Explore GameReplays...

Supreme Commander

Sir_Loui Vs CoW_Scaffy

#11Hysteria  Apr 17 2007, 15:50 PM -
Replays: 8 Game:
QUOTE(LuVA @ Apr 17 2007, 12:33 PM) *

4/10 you guys did so many mistakes

I was expecting alot more from two top 30 players


Watch 90% of top 30 matches and see as many mistakes.. Only the top 5 will consistantly offer the kind of match you appear to be looking for?
Also you seem to be forgetting that the rating we give games is based on entertainment factor as well as skill. Although the two usually go hand in hand a game can get a high rating without showing brilliant skill levels simply by being great fun to watch.. I feel this match was good fun to watch and deserving of more than 4/10.

If you want more information on the rating system please refer to http://www.gamereplays.org/community/index...howtopic=198243 taking special note of the paragraph prior to the rating system section.

/my 2p


#12LuVA  Apr 17 2007, 18:22 PM -
Replays: 3 Game:
It isnt entertaining when you get annoyed by watching
#13AncientSion  Apr 17 2007, 18:51 PM -
Replays: 16 Game:
Awards:
QUOTE(LuVA @ Apr 17 2007, 20:22 PM) *

It isnt entertaining when you get annoyed by watching


Maybe other people have different opinions about the matter ?
#14Sir_Loui  Apr 17 2007, 19:47 PM -
Replays: 12 Game:
Awards:
QUOTE(LuVA @ Apr 17 2007, 20:22 PM) *

It isnt entertaining when you get annoyed by watching



luva luva luva... as i said before i have now watched the replay and im aware of the HUGE amount of mistakes going on but i still think its a entertaining replay. Anyway i do think it deserves a 6/10 a score which i think is right for this game. I mean even though we both do a lot of mistakes we show some potential i believe. Enough said about this replay i think and i would want all of ya to see my new upload...
IT IS MY REVANSCH VS SCAFFY ON SAME MAP AND ALSO ON RANKED^^
#15LuVA  Apr 17 2007, 21:24 PM -
Replays: 3 Game:
QUOTE(AncientSion @ Apr 17 2007, 18:51 PM) *

Maybe other people have different opinions about the matter ?


Thats why I rated it 4/10

I never said that people werent allowed to vote whatever they want, i didnt say anything about other people so i dont know why you wrote that at all.


"4-5: This is the average range, the players knew what they were doing, although they still made mistakes (sometimes some big ones that cost them the game)."

so a 4 fits nicely into what i said


"6-7: The play was pretty good with only a few mistakes and no major ones that gave away the game"

There were some game deciding mistakes so it cant be rated here
This post has been edited by LuVA: Apr 17 2007, 21:33 PM
Reply to Comment