You're not wrong with your analysis entirely. But you miss two important points: 1. The game had only been out for half a year when this replay was uploaded. It's clear that the ins and outs of the game weren't as well understood as they are now. 2. Guys like JuanRing were experienced RTS players so their tempo and general strategy (=not specifically rotwk-related) skills were really good. Therefore, despite your analytic knowledge, you'd get defeated easily by this player you call a 'med'.
A more humble attitude when discussing our old experts would be appreciated.
Don't forget that this replay is history to 2.02 players as well. It makes complete sense that 2.02 players are responding to your comments here.
You're not wrong with your analysis entirely. But you miss two important points: 1. The game had only been out for half a year when this replay was uploaded. It's clear that the ins and outs of the game weren't as well understood as they are now. 2. Guys like JuanRing were experienced RTS players so their tempo and general strategy (=not specifically rotwk-related) skills were really good. Therefore, despite your analytic knowledge, you'd get defeated easily by this player you call a 'med'.
A more humble attitude when discussing our old experts would be appreciated.
Don't forget that this replay is history to 2.02 players as well. It makes complete sense that 2.02 players are responding to your comments here.
Yes at that point back then, some of the clanwars players had to get better until they reach good skill level, because rotwk is different from gameplay in relation to bfme 2.
So surely you can not say that, because this player isn't active in rotwk anymore and despite of that, he lost most of his skill due to inactivity.
And: I already haave proclaimed, that i wont write long ratings/rewiews to old replays here anymore. From until now and a few days ago, I will simply wub a replay, if I liked it and if not i dont wub.
This post has been edited by Johann Tilly: Jun 1 2017, 20:07 PM
1. The game had only been out for half a year when this replay was uploaded. It's clear that the ins and outs of the game weren't as well understood as they are now.
2. Guys like JuanRing were experienced RTS players so their tempo and general strategy (=not specifically rotwk-related) skills were really good. Therefore, despite your analytic knowledge, you'd get defeated easily by this player you call a 'med'.
A more humble attitude when discussing our old experts would be appreciated.
Don't forget that this replay is history to 2.02 players as well. It makes complete sense that 2.02 players are responding to your comments here.