Explore GameReplays...

Rise of the Witch King

Factions of the middle earth

Men of the West
0.00% (0)
OP
0.00% (0)
UP
100.00% (15)
They are fine
Elves
13.33% (2)
OP
26.67% (4)
UP
60.00% (9)
They are fine
Dwarves
13.33% (2)
OP
26.67% (4)
UP
60.00% (9)
They are fine
Isengard
0.00% (0)
OP
26.67% (4)
UP
73.33% (11)
They are fine
Mordor
53.33% (8)
OP
0.00% (0)
UP
46.67% (7)
They are fine
Goblins
53.33% (8)
OP
6.67% (1)
UP
40.00% (6)
They are fine
Angmar
20.00% (3)
OP
20.00% (3)
UP
60.00% (9)
They are fine

Total Votes: 105
Guests cannot vote 
Reply to this topic Start new topic
# 1Ultimategladia Aug 25 2017, 12:24 PM
I saw this topic in 2.01, so I decided to see what people think in 2.02 at the moment.

Posts: 201

Game: Rise of the Witch King


+
# 2brabox Aug 25 2017, 13:16 PM
I don't think you can answer this easily anymore. It all comes down to game mode, MUs and other factors like onhost/offhost.

For 1v1 fords 1k I'd say:
Goblins and onhost Elf are a bit OP.
I find Isen hard to play vs micro-intensive opponents with cavalry.

For large games, Mordor is OP and Dwarves UP.

Posts: 4,127

Game: Rise of the Witchking 2.01


+
# 3Ultimategladia Aug 25 2017, 17:39 PM
QUOTE(brabox @ Aug 25 2017, 14:16 PM) *

I don't think you can answer this easily anymore. It all comes down to game mode, MUs and other factors like onhost/offhost.

For 1v1 fords 1k I'd say:
Goblins and onhost Elf are a bit OP.
I find Isen hard to play vs micro-intensive opponents with cavalry.

For large games, Mordor is OP and Dwarves UP.

No better way to answer than asking people what they think about.
I am asking in general, how they see the units, heroes, powers, upgrades... Not depending the map or specific situations

Posts: 201

Game: Rise of the Witch King


+
# 4brabox Aug 25 2017, 17:44 PM
QUOTE(Ultimategladia @ Aug 25 2017, 18:39 PM) *

No better way to answer than asking people what they think about.
I am asking in general, how they see the units, heroes, powers, upgrades... Not depending the map or specific situations

We'd have done a pretty bad job if there were still factions OP or UP "in general". I certainly wouldn't be able to answer your question.

Posts: 4,127

Game: Rise of the Witchking 2.01


+
# 5Ultimategladia Nov 12 2017, 19:07 PM
QUOTE(brabox @ Aug 25 2017, 18:44 PM) *

We'd have done a pretty bad job if there were still factions OP or UP "in general". I certainly wouldn't be able to answer your question.

Well, you see, people think Mordor and Gobs are OP

Posts: 201

Game: Rise of the Witch King


+
# 6DeeZ Daryl Nov 13 2017, 07:55 AM
QUOTE(Ultimategladia @ Nov 12 2017, 19:07 PM) *

Well, you see, people think Mordor and Gobs are OP

"People" = 5/6 dudes?

Posts: 318

Game: Battle for Middle Earth 2


+
# 7Ultimategladia Nov 13 2017, 09:13 AM
QUOTE(DeeZ Daryl @ Nov 13 2017, 08:55 AM) *

"People" = 5/6 dudes?

ofc

Posts: 201

Game: Rise of the Witch King


+
# 8Mako Nov 13 2017, 10:46 AM
Ultimate 2 things:
1) these pools are intresting becasue they give a feedback from community BUT that doesn't mean they are right.
2) That 6 votes can came from soals, Cam, JR, Folcred, and our king Muadd or from pepita, hunter, sep, pitbull, mako. How much of them came from ppl that spammed over than 1k game playing competitvie 1v1?
It is more intresting if ppl that vote can give motivations.

Said that i think that atm Isengard is pretty good but all are impression. We don't have enough replays to judge it.

Posts: 4,423

Game: Rise of the Witch King


+
# 9Ultimategladia Nov 13 2017, 11:04 AM
QUOTE(Mako @ Nov 13 2017, 11:46 AM) *

Ultimate 2 things:
1) these pools are intresting becasue they give a feedback from community BUT that doesn't mean they are right.

It was only a joke, 8 player votes are nothing
QUOTE(Mako @ Nov 13 2017, 11:46 AM) *
2)
That 6 votes can came from soals, Cam, JR, Folcred, and our king Muadd or from pepita, hunter, sep, pitbull, mako. How much of them came from ppl that spammed over than 1k game playing competitvie 1v1?
It is more intresting if ppl that vote can give motivations.

That is the reason why I made this post long ago (even before there was the idea of 7.0.0 beta I think)
QUOTE(Mako @ Nov 13 2017, 11:46 AM) *

Said that i think that atm Isengard is pretty good but all are impression. We don't have enough replays to judge it.

Vote then, this is how this post will grow and more people will vote and we will know a standard general opinion of what players think

Posts: 201

Game: Rise of the Witch King


+
# 10brabox Nov 13 2017, 11:28 AM
QUOTE(Ultimategladia @ Nov 12 2017, 20:07 PM) *
Well, you see, people think Mordor and Gobs are OP

That seems a premature conclusion. 9 people voted. 44% of them said Mordor is fine.
Also, you started this poll in April so we have no idea how many of these votes are based on v6 and how many on v7 (especially important regarding Goblins' OPness).

Furthermore, you think this proves anything in regards to my remark that no single faction is clearly OP in general? People who vote Mordor is OP most likely play bigger games. People who vote Goblins are OP most likely play smaller games.

As I said: it all boils down to game modes, match-ups and play styles. Put me up against any of those 2v2+ weaklings who don't understand economy and only focus on army composition. I play Angmar and they play Mordor and we'll see how OP Mordor really is.

Posts: 4,127

Game: Rise of the Witchking 2.01


+
# 11Ultimategladia Nov 13 2017, 14:41 PM
QUOTE(brabox @ Nov 13 2017, 12:28 PM) *

That seems a premature conclusion. 9 people voted. 44% of them said Mordor is fine.
Also, you started this poll in April so we have no idea how many of these votes are based on v6 and how many on v7 (especially important regarding Goblins' OPness).

Furthermore, you think this proves anything in regards to my remark that no single faction is clearly OP in general? People who vote Mordor is OP most likely play bigger games. People who vote Goblins are OP most likely play smaller games.

As I said: it all boils down to game modes, match-ups and play styles. Put me up against any of those 2v2+ weaklings who don't understand economy and only focus on army composition. I play Angmar and they play Mordor and we'll see how OP Mordor really is.

As I said to mako, it was a joke because my poll has not been seen by almost anyone

Posts: 201

Game: Rise of the Witch King


+

1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)