Explore GameReplays...

Company of Heroes

puma > vet3 rifles

#11GoodToGo  May 1 2020, 14:56 PM -
Replays: 9 Game:
I saw the replay and I am very curious why the volks, grens and pios moved towards the snipers around 45 minute mark? Pios were going to repair but the other squads? They just sat around doing nothing.
#12S1mply  May 1 2020, 16:16 PM -
Replays: 168
Awards:
QUOTE(TheSkYisTheLimiT @ Apr 26 2020, 10:01 AM)


Ohh yea some people cry about stream sniping but they do not put any delay 😂😂😂

stream sniping is fine, every streamer wants to stream good games. From your comment i get you are fine with stream CHEATING if your opponent doesnt have a delay. I feel just sorry for everyone who feels the need to do that, but it doesnt suprise me very much in your case.
#13Volkl  Sep 22 2022, 22:05 PM -
Replays: 0 Game:
Agreed that all the squads moving past the 88 and exposing the US snipers just before the 48 minute mark looked suspicious. But cannot write off the possibility that this was just a coincidence. As a whole, the Wehr movements were rational and usually reactional.

Not sure if stream-sniping occurred here or not (that seems to be the suggestion). I am sure that stream-sniping is fundamentally no different than maphacking. I.E. it is cheating. That top ranked players would excuse stream-sniping is not only disappointing but calls into question their player integrity and their predisposition to using a maphack.
#14Volkl  Nov 19 2023, 12:16 PM -
Replays: 0 Game:
I am no longer feeling nearly as charitable with my original assessment after reviewing this replay again several times, along with several other of Lucky Stilet's matches.

At 47:25 his volks squad, gren squad, and pio squad all congregate and freeze. They remain there until 47:38 despite no other engagements occurring. They show zero curiosity to investigate what happened to the sherman, engineer squad, and rifle squad just south of them engaged less than a minute ago. Two damaged pumas nearby and yet the pio squad idles. Then when they began their march at 47:38 it is on a perfect intercept trajectory with two cloaked and unrevealed enemy snipers. When revealed seconds later, the snipers are quickly eliminated by the pumas. It's unclear where these squads were headed. They remain stagnant after revealing the snipers, and the pio squad does not start repairing the puma next to it. Why it passed by the first puma without stopping to repair is a mystery too.

Near 58:00 Stilet has four pumas in the enemy base. He fails to concentrate fire on one building at a time which most experts will do. The Tank Depot is at about 25% health at 58:19 but inexplicably all pumas suddenly head south to the motor pool. At that exact moment a 57 AT gun rolled off of the assembly line but in the fog of war.

Also curious. The puma charge on the base at 44:00 could not have been timed better to intercept a moving 57 AT gun. And the subsequent raid at 46:00 to decrew the 105 howitzer was the very first opportunity when it had zero defenses.


Lucky Stilet Rails & Metal match:
https://www.gamereplays.org/companyofheroes...s&id=363817

Lucky Stilet Duclair match:
https://www.gamereplays.org/companyofheroes...s&id=360752
This post has been edited by Volkl: Nov 19 2023, 23:14 PM
#15LuckyStilet  Nov 24 2023, 03:22 AM -
Replays: 411
Awards:
QUOTE(Volkl @ Nov 19 2023, 12:16 PM)
I am no longer feeling nearly as charitable with my original assessment after reviewing this replay again several times, along with several other of Lucky Stilet's matches.

At 47:25 his volks squad, gren squad, and pio squad all congregate and freeze. They remain there until 47:38 despite no other engagements occurring. They show zero curiosity to investigate what happened to the sherman, engineer squad, and rifle squad just south of them engaged less than a minute ago. Two damaged pumas nearby and yet the pio squad idles. Then when they began their march at 47:38 it is on a perfect intercept trajectory with two cloaked and unrevealed enemy snipers. When revealed seconds later, the snipers are quickly eliminated by the pumas. It's unclear where these squads were headed. They remain stagnant after revealing the snipers, and the pio squad does not start repairing the puma next to it. Why it passed by the first puma without stopping to repair is a mystery too.

Near 58:00 Stilet has four pumas in the enemy base. He fails to concentrate fire on one building at a time which most experts will do. The Tank Depot is at about 25% health at 58:19 but inexplicably all pumas suddenly head south to the motor pool. At that exact moment a 57 AT gun rolled off of the assembly line but in the fog of war.

Also curious. The puma charge on the base at 44:00 could not have been timed better to intercept a moving 57 AT gun. And the subsequent raid at 46:00 to decrew the 105 howitzer was the very first opportunity when it had zero defenses.


Lucky Stilet Rails & Metal match:
https://www.gamereplays.org/companyofheroes...s&id=363817

Lucky Stilet Duclair match:
https://www.gamereplays.org/companyofheroes...s&id=360752


Your 1v1? Why you even bother yourself to do it? Roll replay to 47:25 again biggrin.gif and click unit sniped icon plz. Will refutations follow below?
#16Volkl  Nov 24 2023, 03:52 AM -
Replays: 0 Game:
QUOTE(LuckyStilet @ Today, 19:22 PM)


Your 1v1? Why you even bother yourself to do it? Roll replay to 47:25 again biggrin.gif and click unit sniped icon plz. Will refutations follow below?


Nope, unit snipe icon doesn't justify the actions. The last Unit Sniped icon disappears a full 10 seconds before your march begins, and tracking the sniper progress and momentum puts him due south of your leftmost puma. Try again.

Also, why do you not finish off the 25% health tank depot and instead suddenly race to the motorpool where an unrevealed 57 had just rolled off the assembly line? If motorpool had been the priority from the start why did you wait until that moment to seek to destroy it?
#17Volkl  Nov 26 2023, 06:09 AM -
Replays: 0 Game:
QUOTE(Arashenstein @ Apr 25 2020, 13:09 PM)
I know LuckyStilet for over 10 years from COH, this guy was one of those few top players that never ever cheated or did anything suspicious.

I believe you are sincere but, let's just bookmark this quote, shall we.
This post has been edited by Volkl: Nov 26 2023, 06:13 AM
#18djw2104  Nov 26 2023, 15:09 PM -

Replays: 8 Game:
Awards:
Bumping a replay from 2020 to highlight possible anomolies only leads to the usual accusation / counter-accusation bouncing back and forth.

Should anything untoward have occurred back then it will, at this current time, not be retro looked at.

Discussion is locked.
Reply to Comment