Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[review]Rohan Vs Mordor

#1BcVcB  Aug 19 2007, 13:02 PM -

Replays: 46 Game:
Awards:
I was playing with mordor, he's a rank 500 Rohan. Review please.
This post has been edited by BcVcB: Aug 19 2007, 13:03 PM
#2Tams  Aug 21 2007, 14:12 PM -
Unofficial Review By: Tams

Starting positions:
Mordor/BcVcB - Top
Rohan/Gendor - Bottom

Overview:
In all honesty the game was a little too defensive to make it entertaining. Both sides had good starts to the game, Mordor defending his mills, while Rohan tryed to win them. Mid to late game Rohan had complete Map controll which in the end gave him the win.


Mordor/BcVcB

PP route: Eye -> T/L -> Industry -> Darkness

You had a decent start to the game defending your mills well. Try sending laborers to other mills next time. You left the two closest settlements for a while which hurt your economy. After your good start it all went downhill really. Your Eco wasn't up to your style of play, resulting in a late troll cage. Even when your troll cage was up, you had 1600R and still waited 20 seconds or so before building your troll. Try working on your macro more. You camped mid-late game which basically made you lose, giving the Rohan map control. Once you had 5-6 trolls with Drummer LD you should have proceded forward to his base, instead of waiting on W/K. He had only a few Rohirrim and HA's with Theo. All in all, your camping decided the game mate. Keep an eye on your units also, you lost a few trolls due to bad micro.

Improvements:

* Try harrasing more with your Orcs. You defended your mills only.
* Send Laborer to other mills and buy extra Laborers.
* Your trolls were miles away from your Drummers... work on your micro.
* You cashfloated a little, work on your Macromanagement.
* Harrass more, you let him have map control for mid-late game.



Rohan/Gendor

PP route: Draft -> Heal -> Land -> Anduril -> Cloud Break

Great start getting alot of settlements near and far of base. Good fast Cav which give you the edge early game. There is one thing that is bothering me though- Why did you get 3 wells in base? I thought multiple wells were only good for getting Elves? Some good creeping going on here with good micro of Rohirrim. You could have ended the game alot earlier though. The Mordor was camping with three trolls while you had Theo, 3 HA's with Fire and two batts of Rohhirm. You cash floated ALOT this game when you could have got faster heroes. You had 12000 at one point yet decided not to get any of the support heroes, which would have helped alot. A nice attack of base at the end gave you the win.

Improvements:

* Watch your resources. You cashfloated alot.
* Try harrasing more mid- game. You had the edge yet decided to sit back.


Highlight of the match:

The end attack by Rohan, resulting in the Mordor base being destroyed.

Entertainment Rating: 3
Overall Rating: 3


I just thought I'd help out wink.gif
This post has been edited by Tams: Aug 21 2007, 14:14 PM
#3BcVcB  Aug 30 2007, 11:38 AM -

Replays: 46 Game:
Awards:
Thanks for the review m8 banana.gif , it really helps me. thumb.gif
#4Tams  Aug 31 2007, 18:18 PM -
Np mate wink.gif
#5MR_METHOD  Sep 1 2007, 06:58 AM -
Replays: 2 Game:
Good review Tams....

and good game guys..

BcVcB, try to play agressive game next time.. good luck for the next game.. thumb.gif
Reply to Comment