I must really say: AnAgA, the game was already won, i think, after rush failed. WK must decide the game and WK was a good step, as Gandy cant kill him with one Istari, but then...ähm...err...there happened something, which should not have happened and which was a bit lucky imo...the Witchking died...and...died...and...died. Hm, i think very good played on Gondor side (also sometimes bit lucky: 2 times one single horse out of 5 survived and that really saved u ur ***^^) and also good played on Mordor side...definitely silver replay, maybe gold.
Hehe, i can only recommend to watch this replay! Its err, strange.^^