Explore GameReplays...

CNC Zero Hour

thebestpro - Intentional Disconnect - Invalid

Reply to this topic Start new topic
# 1-Riwik^ Jan 10 2022, 20:09 PM
He announced his pro "move" ahead of time, then went ahead and dc'ed.


Attached thumbnail(s)
Attached Image Attached Image Attached Image Attached Image

Attached File(s)
Attached File thebestpro_the_best_dc.rep
Size: 261.66k
Number of downloads: 6
Player Name Side Team
BATMAN007 1
thebestpro 2
GRS1 3
Kreml 1
WTF-FFS 2
Riwik* 3

Posts: 293

Game: CNC Zero Hour


+
# 2-NickName Jan 18 2022, 15:31 PM
Ready for more can be interpret different ways, and based on this I cannot conclude that the accused player disconnected on purpose.

Since this is was in a 2v2v2 match, points cannot be given. I set this accusation to invalid, as there is not enough evidence of this being an intentional disconnect.

Posts: 8,995

Game: CNC Zero Hour


+
# 3-Riwik^ Jan 18 2022, 22:59 PM
QUOTE(-NickName @ Jan 18 2022, 15:31 PM) *

Ready for more can be interpret different ways, and based on this I cannot conclude that the accused player disconnected on purpose.

Since this is was in a 2v2v2 match, points cannot be given. I set this accusation to invalid, as there is not enough evidence of this being an intentional disconnect.


Read again - he said "ready for move" not ready for "more"...

Posts: 293

Game: CNC Zero Hour


+
# 4-NickName Jan 18 2022, 23:50 PM
QUOTE(-Riwik^ @ Jan 18 2022, 22:59 PM) *

Read again - he said "ready for move" not ready for "more"...


Ah, misread that.

Posts: 8,995

Game: CNC Zero Hour


+
# 5Serby Jan 18 2022, 23:55 PM
Jokes aside I read few latest accusations and they are literally funny. Even he said move or more nothing is leading to conviction.

Posts: 8,787

Clan: Brothers of War

Game: CNC Zero Hour


+
# 6-Riwik^ Jan 19 2022, 19:31 PM
QUOTE(-NickName @ Jan 18 2022, 23:50 PM) *

Ah, misread that.


Not even a stern warning? You've changed man...

Posts: 293

Game: CNC Zero Hour


+
# 7-NickName Jan 19 2022, 20:18 PM
QUOTE(-Riwik^ @ Jan 19 2022, 19:31 PM) *

Not even a stern warning? You've changed man...


For making me misread what he wrote? Can't blame him for that, perhaps a different colour would be better though.

Posts: 8,995

Game: CNC Zero Hour


+
# 8Serby Jan 19 2022, 20:18 PM
QUOTE(-Riwik^ @ Jan 19 2022, 20:31 PM) *

Not even a stern warning? You've changed man...

For what?

Posts: 8,787

Clan: Brothers of War

Game: CNC Zero Hour


+
# 9-Riwik^ Jan 19 2022, 20:40 PM
QUOTE(Serby @ Jan 19 2022, 20:18 PM) *

For what?


For quite obviously announcing he was about to DC, and then DC'ing. Nickname's misreading of the text is important because it isn't nearly as open to interpretation as he initially suggested - it's pretty obvious what he is threatening to do given the circumstances.

Or are we committed to performing mental gymnastics here to avoid doing anything?

Posts: 293

Game: CNC Zero Hour


+
# 10-NickName Jan 19 2022, 20:48 PM
QUOTE(-Riwik^ @ Jan 19 2022, 20:40 PM) *

For quite obviously announcing he was about to DC, and then DC'ing. Nickname's misreading of the text is important because it isn't nearly as open to interpretation as he initially suggested - it's pretty obvious what he is threatening to do given the circumstances.

Or are we committed to performing mental gymnastics here to avoid doing anything?


Ready for move can mean different things. Maybe he had an anthrax bomb coming.

Announcing a disconnect has to be way more specific than this. You can read more about it here.

Posts: 8,995

Game: CNC Zero Hour


+
# 11fastAiR Jan 20 2022, 00:24 AM
To really scrutinise this evidence, you would have to find in the favour of Riwik unless the accused came up with reasonable explanations. In the scenario of repeated DC, "are you ready for more" can be taken as a comment in context, and adds credibility to this accusation.

Based on that, and in addition to the DC in a losing position, makes the accused guilty, unless proven innocent.

Posts: 8,099

Game: CNC Zero Hour


+
# 12nAy4oK_AHaHcu Jan 22 2022, 15:56 PM
It always puzzles me that some players openly announce their intentions of disconnecting or mismatching. Just do so quietly and avoid any punishment due to current ruleset.

In our above case, it is rather clear that the perpetrator meant exactly the act of disconnecting (possibly, due to not being fluent in English, they were unable to explicitly express themselves).

This post has been edited by nAy4oK_AHaHcu: Jan 22 2022, 16:01 PM

Posts: 268

Game: CNC Zero Hour


+
# 13fastAiR Feb 2 2022, 00:10 AM
QUOTE(nAy4oK_AHaHcu @ Jan 22 2022, 15:56 PM) *

It always puzzles me that some players openly announce their intentions of disconnecting or mismatching. Just do so quietly and avoid any punishment due to current ruleset.

In our above case, it is rather clear that the perpetrator meant exactly the act of disconnecting (possibly, due to not being fluent in English, they were unable to explicitly express themselves).



hi, and yea

you put things so pefectly, Leikeze would be proud

Posts: 8,099

Game: CNC Zero Hour


+

1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)