Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] Platy vs S[]uare

#1PlaTy  Jan 2 2007, 10:44 AM -
Awards:
Hello ppl

I had this game today vs a mate of mine, It was a ffg so i picked isen and he gondor, both to practise. It turned out pretty nice.

But i still need help, i couldnt crack him
Any comments appreaciated. Review also pls

Thanks in advance

~Platy~ happy.gif
This post has been edited by Platysoma: Jan 2 2007, 10:47 AM
#2PlaTy  Jan 3 2007, 18:08 PM -
Awards:
Bump
#3LiGhT`  Jan 3 2007, 18:24 PM -
Awards:
He was my mentee, what do you expect?! biggrin.gif
#4Madow  Jan 3 2007, 18:35 PM -
Replays: 12 Game:
Awards:
smile.gif i can help with this MU, will start right away
#5Madow  Jan 3 2007, 23:23 PM -
Replays: 12 Game:
Awards:
IPB Image

|S8P|S[]uAr3

Strategy

2 farm start > 2 soldier rush (mid) > knights > HS/FB rush > combo's > heroes > trebuchets
Tops
  • Creeped 4 of the lairs
  • Nice horsemicro, outmicroïng and killing pikes
  • Good HS rush, took a chunk out of Isen's base, also destroyed armory
  • Took mapcontrol after defeating Isen's army
Tips
  • Idle units in base, use those combo's
  • Didn't try to take mapcontrol back during mid-game
Comments

Strangely i could not find many mistakes. I think the only reason that you were not in advantage untill the end was because your harassment was not good. You were annoying with your horses and took down mills alot but you let your opponent just take it back right away so he could keep mapcontroll. Use the combo's you had or get faramir or boromir earlier to kill the pikes at the mills.

Rate
6

IPB Image

Platysoma

Strategy

pit/mills start > uruk spam > pike spam > wargs > heroes > upgrades > combo's > balista's
Tops
  • Took down both Gondor farms EG
  • Blocked middle with pikes, delays horse harassment and HS rush
  • Sarumans powers were used as often as possible
  • Mapcontroll
  • Sold towers before they got destroyed
  • Ballrog took down entire castle, to bad the game was allready decided
Tips
  • Lost xbow early, this stopped your creeping. Use them for creeping where the knights are unlikely to come EG
  • You don't need 1 pike per mill to stop knight-harassment, wargs are more effective. Get them earlier
  • Should have gotten banners earlier for the half warg battalions
  • Started making berzerkers for harassment in late game. Use your wargs instead
  • Industry could have been used more often
  • Micro during attack on opponents castle was poor, you lost alot saruman and alot of units, but didn't really destroy anything
Comments

You made multiple mistakes but still you were in advantage. This changed after your attack on the Gondor base: you just couldn't take out his army of combo's and heroes. In advance, don't enter his base with his army inside but wait for him to come out, then beat him with your combo's, balista's, wargs and sarumans powers. If he doesn't come out, just destroy some wall segments with balistas and maybe some buildings before you engage his army, then you should be able to finish him.

Rate
5

Entertainment
5

Overal
5
This post has been edited by Madow: Jan 4 2007, 00:55 AM
#6LiGhT`  Jan 3 2007, 23:37 PM -
Awards:
Nice review madow, but add players names in, otherwise your screwed when it comes to mirrors laugh.gif
#7Madow  Jan 4 2007, 00:56 AM -
Replays: 12 Game:
Awards:
ok, i edited some mistakes and the names in
#8PlaTy  Jan 4 2007, 01:07 AM -
Awards:
Thanks alot madow very eorigional those tops and tips, sounds better then pros n cons imo ^^

Yes i already had a bad feeling when going it, it felt too narrow, ill kill some walls first next time tongue.gif

@ light true

in the game i saw like three times things, of which i said, LiGhT tought you well pirate.gif e.g. meleeing pikes with knights
This post has been edited by Platysoma: Jan 4 2007, 01:11 AM
#9Madow  Jan 4 2007, 01:16 AM -
Replays: 12 Game:
Awards:
yes he did that like mad 0wn3d.gif gave him 2 battalions of level 10 horses, unkillable for wargs...

btw dutch what are you doing awake at this hour?
#10TheFatOFTheLanD  Jan 4 2007, 09:17 AM -
Replays: 3 Game:
Awards:
yea light tought me well wub.gif esspecially to make sure you have an outpost in late game in case of pro balrog micro thumb.gif was a fun game and like Madow said i need to work on my harasment and keep those farms, thanks for the tips smile.gif
Reply to Comment