me






Dimon had the impression I was abusing bugs on IS with my PKs from the building so feel free to DQ me from future events.
It seems Dimon doesn't know jack shit about PK behavior (who can blame a Soviet for that?) but getting called a bug-abuser is just poor.

For simpletons:
If you put PKs in a building with aggressive stance and then a wall I build around that, it can happen that the PKs continue to shoot (for whatever reason). If you think this is a bug, fair. If you think this is forced bug exploiting you are an idiot.
This behavior can be observed _especially_ on BBB. Wall in anything, infantry will still be able to attack.

This is not on the banned exploit list. If people feel there is need for discussion on this, a separate topic can be opened. - RaGe


Original upload


Attached File _18_02_10_for_05m42s__cWc.zokker13_A__vs_dimon0000000_S_.RA3Replay
Size: 217.47k
Number of downloads: 11
Player Name Side Team
dimon0000000 0
cWc.zokker13* 0
Attached File _18_02_10_for_06m42s__dimon0000000_S__vs_cWc.zokker13_A_.RA3Replay
Size: 269.59k
Number of downloads: 11
Player Name Side Team
cWc.zokker13* 0
dimon0000000 0
Attached File _18_02_10_for_13m27s__cWc.zokker13_A__vs_dimon0000000_S_.RA3Replay
Size: 579.21k
Number of downloads: 13
Player Name Side Team
dimon0000000 0
cWc.zokker13* 0
Attached File _18_02_10_for_06m35s__dimon0000000_S__vs_cWc.zokker13_A_.RA3Replay
Size: 247.76k
Number of downloads: 11
Player Name Side Team
cWc.zokker13* 0
dimon0000000 0




This post has been edited by Inspector RaGe: Feb 10 2018, 15:14 PM

Posts: 4,320

Game: None


+
# 3Vindies Feb 10 2018, 14:53 PM
Vindies 3-0 AA





Original upload


Attached File Vindies_vs_AA_G1.RA3Replay
Size: 524.25k
Number of downloads: 11
Player Name Side Team
|m8s|Vindies* 0
[m8s]DogKnows 0


Attached File Vindies_vs_AA_G2.RA3Replay
Size: 445k
Number of downloads: 9
Player Name Side Team
|m8s|Vindies* 0
[m8s]DogKnows 0


Attached File Vindies_vs_AA_G3.RA3Replay
Size: 477.87k
Number of downloads: 11
Player Name Side Team
|m8s|Vindies* 0
[m8s]DogKnows 0




This post has been edited by Inspector RaGe: Feb 10 2018, 15:10 PM

Posts: 1,300

Clan: m8s

Game: Red Alert 3


+
# 4Dimon0000000 Feb 10 2018, 16:19 PM
QUOTE(zokker13 @ Feb 11 2018, 00:46 AM) *

Dimon had the impression I was abusing bugs on IS with my PKs from the building so feel free to DQ me from future events.
It seems Dimon doesn't know jack shit about PK behavior (who can blame a Soviet for that?) but getting called a bug-abuser is just poor.

For simpletons:
If you put PKs in a building with aggressive stance and then a wall I build around that, it can happen that the PKs continue to shoot (for whatever reason). If you think this is a bug, fair. If you think this is forced bug exploiting you are an idiot.
This behavior can be observed _especially_ on BBB. Wall in anything, infantry will still be able to attack.

This is not on the banned exploit list. If people feel there is need for discussion on this, a separate topic can be opened. - RaGe


Original upload


Attached File _18_02_10_for_05m42s__cWc.zokker13_A__vs_dimon0000000_S_.RA3Replay
Size: 217.47k
Number of downloads: 11
Player Name Side Team
dimon0000000 0
cWc.zokker13* 0
Attached File _18_02_10_for_06m42s__dimon0000000_S__vs_cWc.zokker13_A_.RA3Replay
Size: 269.59k
Number of downloads: 11
Player Name Side Team
cWc.zokker13* 0
dimon0000000 0
Attached File _18_02_10_for_13m27s__cWc.zokker13_A__vs_dimon0000000_S_.RA3Replay
Size: 579.21k
Number of downloads: 13
Player Name Side Team
dimon0000000 0
cWc.zokker13* 0
Attached File _18_02_10_for_06m35s__dimon0000000_S__vs_cWc.zokker13_A_.RA3Replay
Size: 247.76k
Number of downloads: 11
Player Name Side Team
cWc.zokker13* 0
dimon0000000 0




1)Dimon know about this PKs behaviour and Dimon also know player have full control of pks and can easy disable agressive mode and np.
2)Dimon claim you are bugabuser because this is bug(Chris confirmed as i remember, tell me if im wrong). I cant say if you use it specially or not but i exactly know nothing prevented you to move pks back in house and finish my ref with SAME bug way.
3)As Dimon told, he not gonna report on you, so why you make a noise after fight? You should just say sorry and forget about it instead of write crap on forum.

Posts: 731

Game: Red Alert 3


+
# 5Andrey_96 Feb 10 2018, 16:52 PM
To zokker,just off aggressive mod wink.gif

Posts: 737

Game: Red Alert 3


+
# 6Dimon0000000 Feb 10 2018, 16:55 PM
Finals
Dimon 4-3 Vindies









Original upload


Attached File vindies_1.RA3Replay
Size: 378.67k
Number of downloads: 14
Player Name Side Team
dimon0000000* 0
|m8s|Vindies 0
Attached File vindies_2.RA3Replay
Size: 232.75k
Number of downloads: 13
Player Name Side Team
|m8s|Vindies 0
dimon0000000* 0
Attached File vindies_3.RA3Replay
Size: 271.69k
Number of downloads: 11
Player Name Side Team
dimon0000000* 0
|m8s|Vindies 0
Attached File vindies_4.RA3Replay
Size: 327.6k
Number of downloads: 9
Player Name Side Team
|m8s|Vindies 0
dimon0000000* 0
Attached File vindies_5.RA3Replay
Size: 414.36k
Number of downloads: 11
Player Name Side Team
dimon0000000* 0
|m8s|Vindies 0
Attached File vindies_6.RA3Replay
Size: 284.25k
Number of downloads: 13
Player Name Side Team
|m8s|Vindies 0
dimon0000000* 0
Attached File vindies_7.RA3Replay
Size: 350.49k
Number of downloads: 12
Player Name Side Team
dimon0000000* 0
|m8s|Vindies 0




This post has been edited by Inspector RaGe: Feb 10 2018, 17:02 PM

Posts: 731

Game: Red Alert 3


+
# 7Inspector RaGe Feb 10 2018, 16:58 PM
QUOTE(Andrey_96 @ Feb 10 2018, 11:52 AM) *

To zokker,just off aggressive mod wink.gif


We can have this discussion on a new thread.

Posts: 6,694

Clan: m8s

Game: Red Alert 3


+
# 8Inspector RaGe Feb 10 2018, 17:05 PM
Congratz to Dimon for taking this one down.

Sheriff AA and zokker will be playing their 3rd place match later on this week.

Posts: 6,694

Clan: m8s

Game: Red Alert 3


+
# 9Sheriff AA Feb 17 2018, 21:08 PM
AA 3-1 zokker for 3rd place






Original upload


Attached File 3rd_zokker_g1.RA3Replay
Size: 386.67k
Number of downloads: 8
Player Name Side Team
cWc.zokker13 0
[m8s]DogKnows* 0


Attached File 3rd_zokker_g2.RA3Replay
Size: 419.39k
Number of downloads: 8
Player Name Side Team
[m8s]DogKnows* 0
cWc.zokker13 0


Attached File 3rd_zokker_g3.RA3Replay
Size: 201.71k
Number of downloads: 8
Player Name Side Team
cWc.zokker13 0
[m8s]DogKnows* 0


Attached File 3rd_zokker_g4.RA3Replay
Size: 305.15k
Number of downloads: 9
Player Name Side Team
[m8s]DogKnows* 0
cWc.zokker13 0




This post has been edited by Inspector RaGe: Feb 18 2018, 01:44 AM

Posts: 8,213

Clan: m8s

Game: Red Alert 3


+
# 10Constable Chris Feb 20 2018, 15:02 PM
QUOTE(zokker13 @ Feb 10 2018, 14:46 PM) *

For simpletons:
If you put PKs in a building with aggressive stance and then a wall I build around that, it can happen that the PKs continue to shoot (for whatever reason). If you think this is a bug, fair. If you think this is forced bug exploiting you are an idiot.
This behavior can be observed _especially_ on BBB. Wall in anything, infantry will still be able to attack.



After having carefully watched the replay and seeing exactly what happened, I can confirm 100% that this is indeed a bug.

Simply speaking, walls are supposed to provide cover from everything. Exceptions being tier 3 defenses, aircraft, artillery, and yuriko .

Anything other than that should not be allowed to attack anything behind walls, be it aggressive stance or not . (It's not like aggressive stance magically grants units x-ray vision and allows them to see what's behind a wall and attack it) .


Posts: 1,737

Clan: H2O

Game: Red Alert 3


+
# 11GBHmichael Feb 20 2018, 19:53 PM
QUOTE(zokker13 @ Feb 10 2018, 14:46 PM) *

This behavior can be observed _especially_ on BBB. Wall in anything, infantry will still be able to attack.


Infantry in particularly tall buildings can shoot over walls - like the ones by the side refineries on BBB. Normal-sized garrisons (Like the one in this instance) cannot shoot over walls in this way through normal use.

Posts: 830

Game: Red Alert 3


+
# 12lol_maker Apr 3 2018, 19:52 PM
Dimon is absolutely right. There was a huge discussion about it when I was a referee on Gamereplays. Letting Pks shoot through the wall is a clear bug abuse. They do that from a house if they are on aggressive mode. I order to stop them u have to take them out and put them on non aggressive mode and put back again.

Posts: 2,058

Game: Red Alert 3


+
# 13psychoturtle Apr 5 2018, 02:50 AM
GBH is right, in tall buildings, infantry can shoot over walls. I'm pretty sure that was intentionally implemented by EA. And even if shooting through walls in smaller buildings is a bug(pretty sure it is), it's not a banned exploit.

Posts: 2,436

Game: Red Alert 3


+

1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)