Battle for Middle Earth

Some obvious mistakes from both sides but was a fun game. Our dbl roh vs. their dbl gon. Rating would be nice .

Didn't exactly know what to do (I knew the strategy), but when to get things kind of. Probably a bad choice in getting the middle before ups but hey.

[attachmentid=236112]

Rating by: AniMatoR
Starting positions:
Team 4 - Left
Team 1 - Right

Overview:

A fun game with a LOT of action, the game sort of went round in circles, 1 team would win that battle and the opposing team would win the next battle so this made it fun to watch. The problem with the Gondors was the lack of LD and siege resulting in an easier win for the Rohans. Also there was some good teamwork shown from both sides. The fact that rohan managed to get middle, eomer LD, very ranked up combos, VERY ranked up rohirrim with GC and overall more LD won them the game.

Also the start of this game, normally its double Gondor owning double rohan early game and getting land on their mills so knights own when they come out, all the pressure was on the gondor side at the start and this was not good

On a final note anyone who wants to learn double Rohan vs double Gondor should watch this replay as they showed good strat (their own Eomer strat worked) and good decisions.

Team 4 - Double Rohan

So 1 went rohirrim and the other rushed out Eomer. This proved an effective start as normally 1 would go combos and be stuck in his base but this rohan got eomer and got the LD and that extra LD is always good vs gondor. Your game overall was good but your first attack on gondor base was a totally mess! Aragorn didnt use blademaster to take out TG or push away Gandalf and rohirrim had no LD when fighting their combos. You didnt melee any of his combos and with all that LD you could have owned them all.

Your next attacks proved to be successful and in the end your army was way too powerful and you even got aod which was great, they now had now had no chance and you did quite well as a team.

• More use of Aragorn's Blademaster.
• Trample combos then melee them.
• Keep LD together with rohirrim more often, dont have them fighting ranked up combos in big battles with no LD.
• Split up combos whilst fighting more, gandy's blast hit more than 2 combos 1 time.
• Don't cashfloat, buy legolas if you have a lot of money.
• Finish off all units, dont let any enemy units return home! (1 soldier from a rank 8 combo got away).
• When you have ents, try to use 1 or 2 of them to walk over their combos, they will die instantly.

Team 1 - Double Gondor

Your start was bad, they were on your side non-stop in the beginning and you lost farms. Vs double rohan you always have to land their mill so when your horses come out you own their farm without their rohirrim being able to do anything to save it. You didnt get middle and lacked lacked 2 things, boromirs LD and fire trebs. On your first attack at the middle you only had faramir's LD meaning you were inevitably gonna lose that fight as they had eomers LD too, when theo comes you immediately shoot at him, dont worry about eomer so much. He would have actually died if you had boromir's 60% more damage LD there I realise you lost the warg on your side but you still had both trolls, faramir was still gonna be level 5 from 1 troll and boromir could have been used to take the other.

Anyway on their first attack at your base you guys did great and had good teamwork, there was treb back up from inside the base and gandys blast was good and along with his LD, although you had heal and should not have lost him so easily. In the next few battles there was no way out, they were too powerful, the rank of their units, their LD was all too much and if you cant keep up with the LD and not have fire trebs vs double rohan there isnt a single chance in winning the game Some good teamwork though

• Land rohan mills at the start.
• When you see unarmored combos, trample them non-stop.
• Boromir LD is very important, get it.
• Trample combos with horses then blast with gandalf and run.
• Fire trebs is a good weapon vs double rohan, its important to get them.
• DO NOT SEND OUT SOLDIERS, you made 1 rohan that much closer to ents, use your trebs to kill your own soldiers!!!

Overall Rating: 7
RoTW C

someone show me how to do a 'rating' and ill do this one seeing as its a 2v2 rep and its part of my job

Review By: Your name

Starting Positions:
Left - Faction or name / faction or name
Right - " "

Team One / faction, faction / names w.e you want

A somewhat brief paragraph of the major things they need to improve on.

Team Two / faction, faction / names w.e you want

Another paragrapgh, smae as the first for what this team needs to improve.

Overall Rating: 1-10

omg wtf tbh this replay was long, oh dear..i should have looked at the replay size before saying anything about rating this

anyway i should do it so ill try to finish it within a day or 2

its not that long maia, i know the size looks big but it didnt seem like the game took forever, but maybe thats cause i was playing in it...but whatever thanks for looking at it

*Thrandypwned*

rate it button dont work for me ffs!!!

W00t. Ty for review mate .

no problem it was actually a good game to watch

ill see if i can do a double shoutcast with segway on it

Rate it button worked for you apparently, this shows up on the activity list under your name.