Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[Review] Incredible Isen vs Gondor

#1whersmyspacebar  May 28 2007, 11:11 AM -
Awards:
I played a very long game vs gondor, he had incredeble micro. I dominated the hole game till gtw came out i even had lurtz yet i just couldnt kill him it was redicules there was a few times where i came close 2 killing him yet he survived then in 1 last big dig at killing him, both balrog and AotD came out to decide the last siege. Enjoy.
#2Birdy  May 28 2007, 18:38 PM -
Replays: 4 Game:
I'll review this one biggrin.gif
#3Birdy  May 29 2007, 12:43 PM -
Replays: 4 Game:
Review by: IHateWinning

Starting positions:
S|lverKn|ght - North
BACKDOORBANDIT3 - South

Overview:

A normal game in which shows how important it is for Isengard to be aggressive, to creep quickly, and to obtain map control. But against a Gondor who only makes knights and Gandalf.

S|lverKn|ght - Gondor

Some nice fast knights in early game. But only knights vs Isengard won't do the job. The game would be better if you made some else instead of just alot of knights and Gandalf.
You were still lucky in the first 2 waves of Isen. He could had finished you much earlyer.
But thx to your nice Gandalf skilles you won the first 2 waves. Third wave was too much for you.

How to Improve:
  • Stay on your own land and specially if Isen used warchant. (If you use land when he used warchant, the warchant is cancelled but only on your land.
  • Creep faster with your knights.
  • Get faster knightshield vs pikes.
  • Don't make so many knights vs pikes. Some combos + leadership + trebs would be better.
  • Don't use land when your not gonna fight on it. It's a waste.


BACKDOORBANDIT3 - Isengard

Excellent game from you in begin & mid game. But when you started to attack Gondor you made some big mistakes.
You should made some combos + pikes. And should aim faster for Gandalf. You lost alot of units because of lame using.
But after the third wave you finally finished him with some help of Balrog. And you were still lucky because he just had AOD.

How to Improve:
  • Change your pikes faster from formation. You could had killed more knights.
  • Don't place land before you attack.
  • You could had finshed him much faster.
  • Be more carefull for Gandalf. You trained him to rank 9¾.
  • Some big cashfloating.
  • Summon Balrog not next to your own army.

Overall Rating: 3
#4Jase  May 29 2007, 18:22 PM -
Replays: 33 Game:
Awards:
hmm, when he played me he had horrrible micro wacko.gif
#5whersmyspacebar  May 29 2007, 22:42 PM -
Awards:
Can i ask y it got a 3??? And y not do a larger review? And y not mention anything i did that was good like killing gandalf and 2 eagles with lurtz 1 crossbow and a mine.
#6DunedainStriker  May 30 2007, 00:16 AM -
He is an applicant, this review will be looked at for his feedback and your concerns will be addressed.
#7whersmyspacebar  May 30 2007, 01:16 AM -
Awards:
Ok cool,
#8Ang3lic  May 30 2007, 04:14 AM -

Replays: 5 Game:
Awards:
QUOTE(^S1N1ST3R^ @ May 29 2007, 14:22 PM) *

hmm, when he played me he had horrrible micro wacko.gif

he did okay vs me on fanghorn (with mordor) if thats possible lol but is it really possible to kill gtw w/ 1 lurtz + xbow and whats even more amazing that you killed 2 eagles as well.
Definitly gona take a look
#9whersmyspacebar  May 30 2007, 04:40 AM -
Awards:
And a mine what i did was i knew he had GTW running around so i made lurtz attack a farm so it looked like he was alone the i crippled ran bomb next 2 gandy and got the xbows 2 finish him but he also used eagles and the eagles got blown up by the bomb 2.
This post has been edited by whersmyspacebar: May 30 2007, 04:42 AM
#10Birdy  May 30 2007, 09:52 AM -
Replays: 4 Game:
Cause it was just knights vs pikes all the game.
Not really a good battle untill you attacked his base.
And you still needed 3 waves before he died.

That's why -> 3
Reply to Comment