Dunharrow is probably the easiest map for Mordor vs Gondor, so I believed in a little chance for me to win this one. I'm a real noob with Mordor and I'll have to learn a lot more about it. I normally always play with Gondor. This is the first time that I ask for a review for a match with me playing a faction different from Gondor. I managed to kill his Gandi when he attacked me the first time. Later I built up an army of trolls at my outpost and prepared an attack on his base (while he had not much to defend since I killed Fara, some archers and his archery range in a rush before). Unfortunately he DCed (I'll report him in a minute) before I could execute the 2nd rush. But there's still much to review and improve about my play imo. Thx in advance
Review by: Bravo
Starting Positions: BcMordor/Morodor - North latentacion/Gondor - South
Overview: This is a pretty onesided game actually Gondor did nothing but built some Knights and few combo's wasting everything to morodor trolls. Morodor had a decent start with good map control so he decided to go for two troll cages and spamed trolls and rushed to Gondor base and striped off his walls and Finished his entire army. Before the next attack by mordor Gondor quit the game and Mordor wins
BcMordor/Morodor: You started the game well had few lumber mills with workers filled and also managed to defend it. When you are building a resource building very near to warg pit before killing the wargs go for slaughter house insted of lumbermill because wargs line of sight is increased in 1.03 so it will start destoying your mills once your worker is out. Also be careful in selecting your build slots atlest have 3 slaughter house in a row so that you will be able to use industry on all the three, Your build order and power point progression was good. Avoid cash floating you had 1550 when you start building your troll cage. Your idea of going for 2 troll cages was good. But i would also prefer going for a siege works in the outpost because you had good economy at that time. You could have also gone for Witchking or atleast a nazgul before your first attack. On the whole you played a good game and you deserved to win this game.
Mistakes / Things to improve:
• Build Slaughter house in a row. • Avoid cash floating. • Build Nazgul or WK when you have a good economy. • Go for outposts when you have few trolls to defend it.
latentacion/Gondor: You had a really bad start you actually lack in stratergy, Plz watch some silver and golden replays to improve your game. All the best
Overall rating:3
Here is a replay for a good Mordor vs Gondor game (Second link)
This post has been edited by bravo_psg: Aug 17 2007, 05:46 AM
Halo BcVcB i watched your replay, and i feel that you owned him at the start of the game itself. He really played bad with Gondor actually he lacks in stratergy his build orders were bad and he used his units in bad way. You had a good start and you spamed Trolls with Drumer trolls at that time he had only 2 archer combo's(combo's not necessory against morodor) archers placed in skirmish formation will be better against morodor. He brought his gandy in a late game. So you deserved to win this game.
This post has been edited by bravo_psg: Aug 7 2007, 04:37 AM
What a pity, I really thought I would have beaten a medium Gondor player. I also watched replay now. His stables came way too early, he had no inside Farm, barracks was unnecessery, too many statues before gandi, blades too early... I can be really happy that he didn't rush my base imo. But there are probably as many mistakes about my gameplay. Some of them I noticed already (e.g. I used bad build spots in base so that I couldn't use Industry on 3 buildings). A review will really help me.
What a pity, I really thought I would have beaten a medium Gondor player. I also watched replay now. His stables came way too early, he had no inside Farm, barracks was unnecessery, too many statues before gandi, blades too early... I can be really happy that he didn't rush my base imo. But there are probably as many mistakes about my gameplay. Some of them I noticed already (e.g. I used bad build spots in base so that I couldn't use Industry on 3 buildings). A review will really help me.
Ok i will do it tomorrow. Though i am not an RR, this being a very below average performance from one side i will do it so other RR's will not waste time on this.
I feel this map is just horrible especially versus FoL, I alsoo experience mayor difficulties on this map, just because its so friggin big and horses are everywhere. Could you explain me why you think its rather good for mordor v GOndor?
Ok i will do it tomorrow. Though i am not an RR, this being a very below average performance from one side i will do it so other RR's will not waste time on this.
forgotten?
This post has been edited by bravo_psg: Aug 14 2007, 17:48 PM
Dunharrow is probably the easiest map for Mordor vs Gondor, so I believed in a little chance for me to win this one. I'm a real noob with Mordor and I'll have to learn a lot more about it. I normally always play with Gondor. This is the first time that I ask for a review for a match with me playing a faction different from Gondor.
I managed to kill his Gandi when he attacked me the first time. Later I built up an army of trolls at my outpost and prepared an attack on his base (while he had not much to defend since I killed Fara, some archers and his archery range in a rush before). Unfortunately he DCed (I'll report him in a minute) before I could execute the 2nd rush. But there's still much to review and improve about my play imo.
Thx in advance
Review by: Bravo
Starting Positions:
BcMordor/Morodor - North
latentacion/Gondor - South
Overview:
This is a pretty onesided game actually Gondor did nothing but built some Knights and few combo's wasting everything to morodor trolls. Morodor had a decent start with good map control so he decided to go for two troll cages and spamed trolls and rushed to Gondor base and striped off his walls and Finished his entire army. Before the next attack by mordor Gondor quit the game and Mordor wins
BcMordor/Morodor:
You started the game well had few lumber mills with workers filled and also managed to defend it. When you are building a resource building very near to warg pit before killing the wargs go for slaughter house insted of lumbermill because wargs line of sight is increased in 1.03 so it will start destoying your mills once your worker is out. Also be careful in selecting your build slots atlest have 3 slaughter house in a row so that you will be able to use industry on all the three, Your build order and power point progression was good. Avoid cash floating you had 1550 when you start building your troll cage. Your idea of going for 2 troll cages was good. But i would also prefer going for a siege works in the outpost because you had good economy at that time. You could have also gone for Witchking or atleast a nazgul before your first attack. On the whole you played a good game and you deserved to win this game.
Mistakes / Things to improve:
latentacion/Gondor:
You had a really bad start you actually lack in stratergy, Plz watch some silver and golden replays to improve your game.
All the best
Overall rating:3
Here is a replay for a good Mordor vs Gondor game (Second link)